• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers New Short Trek - Q&A

How Would You Rate This Short?


  • Total voters
    128
Name one set-piece, prop, or effect, in the history of the franchise, in which the design favored functional logic over aesthetic.

chair-tos.jpg
 
Why don’t modern producers get Spock? Abraham’s didn’t get him and neither do the discovery writers, Spock singing? Feeling envy? Number one singing sorry cute but I don’t buy it. The problem with discovery and all the short Treks are that they are fluff there’s no weight to them
 
Disco-Ent Bridge is the "true" bridge until the 2265 refit.
In Kurtzman-Trek, the Disco-Ent bridge is the true one period, until we're shown otherwise. Which doesn't bother me one bit. I've never liked the TOS aesthetic.

No, this makes no sense. The cage bridge is the main bridge and was redesigned and updated for a 21st century show with cinematic production values, that's all. It will not be "upgraded" into the TOS bridge just like Rebecca Romijn and Ethan Peck won't morph into Majel Barrett and Leonard Nimoy.
^ What this person said.

***

Also, can I just say yet again how much I would LOVE it if they announced a Pike series? Because I would.
 
Last edited:
I don’t think they under stand Number One either, cool, computer like, logical, second in command, I don’t get that from this number one but I did from the cage version
 
I could easily see Pre-TOS Spock like that based off how we saw him act in ‘The Cage’.

Something just happens to him between then and TOS that makes him more reserved, and act more Vulcan like.

Though even in TOS, stuff breaks through. Like in ‘Amok Time’ where he’s clearly very happy to see Kirk is still alive.
we're all but told the trauma of losing burnham to the far future is what does it.
 
In Kurtzman-Trek, the Disco-Ent bridge is the true one period, until we're shown otherwise. Which doesn't bother me one bit. I've never liked the TOS aesthetic.


^ What this person said.

***

Also, can I just say yet again how much I would LOVE it if they announced a Pike series? Because I would.
Well like I said, you're apparently on the camp that says that Kor, Kang and Koloth always had ridges (no Enterprise does not explain how they go from non ridged to ridged, those 3 Klingons weren't even born yet). I understand that point of view but it's not really my thing.
 
Why don’t modern producers get Spock? Abraham’s didn’t get him and neither do the discovery writers, Spock singing? Feeling envy? Number one singing sorry cute but I don’t buy it. The problem with discovery and all the short Treks are that they are fluff there’s no weight to them
Abrahams? Is that the tall bearded guy from The Savage Curtain? He was more into Kirk than Spock.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top