Have you started the Tolkien book yet? Is it worth buying?
I flipped through it at work this afternoon, and I've read CJRT's introduction.
It's... an interesting book. Of all the posthumous Tolkien books, this is the book that will undoubtedly have the lowest percentage of buyers who actually read it. (Of course, I still haven't finished
The Children of Hurin yet.)
Now, I'm absolutely fascinated by the Volsung Saga to the point where I very nearly named some cats Fafnir and Sigurd. I've read the Volsung Saga, the
Nibelungenlied, and William Morris'
Sigurd the Volsung. I have Wagner's Ring Cycle on CD. (I haven't bought either of the graphic novel adapations, either the Roy Thomas/Gil Kane adaptation from DC or the P. Craig Russell adaptation from Dark Horse, but if I wanted to read them my brother has both.) Suffice it to say, this is a subject that interests me, so there was never any doubt that I'd buy this.
But that's the problem. This is a specialist's book. It's presented in a way that will attract a casual buyer, but I don't see why anyone without an interest in the Volsung Saga would find this of interest. The poetry is written in an archaic alliterative style. There are extensive notes. There is a long lecture that Tolkien delivered in the 1920's. If the subject interests you, this is a book you'll probably want. If your experience of Tolkien is
The Hobbit,
The Lord of the Rings, and
The Silmarillion, this is not your book and will never, ever
be your book.
For what it's worth, Borders had a metric ton of
Sigurd and Gudrun on their front display when I walked in. Clearly, they're hopeful that people will buy the book, not knowing what they're buying.