I think it's bad that someone can just sit on a property doing nothing with it and rejects everyone who wants to work with it. If they don't want to do anything with it, they should give it away.
A corporation is highly unlikely to give anything away, but they could license it to someone they can trust to make money and not devalue the brand.
But not everyone can be trusted not to devalue the brand, according to how CBS defines value. And that may be the problem. Nobody with credibility has convinced them to let them take a swipe at utilizing the brand on TV. It's better to just sit on a brand rather than allow it to be devalued through mismanagement.
We've already seen the damage that can do. CBS doesn't want to have to dig itself out of a hole the way Abrams had to dig out of the hole the movies had gotten themselves into. Better to just start fresh someday, when someone presents a plan to CBS that the suits agree could work.
Has anyone with credibility even tried to convince CBS to let them play with their brand? They'd have to get past the reception desk first.
You mean CBS's Star Trek property? They are making movies with it right now. I mean to say, they are making money with it right now.
No,
Paramount's making movies and money. CBS isn't getting any pieces of that pie, are they?
Even if CBS were not getting a piece of the pie in dollar terms, they are getting free value from the brand- and awareness-building that JJ Abrams is doing. I'm sure CBS understands that's equivalent to money that they can tap into
if someone comes up with a workable plan for TV (and
if there's a workable plan to be had for TV - there's no guarantee that such a plan is even theoretically possible).
Anything is possible...
but my preference would be for a TOS/TMP era show.
That would be mine, too. It'd be cool to see that era get some new stories.
Let me extend the analogy by pointing out that the bike-owner would be foolish to even take money for renting the bike to you if they think you're just going to ride it off a cliff.
As a globally-recognized brand,
Star Trek is not a bike. It's more like a vintage Harley - a vehicle whose replacement value is far, far higher than the rental value. You can't buy another vintage Harley just like you can't buy another brand of
Star Trek's cachet, and you'd be a fool to just let anyone take it out for a ride.