• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New To Voyager

Most of the Maquis who outrank Kim, did not go to the Academy at all.

In the second episode Chakotay puffed his chest out that his people needed representation in the higher ranks so that they can get by without being relegated to some sort of subjugated servant class which really would not do.
 
Me too. Just because he was captain of his own ship... I think it should have been Tuvok. The other thing that bothered me was that in season 1 he was the first person Janeway went to for advice and then Chakotay took his place. It seemed odd considering how long they had known eachother. Just because Chakotay is First Officer suddenly he replaces Tuvok.
 
Well, Chakotay, arguments prevailing, was a Lieutenant Commander when Janeway welcomed him back in from the cold in Caretaker, but Tuvok was only a Lieutenant, even though the Wardrobe department frakked up his costume over the course of the first year, so that his pips were inconsistent and/or misleading, but we did see his promotion party in early season 4.

(A dinner party is in progress. The senior staff are at one long table in the centre, other crew at tables around the outside.)
PARIS: So we rigged the security console so that every time Tuvok accessed the internal sensors it would play a little message.
KIM: Live long and prosper.
PARIS: No matter what button he pushed, live long and prosper.
KIM: Naturally, no one was available to fix the malfunction
PARIS: So Tuvok had to stretch his Vulcan patience to the limit for the rest of the day.
KIM: I swear you could hear him grinding his teeth from across the bridge.
PARIS: And just when he thought it was over, when he went back to his quarters and ordered a cup of Vulcan tea, the replicator says
KIM: Live long and prosper!
JANEWAY: The first time I met Tuvok he dressed me down in front of three Starfleet admirals for failing to observe proper tactical procedures during my first command. My human ego took a little bruising, but, of course, he was right. (she stands.) Over the past nine years I've come to rely on his insightful and unfailingly logical advice. For outstanding services, Chief Tactical and Security Officer, it's my pleasure to grant you the rank of Lieutenant Commander. Congratulations, Tuvok.
TUVOK: Thank you, Captain. Had I known this commendation entailed ritual humiliation, I might have declined. However, I accept it with gratitude and will honour the responsibility that comes with it. During my three years on Voyager I have grown to respect a great many of you. Others I have learned to tolerate. As your Tactical Officer, I will continue to do my best to ensure a safe passage home. As a Vulcan, I share the following sentiment. Live long and prosper.
JANEWAY: Bravo. Well deserved.
Until season 4, Tuvok and Tom were the same rank.

Now, would you like to talk at length about Commander Josiah Bartlett?
 
There was a casualty list near the end that hilariously listed the cast of The West Wing as Officers aboard Voyager.

(President) Josiah Bartlett is the character played by Martin Sheen for 7 years on the West Wing.
 
Heard of it?

Sweet Zombie Jesus.

You're going to give me some excuse like "I was 5 years old when it stared" and then I'm going to run away crying.

The West Wing was invented by Aaron Sorkin who is responsible for The News Room Currently.

If you're not watching The News Room, then there's no hope for you.

:(
 
I've not watched either show, but I've not been able to receive broadcast signals since about 2003.

But back to Tuvok. How is it he was in Starfleet originally long enough to be an ensign, took about a 60 year sabbatical, rejoined the service, Janeway had worked with him nearly 7 years prior to the series, and is still only a lieutenant?
 
Tuvok was a teacher at Starfleet Academy.

Promotion would have meant that he would have had to do more admin and less teaching.

Rank is about how much staff you are allowed to command or/and expected to command.

You get more rank when it seems like you can do more, and (possibly) that you want to do more.

Is it possible that they kept trying to promote Tuvok but he turned them down constantly because it would have gotten in the way of his teaching?

Does Starfleet rank = Academic Rank?

Have we heard of a Commandant positioned/staffed in any other local than Starfleet Academy?

O'Brien, after DS9, was going to be teaching Engineering at Starfleet Academy despite being enlisted? Was he going to receive a massive promotion to teach cadets? Or was he going to leave the service?

Position supersedes rank.

O'Brien was made tactical officer aboard the Rutledge despite not being an officer, and as Chief of Operations he was able to boss around Lieutenants because he had operational command over his superiors within the niche that was his job, because he knew how to get stuff done better than they did. Outside of that niche, an ensign can order him to do starjumps for infinity.

Tuvok could have been the Dean of Archery Science and still only been a Lieutenant?

I assume that there are even civilians instructing at the academy who have no rank. Hell cadets have no rank. Do third year cadets have seniority (How Officers of the same rank measure their peckers) over first year cadets and therefore the ability to order infinity starjumps?

Doing your job doesn't get you promoted. Doing more than your job gets you promoted, but if it's possible that the academic rank is not the same as Starfleet rank, then it's redundant surely that you can be promoted for both at different rates along each command track because of your work as a teacher in a teaching institution is what it is.
 
Heard of it?

Sweet Zombie Jesus.

You're going to give me some excuse like "I was 5 years old when it stared" and then I'm going to run away crying.

The West Wing was invented by Aaron Sorkin who is responsible for The News Room Currently.

If you're not watching The News Room, then there's no hope for you.

:(

Actually I was 9 and no, not watching The News Room. I guess I should change my username to Hopeless now.
 
Grandma watched the West Wing because Charlie Sheen's dad was smoking hot in Apocalypse Now.

Grandma has good taste.

The first 8 minutes of the Newsroom Pilot where the lead has a hilarious meltdown in front of a few thousand iphone cameras.

[yt]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1zqOYBabXmA[/yt]
 
You should see her questionable tastes. how was I to know?! (bring out your violin and start playing)
 
Only one of my grandparents lived long enough to see television, and the only thing I know he watched was baseball games.
 
Where I come from, old people watched something called Coronation Street.

It sucked and still sucks.

3 nights a week for 54 years.

It's unstoppable.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top