• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Longest Trek Episode?

Python Trek

Commodore
Commodore
Which Trek episode covered the longest period of time? The ones that leap immediately to my mind are TOS' "The Paradise Syndrome" and VOY's "Resolutions". I think each of those took place over a couple of months.

Thoughts?
 
enterprise's the expanse perhaps. it took weeks to get back to earth after the xindi attacked, months to fix and upgrade the ship in the dock, and more months to reach the expanse. remarkable is that the stubborn klingon hanged on all the time.
 
Also, Voyager's "Before and After" spans a lot of time as well... quite a bit more than a year depending on how you look at it.
 
For the purposes of this discussion I think it needs to be time that passes in the actual timeline, without getting rewritten. things like YOH, the Visitor, Inner light etc. shouldn't count.
 
Probably All Our Yesterdays (Star Trek) or Living Witness (Voyager).
 
For the purposes of this discussion I think it needs to be time that passes in the actual timeline, without getting rewritten. things like YOH, the Visitor, Inner light etc. shouldn't count.

Spoilsport. I was going to say the shortest episode is probably TOS's "The Naked Time" which apparently ended before it started!

In fact, I have a theory one of the reasons for the Enterprise's legendary speed records is that when it arrived at the next destination after Psi 2000 two days early, Kirk neglected to explain how they got there so fast.

Robert
 
:D

The Paradise Syndrome took place over almost a year.

This one's easy: Spock tells us that the time-consuming part of the episode, the slow coasting of the ship back to the planet apace with the giant asteroid, took exactly 59.223 days. He also tells that the trip to the asteroid at the beginning took "hours", and that the teaser and adjoining search of Kirk was limited to 30 minutes max. And for the final events of the episode, he specified that the asteroid would arrive four hours after the ship did.

So we get an exact duration of sixty days, no more, for the entire adventure. Unless we assume that Spock's 59.223 days were at very high sublight speed (after all, the reverse journey had taken "hours" at speeds up to warp nine), and that time dilation meant that a lot more time would pass for Kirok down on the planet... But there's a weakness in that: McCoy also estimated a two-month journey earlier on, and he'd be speaking from not just the layman's point of view (even laymen might get relativity when it affects their everyday lives), but from the planetside point of view. He clearly says the planet has two months till the asteroid arrives!

So, sixty days. Some nondescript episode like "Explorers" might easily log more than that.

And my candidate for the episode spanning the longest time interval would be "Death Wish", since it's the only episode where our heroes go all the way back to the Big Bang (even "All Good Things.." only goes a few billion years back). But within the rules of "the characters must have lived through all of it, no reset button", I must agree that "The Expanse" gets some sort of a prize. Although those rules might allow for "Blink of an Eye" as well, since several important characters experience decades - and their culture centuries - of very real passage of time which is not reversed for them. A main character adds two non-reset years to his life, even.

Although in the latter respect, Picard's added decades from "Inner Light" and O'Brien's jail sentence from "Hard Time" (neither of which was negated psychologically, even if neither aged the heroes physically) get the two top prizes. The EMH's stay on the "Blink" planet wins in a different category, though, as he did age physically.

Timo Saloniemi
 
Well, Timo, I must admit it's been a while since I saw the episode. I must have mixed in my memories of the James Blish adaptation, which was explicit in stating it was the better part of a year.

We all make mistakes.
 
Oh, sorry, it definitely wasn't my intention to upstage you on Trek trivia... I apologize for being a smartass. "Paradise Syndrome" just happens to be a fun episode in that we get such an exact account on the passage of time there.

It's also a somewhat problematic episode, exacty because of that exact account. How come six months of sublight travel one way (towards the planet) amounts to several hours of warp nine travel the other way (from the planet to the rock, at the beginning of the ep)? Shouldn't warp nine be way faster than that?

The problem becames less severe if we assume the sublight travel was at very high speed, perhaps close to lightspeed. This also helps explain how our heroes could not save the planet with their tractor beams and phasers, even though a tiny course change at a six-month distance ought to be enough to steer the rock past the planet - unless the rock was moving at immense speed. But other problems them emerge, such as the rock casting a shadow on the planet long before its arrival, and creating storms there, and whatnot; there shouldn't be time for such things if the rock traveled at a high fraction of lightspeed.

Frustratingly, one can't find a "sweet spot" for the figures, one where warp nine doesn't become unduly slow but the other weirdness related to really high speed asteroids doesn't yet emerge. But it's a fun source of strange datapoints in any argument of "how fast is warp anyway?"...

Timo Saloniemi
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top