• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Measure of a Man: The solution.

The problem is a general sloppy lack of coherence. In one episode Jake has no money to buy his dad a gift (because the federation doesn't use money) but then Sisko buys a rather sizeable piece of land on Bajor (which must have cost a lot of money). So either Sisko has been doing some trafficking on the side or there is something really wrong here.

I'd assume Starfleet officers get a stipend in whatever local currency they may be likely to encounter. Ben may give Jake a few Bajoran coins or a latinum strip for some jumja sticks, but not enough to buy 400 year old merchandise at auction.
 
Doesn't sound particularly unlikely, really. The officer might fill a requisition form for a pile of baubles X meters high to impress the locals with, to facilitate completion of his assigned tasks, and Starfleet generally would have no reason to turn it down, because baubles cost exactly nothing and officers usually are smart enough not to order a pile so high that it would bury the local economy.

Jake being underage and a civilian means he will be turned down, though. And dad can't be approached on this particular issue.

Timo Saloniemi
 
The thing there is, Starfleet didn't grab Data. After his discovery and (re)activation, the android took his sweet time deciding that going to Starfleet might be fun. The timeline is slightly vague, but at least three years seem to have passed between discovery and enrolling.

What Data's status in those years was is an interesting question. A lab specimen? A random pseudo-citizen with a Nansen passport? A newborn Fed, all of three years old at the time of Academy entry exams?

Timo Saloniemi

Or as 'The Measure of A Man' extended edition would have it, a mere 6 years old when he started, 10 when he graduated. Either way- what the heck was he up to and, if he wasn't a citizen, who sponsored him? Was Maddox an outlier in not welcoming Data as a person?

And, speaking of the extended edition- how often is the Academy putting NFN NMI (No First Name No Middle Initial) on diplomas? Does Worf's diploma say Worf NMI Son of Mogh/Rozhenko? Peanut NMI Hamper? They're working with a lot of diverse cultures and the three name convention doesn't seem all that common even in the Federation.
 
Doesn't sound particularly unlikely, really. The officer might fill a requisition form for a pile of baubles X meters high to impress the locals with, to facilitate completion of his assigned tasks, and Starfleet generally would have no reason to turn it down, because baubles cost exactly nothing and officers usually are smart enough not to order a pile so high that it would bury the local economy.

Jake being underage and a civilian means he will be turned down, though. And dad can't be approached on this particular issue.

Timo Saloniemi

Yes I can picture that.

Sisko (to StarFleet's accountant or whatever): I need a zillion federation credits to buy me a huge property on Bajor.

SFAOW: what do you need that for.

Sisko: I want to make me some wine!!

SFAOW: I don't know there's no precedent.

Sisko: How about Picard? He has a huge property and makes his own wine?

SFAOW: True but he inherited from his barbecued brother and his wife that conveniently disappeared.

Sisko: Listen, don't make me some over and btchslap you!!!

SFAOW: All Right, all right. Here's your zillion Bajorarn rubles. No need to be that way!!
 
Sisko has a lot of negotiation leverage on Bajor. “Oh well it’d be a shame if the neighbors found out why the Emissary won’t be moving in. Or if the prophets found out about your business practices...”

It’s possible someone let him into the academy just cause they thought it’d be a cool novelty.
 
Sisko has a lot of negotiation leverage on Bajor. “Oh well it’d be a shame if the neighbors found out why the Emissary won’t be moving in. Or if the prophets found out about your business practices...”

It’s possible someone let him into the academy just cause they thought it’d be a cool novelty.

Yes, Sisko knows a lot about the rules of acquisition, maybe he's put them into practice.
 
I haven't read them all but I doubt these rules contain anything about sentient AI.
Well, we don't know if Act of Cumberland contained anything about sentient AI. I mean, we don't even know if the JAG believed that Data was sentient (she even called him a "toaster"). The only thing we are sure that she said that the real question was if he has "a soul".
 
Last edited:
The problem with this episode is that the premise is just stupid. At that point in the story, Data has already been given a rank and several medals for his actions both are things that implicitly acknowledge sapience. You don't give a rank or a medal to a toaster!!!

We already give rank and medals to animals:

https://www.businessinsider.com/the...ilitary-history-2018-11?r=US&IR=T#nils-olav-1

Can a King Penguin choose to leave the service or reject a veterinary procedure?

Is Data a King Penguin? Or is he considered "human"? Or the right colour of human, if we go back a few decades and look at the rights of some folk in military service?
 
Please, it's just honorary. A penguin can't give orders. Data can.

Honorary or not, it undercuts Swedish Borg's point.

And Maddox's point might well be that Data's rank and medals are honorary. After all, can you really give a medal for courage to someone incapable of feeling fear?
 
Honorary or not, it undercuts Swedish Borg's point.

And Maddox's point might well be that Data's rank and medals are honorary. After all, can you really give a medal for courage to someone incapable of feeling fear?

Medals are for accomplishments, not whether you are able to feel fear. Data was able to give orders, when was the last time you took orders from a pigeon?
 
Medals are for accomplishments, not whether you are able to feel fear.
"Soldier, you saved a ship full of innocent orphans, captured evil war criminals and prevented World War III! I can't imagine how scared you felt!"
"No, not really. I was, you know, pretty cool, sir"
"Is that so? Sorry, no medals for you. We give them only to people frightened to death , you know."
 
He couldn't function as a member of a crew if it was honorary. Maddox is an ass.
Actually, if you'll indulge me in some semantics, Louvois is the ass, as in a jackass or dumbass. Maddox is a jerk, jerking people around, & Nakamura is either tool, or a shill, depending on how involved you suspect he was in this gambit
 
I mean just imagine, Data asks something of an underling... and they would respond "Sorry honorary commander but I am busy!!" "You're not the boss of me!!":D
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top