• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Lost 5x15: "Follow the Leader"

Grade the episode...


  • Total voters
    62
^^ BAH! Kate is Kate, and all she cares about is herself, no matter how much she claims to be concerned about other people.
 
If Kate was thoughtful and considerate about everyone else, she'd walk around the island naked.
 
Above average. Which has been the norm week after week! These guys are consistently consistent!

All aspects were great. They're setting up the big finale where some are for and against attempting the change. Will they pull off the attempt? And, if they do, does it actually reset things? Speculation follows . . .

I don't think we'll get anything as simple as a yes, it worked as planned. Or no, it didn't work (either because the attempt didn't happen or it happened but just didn't change things). I don't even think we'll get, oops, they caused "The incident". We'll get another twist. Remember, Jack, Hurley, etc aren't even supposed to be there. So, they've already changed the past and that's rippled through to the present (witness the photo). The only question is, what kind of change will they kick-off? And therein lies the source of the twist I'm guessing.

My prediction: the season will end after the attempt we'll see some sort of new, alternate reality. I don't know what exactly. I wouldn't be surprised if reality changed but our characters, protected by the island, did not change. Thus, negating any desire to erase their agony.

I'm also expecting that we'll finally be transported back in time enough to see the civilization that built the statue and temples. And really learn, what lies in the shadow of the statue.

We may get a sneak peak in the finale but I think those will be themes that are really developed next season.

Mr Awe
 
Claire wasn't strongly considering abortion, she was 8+ months pregnant and gave birth shortly after the crash.

She was going to LA to give Aaron up for adoption.
 
Claire wasn't strongly considering abortion, she was 8+ months pregnant and gave birth shortly after the crash.

She was going to LA to give Aaron up for adoption.

My mistake. I knew I had a 50/50 chance of getting it right.
 
Actually if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth. If Locke doesn't crash on the Island, he doesn't bang on Desmond's hatch just when Des is about to commit suicide. If he wasn't there, Des would have killed himself, and 120 minutes later the Swan black hole would have swallowed the Earth and killed all of humanity.
 
Actually if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth. If Locke doesn't crash on the Island, he doesn't bang on Desmond's hatch just when Des is about to commit suicide. If he wasn't there, Des would have killed himself, and 120 minutes later the Swan black hole would have swallowed the Earth and killed all of humanity.
The only reason Desmond is there is because Dharma kept drilling and hit a pocket of energy. After that, Dharma built the hatch and installed the computer with the timing mechanism for the button to be pushed.


One curiosity -- what about the Dharma supply planes that air-dropped food that the Losties picked up in Season 2?
 
One curiosity -- what about the Dharma supply planes that air-dropped food that the Losties picked up in Season 2?

I was thinking it came through one of the time shifts and suddenly appeared during season 2. Of course it would have been sent out after the Swan station was built as it was a drop real close to it. But from where? Naomi's helicopter couldn't see the Island through the clouds and if the Island is constantly moving they would have to use the Lamp Post to get close.

Will we get an answer?

Did Locke, in 1954, mention Jacob to Richard when entering the camp?
 
If Ilana's group is really the current incarnation of the Dharma Initative, that would explain the food drops. They wanted to keep the Swan supplied to make sure their lone survivor kept pressing the button to prevent the planet from being destroyed!
 
I don't know, I think ignoring the fact that everyone who'd survived the crash but died later, and everyone on the plane who didn't survive the crash, would get to land in Los Angeles safely and continue on with their lives if Jack was right, makes Kate just a teensy bit more insensitive than Jack.
I don't think Kate is being insensitive towards those from Oceanic Flight 815 who have already died. I think she's being mindful of those who are still alive! What assurance does Jack have that detonating the bomb will reset everything? A dead man's best guess? That's quite a risk. Remember, this is the same guy (Jack) who thought that freighter approaching the island was a rescue vessel....
I don't think Kate cares about anyone else if they can't benefit her in some form or another. Any reasonable person with a conscience would be willing to take that risk if it meant saving everyone who'd suffered and died over the past three years because of the crash. I know I would be.

And that dead man knew a hell of a lot more about what was going on and what he was talking about than Kate could ever hope to understand. I certainly would have trusted Daniel. Kate is now the Jack to Jack's Locke--and which of those two turned out to be right in the end?
 
Actually if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth. If Locke doesn't crash on the Island, he doesn't bang on Desmond's hatch just when Des is about to commit suicide. If he wasn't there, Des would have killed himself, and 120 minutes later the Swan black hole would have swallowed the Earth and killed all of humanity.
Is this true? I mean, eventually that button was not pushed and the world didn't end.
 
Actually if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth. If Locke doesn't crash on the Island, he doesn't bang on Desmond's hatch just when Des is about to commit suicide. If he wasn't there, Des would have killed himself, and 120 minutes later the Swan black hole would have swallowed the Earth and killed all of humanity.
Is this true? I mean, eventually that button was not pushed and the world didn't end.

It's not true because there never would have been a button in the first place if the Incident is prevented. The whole point of preventing the Incident is that it means they never have to set up that system in the Swan where you have to keep pressing the button. Thus, "if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth" is faulty logic.
 
You're right, I wasn't thinking that the Swan would never exist, just that the plane wouldn't crash.
 
The Swan would exist, just for a different purpose. They're already building it, now.
 
The Swan would exist, just for a different purpose. They're already building it, now.

No, because Jack will have to detonate the Nuke right above/around the Swan station since that is where the unstable energy is. So where the Swan is would/will be a radioactive crater in 2004.
 
The Swan would exist, just for a different purpose. They're already building it, now.

No, because Jack will have to detonate the Nuke right above/around the Swan station since that is where the unstable energy is. So where the Swan is would/will be a radioactive crater in 2004.
A Hydrogen bomb wouldn't leave radioactivity for very long.
 
Actually if Jack prevents Oceanic 815 from crashing on the Island, he would destroy the planet Earth. If Locke doesn't crash on the Island, he doesn't bang on Desmond's hatch just when Des is about to commit suicide. If he wasn't there, Des would have killed himself, and 120 minutes later the Swan black hole would have swallowed the Earth and killed all of humanity.
Is this true? I mean, eventually that button was not pushed and the world didn't end.

As far as we know, it didn't. :evil:

Everything is up in the air, pending the "game changer" next week. What this show's definition of "game changer" is, boggles my mind.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top