McCoy wants to come back...

[Robert D. Robot]

I wouldn't mind seeing the older actors, but maybe not as the Doctor. Here's a 30-second idea:

1. Weird time-fragmenting thing happens with the TARDIS

2. Somehow leads to the Doctor's incarnations getting Arched and living out their lives. Logically, it shouldn't be possible, but the TARDIS got hit with a dose of timey-whimey. Maybe 4's a professor emeritus at Oxford? That way, it makes some sense that they look way different from their last appearance.

3. 11 has to TECH the TECH to reset the timeline, and he has a brief encounter with each incarnation, who don't know that he's them.

Just a thought. I'd like to see something, but I'd probably prefer it not be within the context of a regular story.

I think that this is a pretty cool idea. I suspect, however, that for the 50th anniversary most fans would want to see each of the Doctors featured to appear as the "genuine article", so to speak- rather than alternate versions. I really do like your idea, though, and wish that we could see such a story with one or more other such alternate Doctors leading alternate existences.

 

[Bones2]

I can't see a way of getting all 11 Doctors in a story that wouldn't be a complete mess, not withstanding the impossibility of it. I'm not sure I'd want it either. The Five Doctors is about as good as it could get I reckon. A multi-Doc story could still be good though. 11 and 8 I'd love to see.

 

[Captaindemotion]

I wouldn't mind seeing the older actors, but maybe not as the Doctor. Here's a 30-second idea:

1. Weird time-fragmenting thing happens with the TARDIS

2. Somehow leads to the Doctor's incarnations getting Arched and living out their lives. Logically, it shouldn't be possible, but the TARDIS got hit with a dose of timey-whimey. Maybe 4's a professor emeritus at Oxford? That way, it makes some sense that they look way different from their last appearance.

3. 11 has to TECH the TECH to reset the timeline, and he has a brief encounter with each incarnation, who don't know that he's them.

Just a thought. I'd like to see something, but I'd probably prefer it not be within the context of a regular story.

Oh, that's good. I like that one.

 

[Mr Awe]

I wouldn't mind seeing the older actors, but maybe not as the Doctor. Here's a 30-second idea:

1. Weird time-fragmenting thing happens with the TARDIS

2. Somehow leads to the Doctor's incarnations getting Arched and living out their lives. Logically, it shouldn't be possible, but the TARDIS got hit with a dose of timey-whimey. Maybe 4's a professor emeritus at Oxford? That way, it makes some sense that they look way different from their last appearance.

3. 11 has to TECH the TECH to reset the timeline, and he has a brief encounter with each incarnation, who don't know that he's them.

Just a thought. I'd like to see something, but I'd probably prefer it not be within the context of a regular story.

I think that this is a pretty cool idea. I suspect, however, that for the 50th anniversary most fans would want to see each of the Doctors featured to appear as the "genuine article", so to speak- rather than alternate versions. I really do like your idea, though, and wish that we could see such a story with one or more other such alternate Doctors leading alternate existences.

Yep, at least that's true for me. I want the genuine articles. Alternate versions just wouldn't be as fun.

Mr Awe

 

[Davros]

That reminds me a bit of Big Finish's Zagreus and a lot of fans weren't happy with that result...

I couldn't even listen to the whole thing.