• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Marvel Cinematic Universe spoiler-heavy speculation thread

What grade would you give the Marvel Cinematic Universe? (Ever-Changing Question)


  • Total voters
    185
Also, it makes no sense to assume that prior fandom is the only way to be knowledgeable about a subject. As I already said, in any other profession, if the job requires certain knowledge or skill, then you'll be given the necessary training before you start, or be required to get it yourself.

I agree with your overall point -- looking at his entire body of work, I'd argue Jack Kirby wasn't actually a superhero fan -- but plenty of professions make having a certain knowledge set or skill a -prerequisite- for hiring and wouldn't consider anyone who didn't already have it.
 
I agree with your overall point -- looking at his entire body of work, I'd argue Jack Kirby wasn't actually a superhero fan -- but plenty of professions make having a certain knowledge set or skill a -prerequisite- for hiring and wouldn't consider anyone who didn't already have it.
Jack never stood still. He was always moving from genre to genre, sometimes creating them.
 
Last edited:
I don't see anything wrong with having writers who aren't necessarily familiar with the source material enough to be considered fans, but it's another thing entirely to have writers who are openly disdainful for the source material they are supposed to be adapting. I'd rather the writers have some actual passion for what they're doing rather than just be there to collect a check while wishing they were somewhere else.

Where did that come from? Nobody said anything about disdain. Yes, it's important to love your work, but what I'm trying to get across is that you can learn to love something. You can discover something new and become a fan of it through working on it. It makes no sense to assume you had to be a fan from the beginning, because that ignores the simple fact that people can learn new things and build new bonds.

And fandom doesn't have to be limited to a specific series or work, but can be more about its overall genre or style or inspirations. Last year, I was offered the chance to pitch to a new novel project, something I had no prior familiarity with, but whose genre and approach were a perfect fit for my sensibilities, and which drew its inspiration from earlier works that I am an admirer of. I didn't get the gig the first time around, but I'm really hoping for another chance, since it's something I'd be excited to work on. And I didn't need prior knowledge of it to develop that excitement.
 
Where did that come from? Nobody said anything about disdain. Yes, it's important to love your work, but what I'm trying to get across is that you can learn to love something. You can discover something new and become a fan of it through working on it. It makes no sense to assume you had to be a fan from the beginning, because that ignores the simple fact that people can learn new things and build new bonds.

And fandom doesn't have to be limited to a specific series or work, but can be more about its overall genre or style or inspirations. Last year, I was offered the chance to pitch to a new novel project, something I had no prior familiarity with, but whose genre and approach were a perfect fit for my sensibilities, and which drew its inspiration from earlier works that I am an admirer of. I didn't get the gig the first time around, but I'm really hoping for another chance, since it's something I'd be excited to work on. And I didn't need prior knowledge of it to develop that excitement.
My comment about "disdain" came from X-Men 97 showrunner Beau Demayo's claim that The Witcher's writing staff would openly mock the source material. That's not someone I would want to adapt a property I care for. You don't necessarily have to previously have been a fan of it, but have some basic respect for it.
 
My comment about "disdain" came from X-Men 97 showrunner Beau Demayo's claim that The Witcher's writing staff would openly mock the source material. That's not someone I would want to adapt a property I care for. You don't necessarily have to previously have been a fan of it, but have some basic respect for it.

And it seems, to back up your point, they MAY have lost their acting lead as part of it. Reading between the lines...
 
Seems unlikely. How often would the actors even interact with the members of the writer’s room, outside the showrunner?
 
Seems unlikely. How often would the actors even interact with the members of the writer’s room, outside the showrunner?

Depends. There are a lot of productions where the writer-producers visit the set regularly and work closely with the actors, and others where they don't -- such as those where the writing staff is based in Hollywood while the filming takes place in Vancouver, Toronto, Atlanta, etc. I don't know enough about The Witcher to know where its writing and production are based, though.
 
Seems unlikely. How often would the actors even interact with the members of the writer’s room, outside the showrunner?

From Cavill, after season 1:

“As far as the preparation goes, coming into this, I wanted the character to have a closer relationship to the character in the books, I wanted him to be more book accurate. And so it was more to do with making sure and campaigning for him to sound more intellectual, more philosophical, and to have an emotional side as well, rather than just be a grumpy snowman. Every day I was pushing this stuff as far as prep goes…At the present he can be a little uncommunicative. And I'm obviously working on that.”
 
Chris was in Ghostbusters
Liam was in Independence Day
Luke was in Thor Ragnarok


I am aware that Luke Hemsworth will be the new star of "The Witcher". However, is the MCU planning for Chris Hemsworth to appear in more movies as Thor after "Thor: Love and Thunder"?
 
I am aware that Luke Hemsworth will be the new star of "The Witcher". However, is the MCU planning for Chris Hemsworth to appear in more movies as Thor after "Thor: Love and Thunder"?
Liam is in the Witcher.
No idea of Chris (or Luke for that matter) will be Thor again.
 
On IMDB, Chris is slated to be in Secret Wars.
Well it's IMDB so
CH5Q3nA.jpg
 
I am aware that Luke Hemsworth will be the new star of "The Witcher". However, is the MCU planning for Chris Hemsworth to appear in more movies as Thor after "Thor: Love and Thunder"?
I don't think we've gotten official word either way, beyond the text at the end of Love & Thunder.
 
Huh, their source is Deadline (even though they don't link to the specific report...) so I'm surprised we didn't see this news reported earlier.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top