• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New *Animated* Short Trek: Ephraim & Dot

So which animated Short Trek is the winner?

  • Ephraim and Dot

    Votes: 57 78.1%
  • The Girl Who Made The Stars

    Votes: 6 8.2%
  • Neither, animated Short Treks are rubbish

    Votes: 10 13.7%

  • Total voters
    73
The star of this short was the musical score. Reimagined cues stitched together to make a quilt to keep TOS fans warm at heart.
This! I was going to post the exact same thing. From the Amok Time fight music, to Horner's Reliant riff, no Trek music was left unturned. That was a lot of fun, and also combined personalities from an array of Trek eras (Kirk Thatcher, Michael Giacchino, audio from TOS).

On, I also liked how Dot, after flying through the laundry loads of uniforms, ends up a red-shirt.

My one complaint: no one noticed the Tardigrade eggs in the refit process, where they basically replaced the engines and warp core with new ones? (oh yeah, and the 1701-A destroyed over Genesis).
 
Last edited:
It's another one of those factually inaccurate, dramatized accounts commissioned by Starfleet's Public Affairs Office of the type Admiral Kirk complains about in his preface to the TMP novelization.
Perfect way to cover this one!
 
I liked this one much much better then the other one. It was fun. I liked the animation too.

Stick-up-the-butt Trekkers will feel the stick they have had lodged in them for years grow. Whether that brings them euphoria or rage or despair or that fan-peculiar mix of all three i don't know and really don't care. It was great.
 
As for all the continuity errors, I don't think that "Ephraim & Dot" (btw, which was which?) was meant at all the be even remotely cannon. It was just meant to be a whimsical, very stylized cartoon, maybe like kids in the Trek universe would watch on space TV on whatever the 23rd century equivalent of Saturday morning is.

I mean, was that Tribble cereal commercial supposed to have really been made in the Trek universe? No. It was a little joke. (Either that, someone on the 23rd century equivalent of social media read about Edward's clusterf*ck and decided to make a funny 23rd century SpaceYoutube comedy video to mock him because, well...he was an idiot.)

Because, I mean, when the Enterprise was refit, I think somebody would have noticed those Tardigrade eggs, lol.
 
that's what I meant with the saucer being rotated oddly away from facing forward, and it's the most avoidable of all mistakes:shrug:

Maybe that's a capability of the Enterprise that we just never knew about before!?

It's helps cavitate the subspace something-or-other. :)
 
I was going to mention the sickbay window,but just did not type it.
If the animators had to model and render a refit 1701, as in the movies,why not create the TOS 1701 as we saw it in all other tv shows??
I suspect the point they are making is, "it doesn't matter".

Either that or some 25% conspiracy about them not having sold the rights to the design when Enterprise was cancelled.
 
It was fun, though what was with the placement of Sulu's shirtless swordplay after Kirk meets with Khan in sickbay? The Naked Time takes place well before Space Seed. And, Starfleet kept the tardigrade eggs in the Enterprise's engine room even after the refit?
 
I liked this one much much better then the other one. It was fun. I liked the animation too.

Stick-up-the-butt Trekkers will feel the stick they have had lodged in them for years grow. Whether that brings them euphoria or rage or despair or that fan-peculiar mix of all three i don't know and really don't care. It was great.

Just seen both back-to-back. Wish I'd watched Michael's one first. Ephraim and Dot was leagues ahead of The Girl Who Made The Stars. Whimsical and entertaining for what it was. Can't say I spotted the registry blunder. Anyway... IMO, the best Short Trek since Calypso - which, funnily enough, is the last Short Trek I remotely enjoyed.
 
i freaking loved ephraim and dot it was so damn cute and the ending


giphy.gif


rZx8mQu.png
rZx8mQu.png
rZx8mQu.png
rZx8mQu.png



i want more!
 
Memory Alpha lists Kirk Thatcher (the punk on the bus in TVH) as being part of the cast of this ep. Is this accurate? If so, who does he play?
He was the narrator, that's what he sounds like. He was also the puppeteer of the whales in TVH and he directed one of the later Muppet films before Disney bought them. He played the punk because he was in a punk band at the time and just played one of his band's songs in the scene. If you ever check out the Jim Henson Creature Shop Challenge he was one of the judges.


This was the cutest thing I've ever seen. Another name for tardigrades is water bear, Ephraim is a water teddy bear.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top