• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

More plot details for SGA: Extinction

It could very well be good, but the premise is one that they've done so many times already!

True. But I'm admittedly a huge fan of time travel stories, and I don't see "time travel" as a premise in itself. It's a science fiction idea that can be used in many ways.
However, the idea of Atlantis needing to return to the Pegasus galaxy or else it explodes does seem like a desperate and contrived way to continue the SGA story, so maybe it's likely that the rest will follow that.

Since this movie was originally meant as a two part season six opener it would make sense to get Atlantis back to the Pegasus galaxy.

I thought they knew it was canceled by that point, or am I mistaken? Enemy At The Gate feels like it was written as an end to the series, being the only SGA season finale to not leave any hanging story and danger for the season opener to tie up. If they wanted the episode to work both ways, they should have just left Atlantis in the Pegasus galaxy.
 
"Enemy at the Gates" was only hastily changed to be a series finale, IIRC.

Why stick with your earlier script when you knew that "Extinction" would be a DVD movie, though? No imagination? Laziness?
 
Or maybe the script was that good that it was still good as is and they still wanted to do it. Equally plausible argument.

But I'll buy that Enemy at the Gate was a last minute thing. They shoehorned far too much into it, and it didn't tie up anything from the series, or deal with the characters at all.
 
It could very well be good, but the premise is one that they've done so many times already!

True. But I'm admittedly a huge fan of time travel stories, and I don't see "time travel" as a premise in itself. It's a science fiction idea that can be used in many ways.
However, the idea of Atlantis needing to return to the Pegasus galaxy or else it explodes does seem like a desperate and contrived way to continue the SGA story, so maybe it's likely that the rest will follow that.

Since this movie was originally meant as a two part season six opener it would make sense to get Atlantis back to the Pegasus galaxy.

Returning to Pegasus isn't the problem. Returning to Pegasus because Atlantis is going to explode if they don't? That's just dumb.
 
IIRC they were planing to do this Atlantis film, another SG-1 film (supposedly about public disclosure), an SGU film, and then a major overreaching Stargate film that involves all three.
 
I'd rather see the Stargate concept rebooted from the ground up with a completely different creative team, characters and cast, and Joe Flanigan join some other fun sf/f TV series, maybe playing against type for a change. I suspect he would make a great villain.

If Jason Momoa becomes a Big Damn Movie Star(TM) because of Conan, will they be able to get him to do direct to DVD movies or even Skiffy movies?
 
Maybe they should just do that overreaching Stargate movie. But I'm afraid it would just end up being another typical episode story. Something goes wrong on the Destiny, and they bring Carter and McKay aboard. In the meantime, some totally unrelated shit happens in the Milky Way.
 
Please no overreaching Stargate movie, they'd have the same problems Paramount would've had if htey'd the same thing with a TNG/DS9/Voyager crossover movie. It'd just end being a mess and fanwank at that,
 
Plus it would just end with Carter, McKay, Rush, and Eli pulling some last minute magical technobabble uber-solution out of their collective asses.
 
Christ, Stargate "fans" are insane. First you bitch and moan about Stargate Atlantis being cancelled for SGU, then you bitch and moan about the proposed continuation of Stargate Atlantis.

Reducing it down to this is insane, I'd say. Why should anyone be happy about a continuation if the continuation is crap?


Your claiming its crap from a plot outline. It's like Star Wars fans claiming heresey when all they know of Empire Strikes Back is that Luke is riding a snow horse through a blizzard and gets attacked by a Yeti.
 
Christ, Stargate "fans" are insane. First you bitch and moan about Stargate Atlantis being cancelled for SGU, then you bitch and moan about the proposed continuation of Stargate Atlantis.

Reducing it down to this is insane, I'd say. Why should anyone be happy about a continuation if the continuation is crap?


Your claiming its crap from a plot outline. It's like Star Wars fans claiming heresey when all they know of Empire Strikes Back is that Luke is riding a snow horse through a blizzard and gets attacked by a Yeti.

LOL, no, the equivalent of information would be:

Months after the Death Star has been destroyed, the Rebels hide on an Ice Planet. Probes of the Empire find the hideout, and Darth Vader starts an attack. Our heroes get scattered across the galaxy. And some Jedi Knight might appear as well.
 
Atlantis' self destruct automatically turns on because they have been "out of range of the Pegasus galaxy for too long"? Really?

I would have wished for this anyways, but this info reinforces my wish that if we really get another Stargate movie, I really hope it's either a SGU wrap up or the O'Neill-centric movie that was discussed a while ago.
 
The O'Neill centric one is supposedly the same as the Public Disclosure one, Stargate: Revolution if I remember correctly.
 
I suspect there would have been a reset button attached to that, as Revolution was supposed to be set before SGU.
 
Not necessarily. They've moved stories based on production stuff before. As-written "Continuum" was supposed to be immediately after "Ark of Truth," but when the release was delayed and Carter went to Atlantis, it ended up being moved to take place more than a year later.
 
Not necessarily. They've moved stories based on production stuff before. As-written "Continuum" was supposed to be immediately after "Ark of Truth," but when the release was delayed and Carter went to Atlantis, it ended up being moved to take place more than a year later.
Yeah, that was kind of awkward.

Carter: "Oh, by the way, they found the last Ba'al clone, so I'm gonna go out of town for a while. KBye."
 
Well, then what the hell's the point of the movie? They already did "The Road Not Taken" and "2010."
 
Mallozzi reveals plot details for Stargate Atlantis: Extinction

GateWorld has the full story, from his blog.

Short version: the Ancients installed a self-destruct in Atlantis in case the city was ever taken outside the Pegasus Galaxy. When it activates several months after "Air", there is a mad dash to get Atlantis back to Pegasus, which can be done in two jumps using the wormhole drive. After the first jump and with the clock ticking, the drive burns out; the team finds a habitable planet in range. Seeking help, they travel there and end up in "a wild time-travel themed adventure in which Todd, the Wraith, turns out to be, simultaneously, their hugest threat and biggest ally.”

Honestly, I'm glad that this movie was canceled. It just feels far too forced and too derivative of earlier ideas (especially "Adrift" and Stargate: Continuum). It also doesn't feel like it would have been anything close to a satisfactory wrap-up of the ongoing arcs, especially with the IOA and the Wraith. Using a countdown clock to get Atlantis back to Pegasus feels like a cheat to get around potential political implications, and the very logical idea that Atlantis is probably Earth's best defense without the Ancient chair and a much better location for any IOA-unified Stargate Command than Cheyenne Mountain.

And I'm absolutely sick to death of time-travel. I could have dealt with the countdown if it meant we got back to Pegasus to deal with the Wraith once and for all. But no, instead, we're getting yet another "enemy changes the timeline" story. I realize that this is a very short summary, but it sounds far too much like Ba'al's actions in Continuum; alternatively, it's an inverted version of "Moebius" with Todd changing the timeline instead of Our Heroes. I would much rather see a story which deals with Stargate Command trying to end the Wraith threat once and for all, whether it's through using the retrovirus to negotiate for peace or if it's taking more desperate measures to prevent the Wraith from finding the Milky Way.
 
Re: Mallozzi reveals plot details for Stargate Atlantis: Extinction

Given the appallingly bad writing on seasons 4 and 5, I'm not surprised to read such a dreadful synopsis for an SGA movie.

Thank frank it'll probably never get made, I prefer to remember the show as it was in seasons 1-3
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top