• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Personal Behavior - Online and IRL

So in that regard, the context I function in can vary as much within this forum as it does within any broader domain of life.

Yes I agree, that's very much the point I was trying to make.

RoJo said:
I think there's a huge difference between being a different person in different contexts and simply behaving differently in different contexts.

How so?

The way we interpret who a person is IS very much through their behaviour in the contexts we encounter them. YOU may feel it's consistent, but OTHERS may possibly see a very different person in those different settings. For those who compartmentalise their lives quite heavily, the differences are likely to be more pronounced. I would agree that for those that who compartmentalise much less, the difference is likely to be less marked.

I guess the more fundamental point I'm making is that the locus of control of who were are perceived as is often in others as much as it is ourselves, and some contexts drive the movement of the locus further away from ourselves, while others move it closer. Our response to this pressure also affects the differing perceptions.
 
The article linked in the original post strikes me as extremely technology-phobic.

It does, but these pop-psychology articles often seem to incite this fear: A vague and over-generalising directional pressure against modern technology, that feels almost religious by the constancy of it's tone. I'm not sure why that is.
 
I try to be very polite here, the way I am with strangers IRL... but with my friends I'm completely rude and annoying :lol:
 
Holdfast, I think the article points out that some people have difficulty compartmentalizing.

Spots, I can relate in that I tend to rant more online than offline, and that doesn't necessarily mean I'm a different person.

Litmus, I understand the article may sound somewhat biased. I dont totally agree with it.
 
Last edited:
So in that regard, the context I function in can vary as much within this forum as it does within any broader domain of life.

Yes I agree, that's very much the point I was trying to make.

RoJo said:
I think there's a huge difference between being a different person in different contexts and simply behaving differently in different contexts.

How so?

The way we interpret who a person is IS very much through their behaviour in the contexts we encounter them. YOU may feel it's consistent, but OTHERS may possibly see a very different person in those different settings. For those who compartmentalise their lives quite heavily, the differences are likely to be more pronounced. I would agree that for those that who compartmentalise much less, the difference is likely to be less marked.
That must be it, then. I don't really compartmentalize much of anything. Of course, I haven't need to. I've been a bartender for the last 5 years. I can pretty much act the same way I do around my friends and get away with it. Many of my coworkers are also my friends, and some I would even consider family. And all of my work friends have been around my non-work friends and have become friends (or at least good acquaintances) with each other. So really, everywhere I go I'm surrounded by friends, regardless of the setting or what I'm going.

The only time you might see a different side of me is when I'm driving. I get angry. :lol:

It's possible that with my new job (which I start tomorrow:eek: ) that I will need to be a different person at work, but we'll see.
 
I am off board as I am online. Of course, conversing with me in person is going to be different because you'd be able to hear the tone of my voice, interpret body language, and see my facial expressions.
 
"the five forces that assert themselves online: aggression, narcissism, grandiosity, immaturity and impulsivity."

Wow, online me in a nutshell
 
The article linked in the original post strikes me as extremely technology-phobic.

It does, but these pop-psychology articles often seem to incite this fear: A vague and over-generalising directional pressure against modern technology, that feels almost religious by the constancy of it's tone. I'm not sure why that is.
This was my impression as well. Society is always headed downhill, precipitated by something or other.

Someone else mentioned it, but the internet has its own contexts. The same person might behave differently if writing a personal blog, commenting on facebook, commenting on a NYTimes article, just like they would if talking to a friend on the phone vs. a potential employer. It's hardly unique to the medium.
 
I’m definitely WYSIWYG. I have a hard enough time being me and trying to be a better me, I wouldn’t be able to keep track of two of me.
 
I'm the same person wherever I go, allowing for context.

I get a kick out of all these Mr Hydes who must let their hidden anger and frustrations run rampant on the Internet. I'm just the opposite. On the Internet, especially the smaller boards I belong to, I get to relax and be as nice as I want to be. :rommie:
 
Obviously, IRL I would never argue insignificant minutae of Star Trek like I do here. It would be silly.

I guess I'm a more outgoing online, but that's the charm of the internet. IRL there's a feeling out proccess (I said out:borg:) where you figure out what sort of interaction is appropriate with whomever you're talking to, if they'll get your sense of humour etc. that doesn't really exist in cyberspace. The internet is so big and all-at-once, you don't have to change to fit in - just find another site if no-one gets you.

Plus, it's a lot easier to ignore people you don't like online.
 
IRL I'm more introverted and shy. Online I can let go a little because of the anonymity but I try not to say anything or act in a way that I wouldn't IRL.
 
I'm also a WYSIWYG person where online communities is concerned. In fact, I can relax more here than I often can in RL. At my last job I was told several times that I was too blunt and forceful despite the fact that I was reigning myself in all the time, to the point where I decided that I would never please the boss (about whom I shall remain polite and say nothing :borg:). The only place I really let rip is in my LiveJournal blog, but that's heavily friendslocked. For the rest I usually behave myself online but have fun as well. I don't tend to be nasty to people IRL and I do the same online.
 
I'm a bit more introvert in real life. At times I don't really know how to act or what to say, and thus opt to not say anything. I constantly try and improve that part of me, but otherwise I'm pretty much as I am online.
 
We're all, obviously, more open and friendly here than IRL because we have all become friends over the years. It's like having a thousand close personal friends whom you can really open up to.
 
Obviously, IRL I would never argue insignificant minutae of Star Trek like I do here. It would be silly.

Uh ... uh ... uh ....

**Torn between running away and hiding, and standing proudly and acknowledging**

:lol: The only RL Trekkies I know are my husband and daughter, and my daughter. So, yes, I'm here for the Trek talk as well as the social gubbins, but only because I hardly have anyone with whom to discuss it in RL, silly or no.
 
I flirt less in real life, but only because real life people, for some strange reason, expect people to follow through.

The art of casual flirting had previously been lost, but with the advent of the internet, it is coming back.

I'm pretty safe with the guys that I flirt with IRL ~ 70yr old golfers do not expect too much ~ they're quite happy with a little banter and a slice of cake :D

But I agree, there are some nice guys to flirt with on here ;)

I sincerely doubt that anyone is the same IRL and online. In fact, I'd go so far as to suggest if they were, that would speak of quite a rigid personality. After all, people are not the same in different RL contexts (work, home, socially, with partners, etc) depending on the setting and the people around them, so why should we expect them to be the same online? Equally, I would not expect people to be the same on all the different sites they visit. They will present a different set of facets everywhere they go.

Of course, there's likely to be an underlying core consistency, assuming there's not an attempt at deliberate deceit. But the idea that one can be the same online and offline strikes me as just as implausible as the idea that one can be same in all the different offline contexts we function in.

I don't think I'm that different online or IRL. Different social situations do sometimes require an adjustment of attitude ~

I try to be very polite here, the way I am with strangers IRL... but with my friends I'm completely rude and annoying :lol:

Exactly! Your friends know you and love you so you can drop some social constraints.

I think I'm a little more amiable in RL. My colder side tends to come out a lot more online. I guess because I make less effort to be interesting/funny/sexy, especially here. Probably because I don't know most of you all that well. There are some people you just don't want to encourage.

So, I'd say, yes, I definitely have an online personality that differs somewhat from my RL personality. Some parts of myself are suppressed, others magnified... it's not the easiest medium through which to find the true measure of a person... although you can have certain hints over time.

As to the obsessive shopping, gambling, bullying... erm, nope, I don't think that's me, that's probably only a very small percentage of internet users, and they probably have pre-existing psychological problems, rather than something that is inspired by the internet alone.

True.
An Officer, you have always come over as interesting/funny/ and caring (see how I changed sexy there but that's just to me ;)) but I agree it's easier to be slightly more removed online ~ a RL smile goes a long way :)


I'm the same person wherever I go, allowing for context.

I get a kick out of all these Mr Hydes who must let their hidden anger and frustrations run rampant on the Internet. I'm just the opposite. On the Internet, especially the smaller boards I belong to, I get to relax and be as nice as I want to be. :rommie:

Very much so.
I think I'm quite similar online and IRL. I have the same views and ideas but I'm happier demonstrating them in real life.

I understand how text can be misconstrued and I do not want to offend anyone. I'm aware that what I type, maybe not well thought through but will be there for all to see, so I think before I type.

IRL I'm much better at getting my ideas and feelings across with body language, facial expressions and the ability to read other's reactions immediately.
Apparently I can be quite scary (:klingon:) ~ I have a very good 'don't f*** with me face' which on occasion is handy, but I can swiftly read the situation and adjust IRL.

A true IRL smile and laugh, and not forgetting a little touch of the arm can never be recreated online.
 
An Officer, you have always come over as interesting/funny/ and caring (see how I changed sexy there but that's just to me ;)) but I agree it's easier to be slightly more removed online ~ a RL smile goes a long way :)

You mean I've never gotten sexy with you, or you just don't find me sexy? :hugegrin:

Don't make me go Right Said Fred on your ass now! :p

To stay on topic, I should probably add that I'm a little more vain in RL. :rommie:
 
I'm the same online and in the real world... and in the real world I'm the same person with absolutely everybody I interact with... it's a source of pride.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top