• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Neverending Story remake

Meh...I guess I'd try giving it a shot with my kids. They aren't too picky yet!:bolian:
 
I love the book as well as Wolfgang Peterson's 1984 film adaption, hell I own the crap DVD. That said for once I wouldn't mind somebody else taking a shot at it as the 1984 version only liberaly adapts only the first half of the novel. A more direct adaptation would be my preferance this time around.

I've suggested this idea more than once, and many fans don't seem to like it. :p I enjoy the original movie as much as anyone else who grew up in the '80s, and it's certainly the best adaptation to date (the sequels don't count for me), but it is still only half the story.

I'm not talking about the original movie. I'm talking about the wonderful book. There shouldn't even have been an original move in the first place.

And, quite frankly, compared to the original, german book by michael ende, the movie sucked, big time.
 
I recall reading that Mr. Ende felt that way about the movie. I got the impression he felt it deviated too much from the book, though I'm not sure I'd fully agree. I understand why some of the differences in the movie happened.

* shrugs *
 
I think it would be great if they did a remake of Neverending Story. I loved the movie in the 80s as well as the song.
 
Since the original won't magically disappear if they make a new version, I say bring on a remake, I can always watch the original Wolfgang Petersen film when I want to.
 
The Neverending Story movies were so terrible that a remake might help forever erase them from history. I'm for it. :thumbsup:
 
And, quite frankly, compared to the original, german book by michael ende, the movie sucked, big time.

That's what I thought too, even though I'm a child of the 80s. But I knew the book before seeing the movie and I remember I was really disappointed when I went home from cinema.

Still, I just want them to get it right this time and this quote makes me a bit hopeful they might:
The new pic -- which original producer Dieter Geissler also will produce and Sarah Schechter and Jesse Ehrman will oversee for Warners -- will examine the more nuanced details of the book that were glossed over in the first pic.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/film/news/e3iaeb1c24de37000ac9d6ab15e86a4f615
 
And, quite frankly, compared to the original, german book by michael ende, the movie sucked, big time.

That's what I thought too, even though I'm a child of the 80s. But I knew the book before seeing the movie and I remember I was really disappointed when I went home from cinema.

Still, I just want them to get it right this time and this quote makes me a bit hopeful they might:
The new pic -- which original producer Dieter Geissler also will produce and Sarah Schechter and Jesse Ehrman will oversee for Warners -- will examine the more nuanced details of the book that were glossed over in the first pic.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/content_display/film/news/e3iaeb1c24de37000ac9d6ab15e86a4f615

But how often have we heard this - a film will respect the book, be close etc etc only the find it completly twists the source material. I accept that sometimes budgets and technologies can impose limitations but others it's just the studio doesn't care or gets cold feet.
 
Do you feel that was the case with the NES movies? I'm sure it was with the sequels, but I'm not so sure it was true of the first film. * shrugs *

Just curious mainly. I grew up watching the movie long before I read the book, so I like both.
 
It's been a long time since I either read the book (not in German though...) or saw the movie. I remember liking the film and loving the book. I don't think I ever saw any of the sequels.

It's a good story, so why not have a go at it. As The Evil Dead said in an earlier post, the first film (or the book!) won't disappear if a remake gets made. The only problem I do have with remakes in general is that I have to wonder if they've completely run out of ideas for original films... But then, the first NES film wasn't a new story either, was it, it was based on the book after all.
 
^ My thoughts exactly. I'll simply wait and see how the new movie turns out. If I dislike it I'll still have the book.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top