• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Missed tech possibilities....

Multiple computer cores (the Ent-D had 3, we have chips with 72 in production)

Change in terminology. As presented in the TNG Tech Manual, the computer cores are actually what we now call clusters or nodes - massive banks of processing chips (what we now call cores) plus filestores. The type of chip you're referring to is likely outclassed a dozen-fold by a single isolinear chip... The E-D computer cores were filled with whole banks of those.
 
Stabbed during a bar fight with Nausicaans.
Yes that's what happened when he was a young man that required him to have an artificial heart in the first place. But in Tapestry, something like a blast from an energy weapon caused the heart to malfunction.
 
One of the things I lamented was that the crew would find fantastic technology, but you would never see it incorporated. I would have loved for the Declaration ringship be what took the Kelvans home, say.

The look of the Enterprise was like the teardrop for submarines--a perfect shape that didn't need changine much. (hate pointed saucers)
 
Technology that is touched upon by information-technologies grow exponentially. I'd expect to see maybe 80% of the advances in Star trek's 24th century to happen by 2050. Some already are in very experimental versions.

Star Trek's treatment of automation and AI is generally lacking (despite lots of stories about it), and it's treatment of biotech is hopelessly biased and outdated.

RAMA

This discussion is spun off a discussion in the Movie Forum regarding TMP uniforms.

The idea, here, is to touch on ideas--predominantly science and technology--that could or should have been seen in Star Trek but weren't.

In the 1960s TOS seemed quite advanced and futuristic in many ways. It must be said, though, that even by the standards of the time some of the visualizations of the sci/tech in TOS looked dated. But suffice to say much of it then looked sufficiently convincing of a far future as envisioned from a mid 1960's perspective.

But flash forward just a few years and sci/tech was starting to be depicted even more advanced (in some ways) than what was seen on TOS.

I've just recently finished watching the old series SEARCH from 1972. For those unfamiliar with this old show it centered on the exploits of three rotating agents (known as Probes) who worked for an agency known as World Securities.

Probe field agents each had an audio implant that allowed them to remain in constant contact with Probe Control. They also had a dental implant that allowed them to signal "yes" or "no" responses to Probe Control whenever it wasn't possible for the agents to communicate by voice (such as when other people were present).

The agents also had a miniaturized scanner about the circumferance of an AA size battery and no more than a quarter inch thick that attached either to a ring, a tie pin or decorative neck chain. This scanner allowed Probe Control to track the agent globally as well as monitor his/her vital signs. Probe Control could use the scanner to aid the agent through all manner of wavelengths (and to some extent by necessity of the plot). They were generally consistent with its use and limitations. The scanner could also read bio signs of the agent and of others in the agent's vicinity.

Meanwhile Probe Control operated in a way somewhat analogous to a starship bridge in contact with landing party/away team members. We saw something like this briefly in early TNG and then the practice was abandoned. Probe Control gave the agents immediate access to all sorts of information to facilitate execution of their assignments. And being able toconstantly monitor the agent allowed them to dispatch aid whenever needed or requested.

My essential point, though, is that as far-fetched as the tech seamed in 1972 it really seems quite plausible today. And it always struck me as more advanced than what was seen in TMP and later Treks. The audio implant would make perfect sense for a far future concept like Star Trek and the wearable miniaturized scanner makes the tricorder look awfully clunky and cumbersome given the SEARCH scanner and implant leave one's hands free. A communicator implant would also eliminate the old gimmick of losing one's communicator thus losing contact with the ship.

In some respects SEARCH was a spin on the old The Man From U.N.C.L.E. idea, but the tech depicted struck me as a smart evolution of what was seen on TOS.

In retrospect some of what we saw in TMP, the subsequent films and then TNG onward doesn't impress as sufficiently evolved given some of the sci/tech ideas being seen in other SF over the years.


Anyone else with something they think could or should have been seen in Trek but wasn't?
 
One thing I think they didn't get quite right were the data pads, especially when compared to our tablets and e-readers. In Child's Play, when Janeway and Seven of Nine say goodbye to Icheb in the transporter room, Seven tells gives him a bag, telling him she included pads, plural, on a variety of variety of subjects. This indicates that each subject required a different device, as if one pad equaled one book, rather than an entire library or a database. In the 24th century, one pad should essentially be a portable computer, into which Voyager's entire database could have been downloaded. Considering that this episode aired about a decade, give or take from the introduction of e-readers, tablets, and smartphones, how they portrayed the data pads on this Voyager seems rather short sighted.

Similarly, Janeway essentially being tethered to her desk to use the computer in her ready
 
Argh, posted before I was ready! Continuing, Janeway being tethered to her desk to use the computer in her ready room, instead of having a portable computer she could have sat on the comfortable couch to use also seems short sighted. It seems as if Voyager's crew was limited to desk or console computers where they'd have to bring themselves to the computer, rather than computer access being portable and usable wherever they happened to be at any given moment on board ship, considering the limited use of the pads as Child's Play seemed to indicate.
 
Honestly, the pads miss all the way around - there is every indication that well before the middle of this century - much less by the late 24th century - displays for personal data will be either extremely foldable and rollable, written with light in air, or built in to *us* in the form of optical or direct brain implants. Probably some combination of all three. In Trek, given that there is a taboo against modifying humans due to the Eugenics Wars and some other atrocity involving computers or AI that has only been hinted at, I can see that they might not go for implants - but a wristband or similar that contains the power, storage, and connectivity of a current supercomputer and uses a laser (or... something? Molecules momentarily altered by a nanoreplicator?) to display the information in air in front of you, or on any convenient surface, seems completely likely.
 
Technology that is touched upon by information-technologies grow exponentially. I'd expect to see maybe 80% of the advances in Star trek's 24th century to happen by 2050. Some already are in very experimental versions.
RAMA

Just a pity we most probably won't have the likes of warp drive, replicators, transporters and such anytime that soon, if ever ...
 
Honestly, the pads miss all the way around - there is every indication that well before the middle of this century - much less by the late 24th century - displays for personal data will be either extremely foldable and rollable, written with light in air, or built in to *us* in the form of optical or direct brain implants. Probably some combination of all three. In Trek, given that there is a taboo against modifying humans due to the Eugenics Wars and some other atrocity involving computers or AI that has only been hinted at, I can see that they might not go for implants - but a wristband or similar that contains the power, storage, and connectivity of a current supercomputer and uses a laser (or... something? Molecules momentarily altered by a nanoreplicator?) to display the information in air in front of you, or on any convenient surface, seems completely likely.
I think that the resistance to such implants is not only due to lessons learned from the Eugenics Wars, but also reinforced by the Federation's experiences with the Borg. Of course, they neglect to distinguish between voluntary and chosen implants from being involuntarily being assimilated.
 
I think that the resistance to such implants is not only due to lessons learned from the Eugenics Wars, but also reinforced by the Federation's experiences with the Borg. Of course, they neglect to distinguish between voluntary and chosen implants from being involuntarily being assimilated.
I would think so, too - except that in TOS, they hadn't met the Borg, and they showed some strange hesitance with a lot of tech. M5, for example. Plus, it would help explain the seeming backwardness of their tech if *something* happened that made them leery of letting computers gain too much control.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top