Message in a Bottle
- Thread starter BillJ
- Start date
Really? You hated it? I love that episode. I think the two EMHs are hilarious together! But, like my mother always says, "That's what makes horse racing!."
Loved the ep!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_LYOzCjYsc
"Far be it from me to turn down the chance to be a hero."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_LYOzCjYsc
"Far be it from me to turn down the chance to be a hero."
This is one of my favorite episodes.
Think my favorite bit is when Seven zaps the Hirogen. Janeway's and Bellana's reactions afterward, priceless.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YefUnnKgz3A&feature=related#t=6m20s
Think my favorite bit is when Seven zaps the Hirogen. Janeway's and Bellana's reactions afterward, priceless.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YefUnnKgz3A&feature=related#t=6m20s
I love the ep. I think it's hilarious the Doctor ends up with another EMH even more precious than he is. It's like everything about the Doctor evolved and became more so even his self absorption!
This is one of my favorite episodes.
Think my favorite bit is when Seven zaps the Hirogen. Janeway's and Bellana's reactions afterward, priceless.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YefUnnKgz3A&feature=related#t=6m20s
I love it when Mom walks away, and the "Big sister" gives Seven respect.
"Mild shock. Not bad."
I liked the episode. Part of me wishes the first visit to the alpha quadrant wasn't a comedy episode, I wish the Romulans weren't so hapless (these people stole Starfleet's deadliest weapon?), and the idea that only six people knew how to fly the Prometheus is a joke (how many people would have been involved in it's design and construction?), but I enjoyed it for what it was.
I absolutely loved that episode! It's a great Doctor episode (as they usually are), and Andy Dick had a pretty good dynamic with him (and I'm not an Andy Dick fan).
It was a great light-hearted comedy episode, and is still an important episode for the Voyager crew. And despite all of the fun, I found the ending quite touching. I think I got a little emotional when Janeway said "60,000 light years seems a little closer today".
It was a great light-hearted comedy episode, and is still an important episode for the Voyager crew. And despite all of the fun, I found the ending quite touching. I think I got a little emotional when Janeway said "60,000 light years seems a little closer today".
I love this episode, one of the highlights of one of my favourite seasons of Trek.
When it comes to this ep, I find myself torn.
It had a fun, adventurous feel to it, and a lot of great moments (some of which have been mentioned in this thread). The sequence with Harry and Tom trying to program a replacement doc is fantastic, and in particular, the part where he starts reciting Gray's Anatomy, word for word from the very beginning, is hilarious. I'm not generally a fan of Andy Dick, but I found EMH2 to just... work. I'm not sure why, but somehow, I found him more funny than annoying (for the most part, anyway). And, this ep also has one of my favorite battle moments: near the end, when those three other Starfleet ships (with two of my favorite classes!) just swoop in, guns blazing... that was spectacularly cool. None of the usual Trek preamble or diplomatic overtures or hailing frequencies or warning shots; just "Those Romulan petaQ's are stealing our ship! Get em!" Fuck yeah, Starfleet.
On the other hand...
The basic premise is pretty dodgy, it shines a bright spotlight (AGAIN) on the nonsensical "does the Doc have a backup, or is his program contained entirely IN the hologram, or what?" issue, it has some great lines but also some real groaners, and of course, there's the inane stupidity of the U.S.S. "And I'll form the head!" Prometheus.
So... yeah. I guess all of that would make it even out to a 5 out of 10?
It had a fun, adventurous feel to it, and a lot of great moments (some of which have been mentioned in this thread). The sequence with Harry and Tom trying to program a replacement doc is fantastic, and in particular, the part where he starts reciting Gray's Anatomy, word for word from the very beginning, is hilarious. I'm not generally a fan of Andy Dick, but I found EMH2 to just... work. I'm not sure why, but somehow, I found him more funny than annoying (for the most part, anyway). And, this ep also has one of my favorite battle moments: near the end, when those three other Starfleet ships (with two of my favorite classes!) just swoop in, guns blazing... that was spectacularly cool. None of the usual Trek preamble or diplomatic overtures or hailing frequencies or warning shots; just "Those Romulan petaQ's are stealing our ship! Get em!" Fuck yeah, Starfleet.
On the other hand...
The basic premise is pretty dodgy, it shines a bright spotlight (AGAIN) on the nonsensical "does the Doc have a backup, or is his program contained entirely IN the hologram, or what?" issue, it has some great lines but also some real groaners, and of course, there's the inane stupidity of the U.S.S. "And I'll form the head!" Prometheus.
So... yeah. I guess all of that would make it even out to a 5 out of 10?
I just watched this episode.
The battle scenes were great.
The Prometheus ship looked like many of the pointy triangular 24th century ships we've seen on VOY. The bridge was amazing. I loved all the white/light grey on that walls, ceiling skylight, decor, and captain's chair. What set did they repurpose for it?
oh i just checked memory alpha:
and
I enjoyed the EMH Mk.IIs conversations with the EMH and the humor and it got me thinking to the next Trek TV series and if there will be another EMH?
Of course it would have to be a show set after 2375 because the EMH was
I started a thread a couple of years ago (that is a dead thread) about it.
Emergency Medical Hologram in future Trek ?
The battle scenes were great.
The Prometheus ship looked like many of the pointy triangular 24th century ships we've seen on VOY. The bridge was amazing. I loved all the white/light grey on that walls, ceiling skylight, decor, and captain's chair. What set did they repurpose for it?
oh i just checked memory alpha:
and
I thought they looks pretty badass in the battle scenes.
I enjoyed the EMH Mk.IIs conversations with the EMH and the humor and it got me thinking to the next Trek TV series and if there will be another EMH?
Of course it would have to be a show set after 2375 because the EMH was
according to memory alpha.
I started a thread a couple of years ago (that is a dead thread) about it.
Emergency Medical Hologram in future Trek ?
It's an okay episode, but nothing special. I wish that the first big Alpha Quadrant episode hadn't been a ridiculous comedy. They really should have used this opportunity to do a DS9 Dominion War/Voyager crossover. Now THAT would have been much more interesting.
When it comes to this ep, I find myself torn.
It had a fun, adventurous feel to it, and a lot of great moments (some of which have been mentioned in this thread). The sequence with Harry and Tom trying to program a replacement doc is fantastic, and in particular, the part where he starts reciting Gray's Anatomy, word for word from the very beginning, is hilarious. I'm not generally a fan of Andy Dick, but I found EMH2 to just... work. I'm not sure why, but somehow, I found him more funny than annoying (for the most part, anyway). And, this ep also has one of my favorite battle moments: near the end, when those three other Starfleet ships (with two of my favorite classes!) just swoop in, guns blazing... that was spectacularly cool. None of the usual Trek preamble or diplomatic overtures or hailing frequencies or warning shots; just "Those Romulan petaQ's are stealing our ship! Get em!" Fuck yeah, Starfleet.
On the other hand...
The basic premise is pretty dodgy, it shines a bright spotlight (AGAIN) on the nonsensical "does the Doc have a backup, or is his program contained entirely IN the hologram, or what?" issue, it has some great lines but also some real groaners, and of course, there's the inane stupidity of the U.S.S. "And I'll form the head!" Prometheus.
So... yeah. I guess all of that would make it even out to a 5 out of 10?
But didn't this episode continue the theme of not having a backup for the EMH. So it would be in line with continuty, it wasn't until a later episode "Living Witness"(if memory serves) that after x years, they remembered ah yes he does have a backup module after all.
As for the episode it's self basing as it compares to VOY episodes I would give it a 7/10.
I really liked this episode, perhaps arguably the best VOY story, as somewhat silly as it is. I like how it overlaped with DS9 without too much baggage.
Similar threads
