• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

MAN OF STEEL - Grading & Discussion

Grade the movie...


  • Total voters
    265
I haven't said anything about the movie one way or the other. I haven't even seen it yet. But no matter how much money it's made, there are obviously issues with the movie, or else so many people wouldn't have so many issues with it. It's obviously far from perfect, nor would I expect it to be. Just because you think it's the best thing since sliced bread doesn't make you the final, ultimate authority on its perfection.

God could make a movie and this crowd would find things to bitch about.
 
I found myself wondering the same thing at the end of this movie as I did at the end of the Avengers. And that is about how much paperwork would have to be filled out after such an event.
 
I found myself wondering the same thing at the end of this movie as I did at the end of the Avengers. And that is about how much paperwork would have to be filled out after such an event.

I'm sure the first thing insurance companies would do is claim that no one had "super-villain" clauses in their policies and refuse to pay. :lol:
 
I honestly originally felt like Superman was in his mid 20's or something before they revealed he was 33.

Henry Cavill is 30. I'm sure they wanted Superman close in age to the actor playing him.

Ehhh.... Maybe. But in the same movie the 30-year-old Cavill plays an 18-year-old Clark in the tornado flashback and the 30+ year old Tom Welling played a 20-something Clark when the series ended. So the age of the actor shouldn't (and has never) have anything to do with the the age of the character. Unless Beverly Hills 90210 really was about a bunch of middle-aged high school students. ;)

It strikes me as an instance of the symbolism writing the story over the story trying to make sense. Superman is 33 simply because he "needs to be" for the Jesus symbolism to fit that much more. Amy Adams is also in her late 30s so we can probably assume Lois Lane is too.

Which, again, feels... "odd." Now for "main stream"/career Superman being 33 I can see. But just starting out as Superman? Strikes me as old. He's really wandered around the planet for decades without ever learning he could fly?

Lois Lane has yet to find a boyfriend, husband or at least a serious relationship? It doesn't seem to "feel right", I guess, more so in Superman's case.
 
Lois Lane has yet to find a boyfriend, husband or at least a serious relationship? It doesn't seem to "feel right", I guess, more so in Superman's case.

The writers clearly wanted Superman and Lois to be each others first real romance. Nothing wrong with that.
 
A better safety tip would be to look slightly to your right when looking out the windshield and you may see a tornado and/or storm well before there is a problem.
 
All I remember about Superman IV right now is that Nuclear Man was terrible, and the ridiculous scene with Superman carrying the woman in outer space. I still don't know how she was alive during it. It was like the writers had stopped caring at that point! :lol:

Oh, it could have been even worse. Just check out the deleted scenes on the Superman IV blu-ray and you'll see stuff that is so awful you'll want to gouge your eyes out afterwards.

Man of Steel and OVERPASSES AND TORNADO SAFETY

Getting everyone under the overpass was such a dumb move.

Well obviously it wasn't the most ideal place, but they didn't have a whole lot of time or options. And the tornado didn't appear to be actually passing over the overpass anyway, so it was more them just getting out of the tornado's path.
 
Man of Steel and OVERPASSES AND TORNADO SAFETY

Getting everyone under the overpass was such a dumb move.

Hey, what do you know? It's the exact same link I gave! :)


The site was so useful it was posted twice. But I was in the same position you were in when you first posted that.;)
 
Doesn't mean it doesn't have issues, either.

You've yet to identify a real one - just stuff you don't like.

The folks who made this film would do well to ignore anyone who tells them they should do anything other than what they think best.

I could've used a few witty one-liners sprinkled in but other than that, it was a great movie.

My thoughts exactly.

I'd have preferred a tittle less total devastation in metropolis too, but I still loved the movie
 
Total devastation?

10 buildings at most. That city spreads out for miles.

Bah.

Although it's nice practice for the Miracleman Movie when London is turned into a hole.
 
Yeah it was definitely a large area, but hardly the entire city. Hell, the Daily Planet was spared and that building appeared to be within fairly close range of the World Engine.
 
I could've used a few witty one-liners sprinkled in but other than that, it was a great movie.

I for one am so happy they avoided the cheesy one liners. I went in expecting a solid story, amazing action, but to have to grit my teeth and get through some horrible witty one liners in the middle of a life and death conflict. I actually can't believe they held off on the comic relief, it made it feel like a mature film and helped me get drawn in to the situation rather than feeling detached from it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top