• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

People Still Believe The Planet Is Flat

I was reading on CNN that some people still consider the word to be flat. I don't want to be the obvious no brainer here but isn't the moon round? If the Earth was flat then wouldnt the Moon relative to the Earth appear like a rectangle? The same with the Sun as well. I mean really can those people in the past let alone in our modern time even think that the Earth was flat back then and is flat now. If its not obvious back then and now that the Earth is round as well as the rest of the planets then why do bikes have found wheels? Why do wooden ships have round steering wheels and why when driving a car with a round steering wheel does the car go around in circles. I mean seriously are people that box headed? Its just absolutely incredible. Those people should be Believe It or Not.....I mean its right there. The moon...its round...Our eyeballs are round....twist twist twist...
no more oxygen for those types of people. The sun is round...
if you are trying to convince people the Earth is round you are doing a terrible job.
 
I don't prescribe to the idea that anyone still sincerely believes the Earth is flat, so any generalizations about this is just manufactured prejudice or baseless accusation against someone, some group or groups of people. But if anyone does still sincerely believe the Earth is flat, it's magical-thinking bible-thumping fundamentalist creationists who believe the Earth is 6000 years old. i.e., Republicans.
 
Last edited:
if you are trying to convince people the Earth is round you are doing a terrible job.
I don't know. Woolly thinking might convince them where reason failed, or maybe it would get their baloney detectors going (which might ultimately have the same effect).
 
If the Earth was flat then wouldnt the Moon relative to the Earth appear like a rectangle? The same with the Sun as well.

Neither one has four right angles. If they were just flat round discs, then they would appear ellipsoid to varying degrees depending on the viewing angle, but never rectangular. :wtf:

Kor
 
Neither one has four right angles. If they were just flat round discs, then they would appear ellipsoid to varying degrees depending on the viewing angle, but never rectangular. :wtf:

Kor

remark - A disk viewed edge-on is a line segment, which is a degenerate rectangle having at least one side of zero length.
 
I don't prescribe to the idea that anyone still sincerely believes the Earth is flat, so any generalizations about this is just manufactured prejudice or baseless accusation against someone, some group or groups of people. But if anyone does still sincerely believe the Earth is flat, it's magical-thinking bible-thumping fundamentalist creationists who believe the Earth is 6000 years old. i.e., Republicans.

I wish I could say that discovering someone believed the world was flat would surprise me. I WISH I could say that. However, I have become inured to the inveterate stupidity of my fellow Americans. :sigh:
 
Sadly, I don't think the OP realizes his thread got moved to misc from sci/tech. He probably thinks it was closed and will never return to it to enlighten us further on the subject.
 
Round steering wheels would still make sense on a flat Earth, and as others have mentioned a disk is both flat and round; Flat Earthers tend to believe either that the Earth is disk-shaped and with an edge that you can fall off, or that it is infinite in all directions.

With that being said, with regards to comparing the Moon and the Earth:
A pretty central part of many Flat Earthers' beliefs is that the Earth is unique in the cosmos. Based on what I've seen, a belief in a Flat Earth all but requires that you believe in a creator deity, who set the Earth apart from all other things in the Cosmos. Many (but certainly not all) Flat Earthers accept that the Moon and/or Sun and/or planets are spherical, but to them that is not relevant, because the bodies which inhabit the celestial dome are of a completely different nature than the world on which we live.

I am certainly not advocating this view, but it's something that needs to be remembered when discussing Flat Earthism.
 
I was reading on CNN that some people still consider the word to be flat. I don't want to be the obvious no brainer here but isn't the moon round? If the Earth was flat then wouldnt the Moon relative to the Earth appear like a rectangle? The same with the Sun as well. I mean really can those people in the past let alone in our modern time even think that the Earth was flat back then and is flat now. If its not obvious back then and now that the Earth is round as well as the rest of the planets then why do bikes have found wheels? Why do wooden ships have round steering wheels and why when driving a car with a round steering wheel does the car go around in circles. I mean seriously are people that box headed? Its just absolutely incredible. Those people should be Believe It or Not.....I mean its right there. The moon...its round...Our eyeballs are round....twist twist twist...
no more oxygen for those types of people. The sun is round...
iTSQk7t.gif
 
Even some basic googling turns up just how few member the Flat Earth Society has had over the years. It's one of those things that gets a lot of press but we're talking a very, very small number of people.
 
Yeah, I am far more disturbed by the fact that over 40% of Americans believe God created humans in our present form around 10,000 years ago. That's millions and millions of people.
 
Anyone else amused by the fact that Magellan just weighed in on the topic? I mean, if you wanted someone to debunk the Flat Earth nonsense, he'd be your guy, right? :lol:
 
This is a fun watch. He also mentions Poe's Law which might be a valid point.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Yeah, I am far more disturbed by the fact that over 40% of Americans believe God created humans in our present form around 10,000 years ago. That's millions and millions of people.


I thought they said 6000 years ago the Earth was made. That's an aweful short length of time isn't it?
 
Round steering wheels would still make sense on a flat Earth, and as others have mentioned a disk is both flat and round; Flat Earthers tend to believe either that the Earth is disk-shaped and with an edge that you can fall off, or that it is infinite in all directions.

With that being said, with regards to comparing the Moon and the Earth:
A pretty central part of many Flat Earthers' beliefs is that the Earth is unique in the cosmos. Based on what I've seen, a belief in a Flat Earth all but requires that you believe in a creator deity, who set the Earth apart from all other things in the Cosmos. Many (but certainly not all) Flat Earthers accept that the Moon and/or Sun and/or planets are spherical, but to them that is not relevant, because the bodies which inhabit the celestial dome are of a completely different nature than the world on which we live.

I am certainly not advocating this view, but it's something that needs to be remembered when discussing Flat Earthism.
I thought we were all riding around on top of a giant turtle? Didn't I hear that someplace? :confused:

;)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top