Mark Gatiss to play the 3rd Doctor at Christmas?
- Thread starter StCoop
- Start date
Legends of Tomorrow recently did a story where they travelled back in time to WW1 and met Tolkien in the trenches.
I hope he's not playing Tolkien. I really really really hope not. It's lame. "Pop the Doctor inspired the books!" No. The horror of fucking war inspired the books.
I should have asked him when I bumped into him a few weeks ago in Cardiff on a street corner!
Dammit!
You nicked his wallet, didn't you?
I wish
I have no objection to the Doctor meeting Tolkien. Hell, I've had the vague idea myself of a War Doctor Christmas special with Tolkien and the Somme.
But. I draw the line at Gatiss as Tolkien. He's far too old for the role.
I have no problem with The Doctor meeting Tolkien, but, like Professor Zoom, I don't like the idea of an adventure with The Doctor being the inspiration for his books.
Actually we have a third candidate for Gatiss's character, who has a similar appearance, with the moustache- Gilbert Mackenzie-Trench, the guy who designed the TARDIS style Police Box, and who was a Lieutenant in WW1.... He too would fit the Radio Times description of " having a resonance through all of Doctor Who". Though given that they deleted my comment about Tolkien (with a picture) I still suspect he might be most likely.
Well, that trailer does have Gatiss, supposedly in character, commenting upon the notion of police boxes with admiration. I rather like that theory! I hope it proves true.
With a bit of embarrassment, I thought the term "McKenzie Trench" in relation to the iconic box referred to two separate individuals who contributed to the famous design.
Oh, that sounds much more appealing and makes sense as a tie-in to The First Doctor.
That said, the Radio Times did delete my comment about the similarity to Tolkien, but didn't delete any other speculations, including Mackenzie-Trench, so...
Ugh, Moffat!!
Coincidentally, Nicholas Hoult is in early talks to play J.R.R. in the upcoming biopic entitled Tolkien, set during WWI.
Would a character reveal like that be something the Radio Times would know? Telling the person running the website so they could delete, wouldn't it basically get out faster?
Can I just ask how does Tolkien "echo" throughout Doctor Who, exactly? I've never heard of the Tolkien-Who connection ever before, is it actually a long, pre-existing one?
Gandalf regenerates halfway through LOTR....
But Mackenze-Trench also has his work in every episode... And may that's why they've gone to the extent of having the two different TARDIS exteriors this time...
Search me.
Maybe Radio Times hates Tolkien on some principle.
To be honest, Mackenzie-Trench feels more like something Moffat would do, while Tolkien seems more of an RTD trope. And though Moffat has channeled his inner RTD a few times over the past year, with this special being Moffat's last episode, I think we're more likely to get something pure-bred Moffat. Therefore, I am siding with the Mackenzie-Trench theory.
Last edited:
Similar threads
