Discussion in 'Star Trek: Lower Decks' started by mdtauk, Oct 25, 2018.
I don’t follow, sorry; what do you mean?
Here's a non-Twitter link.
Should work worldwide:
What's the harm if the series goes the Orville direction? Or a completely new direction?
Now, Orville is hit and miss for me but there is a huge appeal. Maybe Lower Decks will find such a niche?
Don't worry, nothing about this looks nearly as good as The Orville. Not a surprise.
"We live on a spaceship." Wonder where they cribbed that from?
Well, as somebody who doesn’t like the Orville it’s a personal hope that it doesn’t go too far down the Orville route. As I didn’t enjoy the Orville, I’d be unlikely to enjoy this. If it goes down the entirely new route, then great. I might like that, I might not. There’s certainly no harm in any of it, it’s just a personal and subjective view.
WHERE is the Lower Decks sub forum?
We should have one by now.
Screencaps suggest conflicting registry numbers: 77567 vs. 75567...
Then again, that shuttle might belong to another starship. We'll find out, right?
Cool! Looks like fun. I like that we can have different tones in Trek. This idea that everyone in Starfleet is going to be the perfect specimen of humanity? Yeah, never really bought that.
There's also a cribbed Rick and Morty alien creature bit in there too. But whatever, it looks fun and silly and I'm in. Only because I'm super tired of dead serious Trek with hints of melodrama (looking at you Disco and PIC).
I know I could be watching The Orville but I don't care for Seth McFarlane or his TNG fan fic.
And it's still bothering me: Rutherford should have a full name, right?
Sesame Street? A Beatles song?
At least the "by the book" guy doesn't come across as Rimmer...
But there's something apocryphal about the lower decks crew yelling "Hey green girl"... but this cartoon is a parody.
Before the 1:15 mark there's some generic American Dad style humor. It's probably the worst moment of the teaser.
By 1:26 they're breaking the fourth wall in telling us the obvious (since the title of the show didn't do it on its own?) And it can't be a great if the Enterprise never had episodes with its lower decks fixing everything... again, it's a parody...
The blast shield bit was funny (I was chuckling a bit throughout, TBH) but it has a partial Orville vibe. At least Orville didn't do it. Again, being a parody, her child-like enthusiasm is more engaging than anything else.
"We live on a space ship. Nobody is dying from a spear wound." The first half is a bit lax but the second half changes and improves the context.
I get a partial Futurama vibe as well.
1:57 has a vibe of "Homeboys in Outer Space", only taken to the next level.
When I use "vibe", think "homage" or "influence" and not "lame copycat".
I'm actually stoked for this. "Hey green lady" line aside.
Aren't the makers of Rick and Morty involved in this? That would make cribbing impossible, if it's their signature style?
No, but the creator of Lower Decks did work on Season 1 of R&M.
Well Orville is generally accepted to be garbage by all but it's miniscule cadre of an ever-shrinking fan base (If the rapidly diminishing ratings and brute force ejection from FOX are any indication). This is in a climate of probably some of the best science fiction ever aired (Devs, Watchmen, Westworld, Expanse, Discovery, Picard, Legion, etc) so it suffers even more from the comparison.
Will Lower Decks reach the audience its trying to reach with CBSAA's intelligent decision to appeal to a wider age group? Who knows.
You're right, it looks a lot better than Orville.
I think the Orville fandom is doing fine.
Perhaps 1/3rd less pee pee and fart jokes is part of the equation.
Cool. It's the only one of these silly space operas I can be bothered to give a shit about these days.
The trailer is on the official website now for those who don't want to use twitter
Edit: Oh RAMA already posted it whoops
Separate names with a comma.