• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

PIC S3 Ships & Tech

Yeah, i could really imagine that. Perhaps the strenght level of the force field determines how much pain it can inflict on prisoners trying to get out.
or how much energy can go through you if you try to short it and accidentally get to become ground.

But what kind of injuries could a force field cause? Burns perhaps?
i’d day electric shock.

By the way…an access panel INSIDE the cell? Really, Starfleet?!
 
Good point. Thought before that Q was simply pissed and annoyed that he couldn't leave the cell. But i doubt that the effect (at least in TNG) is actually like an electrical shock. He wasn't convulsing or pushed back by the field.

Still wondering about what it really does to a body and what it feels like.

I have this headcanon idea about what it feels like but I'm not sure how easy it is to explain. I imagine they feel very different to a solid surface and at the lowest setting a forcefield has that sort of "slippery" feeling of trying to force to alike magnetic poles together, and then it goes down a spectrum past "pleasantly tingly" through "pins and needles" to "agonising cramps and muscle spasms", depending on the power of the forcefield and how long you're in contact with it.
 
By the way…an access panel INSIDE the cell? Really, Starfleet?!
He didn't open an access panel, he planted a device.
S6KUAI3.png
 
A “warp governor“ is an intentional throwback to the NX design that clearly inspired the Eleos
Drexer's diagrams for the Stargazer and Titan-A label the blue domes (that some people have referred to as 'impulse crystals' on older ships) as warp governors as well.

I suppose next week we'll see if they do the phasers right. Or wrong. Or both.
There is no wrong ways to do phasers. But we see a beam come from the rear of the Titan (or another ship using the same nacelle design) in a trailer.
 
Last edited:
Drexer's diagrams for the Stargazer and Titan-A label the blue domes (that some people have referred to as 'impulse crystals' on older ships) as warp governors as well.

Ooh. Does that mean that the refit Constitution-class's "impulse defection crystal" was really the evolution of the NX-01's warp field governor? It was never confirmed to be anything to do with the impulse engine on screen, after all. Interesting.
 
Ooh. Does that mean that the refit Constitution-class's "impulse defection crystal" was really the evolution of the NX-01's warp field governor? It was never confirmed to be anything to do with the impulse engine on screen, after all. Interesting.
Yeah, Impulse Deflection Crystal I think came Mr. Scott's Guide to the Enterprise. Probably because it's attached to the impulse engine on both the Miranda and Connie.
 
Yeah, Impulse Deflection Crystal I think came Mr. Scott's Guide to the Enterprise. Probably because it's attached to the impulse engine on both the Miranda and Connie.

It probably goes back to Probert. It's not just part of the impulse assembly on the Enterprise, it's also the upper terminus of the intermix shaft.We never saw enough of the Reliant's engineering system (except that it has one deck of vertical tube) to know if, say, it zig-zags to connect it's deflection crystal to the similar feature on the bottom of the ship.

Yep, it was Probert's name for the dome (though spelled "deflector crystal"). His idea was probably the same way Johnson described it, though, that it's "deflecting" warp power into the impulse drive. Still, no reason it can't be retconned (enough people call the "intermix shaft" the "warp core," for instance).

Also…What happened to checking that your prisoners don’t have tools to escape?

It'd be a pretty lousy forcefield-lockpick if it couldn't be concealed from a search.
 
Yet, we have devices now that can locate devices on a person's body, like our x-ray machines and the airport gates that people have to walk through. I would imagine that a more sophisticated, advanced culture would have even better means of detecting devices.
 
Of course Starfleet has an awful record on this topic. See when they let a whole disassembled destructor through, for example…
 
Yet, we have devices now that can locate devices on a person's body, like our x-ray machines and the airport gates that people have to walk through. I would imagine that a more sophisticated, advanced culture would have even better means of detecting devices.
That would make for boring stories.
 
Yeah, i could really imagine that. Perhaps the strenght level of the force field determines how much pain it can inflict on prisoners trying to get out.

But what kind of injuries could a force field cause? Burns perhaps? But in this case if Dominion force fields use a similar technology, what makes them so deadly if you just touch them, if we rule out causing electrical shocks?

The DS9 ep Civil Defense had Dax get her hands burnt when a small forcefield went off to stop her tampering with the leftover counter-insurgency program that they'd unwittingly tripped.

Later that same ep, Kira makes reference to the Cardassian "neutralization emitters" having been removed because "we prefer our forcefields to be non-lethal".
 
The DS9 ep Civil Defense had Dax get her hands burnt when a small forcefield went off to stop her tampering with the leftover counter-insurgency program that they'd unwittingly tripped.

Later that same ep, Kira makes reference to the Cardassian "neutralization emitters" having been removed because "we prefer our forcefields to be non-lethal".

Interesting. Had totally forgotten the comment about the neutralization emitters. Now i wonder about what they are (and do) and even more about the physics and characteristics of force fields and how they work.
 
Yet, we have devices now that can locate devices on a person's body, like our x-ray machines and the airport gates that people have to walk through. I would imagine that a more sophisticated, advanced culture would have even better means of detecting devices.
Since when has Starfleet Security ever worked? If it serves the drama of the story it will fail or succeed. Star Trek security tech does not keep up with what is actually possible with their level of technology.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top