• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Oh Oh..

Commodore Oh - Romulan or Vulcan?


  • Total voters
    146
I am inclined to think Oh a Vulcan with at least some pro-Romulab sympathies. Her exchange with Rizzo makes the most sense that way, I think.

All this said, who can say that she and Rizzo might not both be members of the same conspiracy, dating to a point predating the proto-Romulans,' departure.
 
In light of her exchange with Rizzo, identifying Oh as a Vulcan with some pro-Romulan sympathies makes the most sense to me.

That said, who knows but that Oh might actually be a member of a Zhat Vash that traces its ancestry back to Vulcan before the proto-Romulans' departure?
 
In light of her exchange with Rizzo, identifying Oh as a Vulcan with some pro-Romulan sympathies makes the most sense to me.

That said, who knows but that Oh might actually be a member of a Zhat Vash that traces its ancestry back to Vulcan before the proto-Romulans' departure?
That would seem to be at odds with her fear of having her cover blown.
 
A Romulan placed high in Starfleet Command would be a more creative and original idea. If we're going to have another sinister flag officer let's have them be of an outside, adversarial species that's been undercover for a number of months or even years. "Conspiracy(TNG)" works in part because those Admirals and other officers were infected by the parasite aliens and still maintained a normal appearance on the outside.
 
hwzrx6e.jpg

hwzrx6e.jpg

8EqiAzW.jpg
 
Somewhat but they have diverged slightly.
What if the lie goes deeper.

What if the Romulans and Vulcans are actually both sub species, a lot depends on exactly when this AI event happened, before, during or after the schism that caused the Romulans to leave.
 
Why would a Vulcan be undercover in Starfleet?

There are other organizations and communities that she might be undercover for. If the Zhat Vash extends to Vulcan, it could be that.

Alternatively, she is an operative for the Mintakans. (No one suspected them.)
 
There are other organizations and communities that she might be undercover for. If the Zhat Vash extends to Vulcan, it could be that.

Alternatively, she is an operative for the Mintakans. (No one suspected them.)
If Vulcans knew about Zhat Vash, so would rest of Federation and so would Picard. No way would a Vulcan (with Romulan sympathies or not) be a member of Zhat Vash
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


where was I.. anyway Romulan. If it's pointy and calm = Vulcan
if its pointy and shifty = Romulan
if its pointy and glows and explodes = Vulcan Extremist
 
There are other organizations and communities that she might be undercover for. If the Zhat Vash extends to Vulcan, it could be that.

Alternatively, she is an operative for the Mintakans. (No one suspected them.)
Those organizations would be? Hopefully not ones recognized by the Vulcan Government
The Mintakans? A prewarp culture???
 
If Vulcans knew about Zhat Vash, so would rest of Federation and so would Picard. No way would a Vulcan (with Romulan sympathies or not) be a member of Zhat Vash

There are presumably billions of Vulcans, a species with a proven ability to keep secrets for centuries. Who can say but that some Vulcans might be very good keepers of an ancient secret?

Those organizations would be? Hopefully not ones recognized by the Vulcan Government
The Mintakans? A prewarp culture???

Exactly! No one would suspect them ... ;-)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top