• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Logical inconsistencies within Star Trek episodes

One that always bothered me was Data being infected in 'The Naked Now'. He gives a little speech to Picard about how he can 'leak' also if injured when questioned about it. To me a machine in humanoid form is just that- aside from mimicking a structure there should logically be no common biologic elements. The mutated PSI2000 virus affected the organic brain in a fashion similar to alcohol, why should it have an identical affect on a Positronic computer?
The Loopy Data was fun to watch and he did have some fun with Tasha, but it never did make sense to me.
 
Spock "reverts" to his savage Vulcan ancestry in the Sarpeidon ice age.
I think Spock has a on-going low level mental contact with all Vulcans, like a vague mind meld. This is how he felt the Intrepid "die."

His connection with the savage Vulcans then on Vulcan was influancing him and his behavior.

***

In the case of Data, I understand he was originally supposed to be a bio-mechnical being, and so would be capable of being infected by a virus.

:)
 
Swahili came back to her more quickly, English more slowly.
Indicating that (perhaps) Swahili is Uhura's native language, what she spoke as a child. But English was learned later, maybe in High School or after she entered Starfleet Academy.

What Nomad did to her might have been similar to a stroke, all the information is still there, but you have to relearn how to get to it.

:)


But NOMAD itself said:

NOMAD: The unit Scott required simple structural repair. The knowledge banks of this unit have been wiped clean.

So NOMAD didn't understand what it did?--Which I'd have guessed was a cut and paste job with Uhura's knowledge the files. But it was clearly interested in what she knew, hence the "think about music" command. It wasn't using something it considered a weapon, I'd say, something that scrambled her for the sake of scrambling her. It was more like it was interfacing with another machine to gather data. But not copy and paste, cut and paste, if we can believe NOMAD itself.


NOMAD refers to her knowledge banks. I don't know about others, but I don't usually think of my first language as "knowledge," although I know that it is. I think of it as part of my inherent, day-to-day makeup, that is, speaking with other people, reading, etc, are so ingrained as instant habit that they're nothing like, say, learning a branch of math you never studied before, or learning 100 new songs. Could be equivalent to a computer's operating system instead of data files, and maybe NOMAD viewed such deeply ingrained parts of a biological unit's functioning as its operating system, separate from its "knowledge." So Uhura wouldn't have lost her first language (but almost all else).

NOMAD could have been in error.

After all we know of at least 3 errors it made which Kirk pointed out to it.
 
Spock "reverts" to his savage Vulcan ancestry in the Sarpeidon ice age.
I think Spock has a on-going low level mental contact with all Vulcans, like a vague mind meld. This is how he felt the Intrepid "die."

His connection with the savage Vulcans then on Vulcan was influancing him and his behavior.


:)


That's pretty good. I'll buy that. I like how that implies, also, that telepathy and related psionic stuff aren't limited by light speed in the Trekverse (else how would the meld be maintained when a ship is traveling at warp speeds?). Weren't there a number of occasions when Troi's abilities had to be working faster than light speed? This would make Vulcan abilities' limitations consistent with those of other telepathic or semitelepathic races.
 
Along those lines, I'm really surprised that follow-up research is rarely, if ever, mentioned outside of expanded media. Kirk and Picard made some groundbreaking discoveries when faced with alien technology or the solution to whatever unique anomaly or problem they faced, and no doubt that's all documented through their logs. But there isn't even a hint as far as the live-action media goes with Starfleet's concerns about it. I'd be very much interested in their assesment of the Dyson Sphere, for example. Nanites were mentioned once more, as a potential weapon -- how about as part of ship maintenance or medical treatment? (I know Voyager mentioned nanites, but that's their ingenuity and not Starfleet) Were any lessons learned from the whale probe disaster? Et all. Our heroes did their part, so it'd be nice to see Starfleet handle their end.
 
All the research, analysis, and log entries by Kirk and Picard were consigned to a huge warehouse in the Starfleet Archives and never seen again.
 
In 'Plato's Stepchildren' McCoy quickly rigs up an injection of kironide which provides Kirk with the same Telekinetic powers, that was immediately forgotten although it would have proven very useful in later shows.
 
In The Wire Odo has full video surveillance on Quark.

In many other episodes things transpire in Quark's bar that Odo has to investigate.
 
Yet other logical inconsistencies:
TOS-Arena:
The Gorn - "nice" fellows that they are - killed every man, woman and child in a human colony as a 'no trespassing' sign.

Enterprise chases the gorn ship into metron territory:
"METRON: We are the Metrons. You are one of two crafts which have come into our space on a mission of violence. This is not permissible. Yet we have analysed you and have learned that your violent tendencies are inherent. So be it. We will control them. We will resolve your conflict in the way most suited to your limited mentalities.[...]We have prepared a planet with a suitable atmosphere. You will be taken there, as will the Captain of the Gorn ship which you have been pursuing. There you will settle your dispute.[...]The winner of the contest will be permitted to go his way unharmed. The loser, along with his ship, shall be destroyed in the interests of peace. The contest will be one of ingenuity against ingenuity, brute strength against brute strength. The results will be final."

So, the metrons - supposedly, moral beings who dislike violence, as per the authors' intent - said that they'll annihilate the loser's ship.
Which raises the question - why did the metrons interfere at all? Why didn't they let the federates and the gorn fight it out? The result would be the same.
The metrons only changed the fight from ship-vs-ship to man-vs-man. And promised to destroy the loser's ship themselves - the personal touch.
Their explanation - it's more suited to primitive mentalities. That's why they arranged a gladiator fight to the death and watched, in order to see which ship they'll destroy.
Not very civilized on the metron's part. But wait - they keep preaching 'peace', so it's all right.

And there's more - Kirk, apparently, agrees that the metrons are the ultimate in moral accomplishment:
"METRON: Very good, Captain. There is hope for you. Perhaps in several thousand years, your people and mine shall meet to reach an agreement. You are still half savage, but there is hope.
[...]
KIRK: We're a most promising species, Mister Spock, as predators go.
[...]
KIRK: And maybe in a thousand years or so, we'll be able to prove it."

I guess Kirk thinks Magna Roma is the ultimate in moral achievent, as well. Or, at least, he would have thought so, were he one of the spectators delecting themselves watching a fight to the death, as opposed to a gladiator.
 
TOS-Arena:
METRON: The loser, along with his ship, shall be destroyed in the interests of peace.

So, the metrons - supposedly, moral beings who dislike violence, as per the authors' intent - said that they'll annihilate the loser's ship.
Which raises the question - why did the metrons interfere at all? Why didn't they let the federates and the gorn fight it out? The result would be the same.
The metrons only changed the fight from ship-vs-ship to man-vs-man. And promised to destroy the loser's ship themselves - the personal touch.
Their explanation - it's more suited to primitive mentalities. That's why they arranged a gladiator fight to the death and watched, in order to see which ship they'll destroy.
Not very civilized on the metron's part. But wait - they keep preaching 'peace', so it's all right.

The Metrons are deceptive beings, because they don't reveal their true intentions until the end. There's really not much evidence that they're morally superior and devoted to peace. They're only concerned about maintaining the peace within their own immediate space. They actually intend to destroy the winners of the contest, who might pose a threat to their own safety, but lie about it to provide an incentive to win.

I think the James Blish story adaptation reveals this earlier, though it's been so long I may be thinking of fanzine analysis during the 70s-80s.
 
Every time Kirk does a log entry when it either makes no sense at all to make a log entry at that very moment, or when he shouldn't be able to make an entry because he's not on the ship, has no communicator, etc...

The idea that logical Vulcans, who seek a state of no emotions because of their violent history, are prejudiced and racists, and would stop talk to their children because of a decision they didn't like.

Kruge asking random people to give them Genesis. What did he expect to receive?

Geordi has a huge group of engineers, including Barclay, but when the Enterprise gets trapped in an energy dampening field, he goes alone to the holodeck to talk to a holo-engineer, wasting energy.
 
Last edited:
Kruge asking random people to give them Genesis. What did he expect to receive?

People do this in real life, demanding someone to give them something in a box or a bag they think it might be something to profit or enjoy or whatever without really knowing what the contents were.
 
The transporter accident in TMP. I could never buy into the idea that the transporter, which Decker/Scotty are working on when Kirk arrives and interrupts them, and, tho it gets "a back-up sensor," is all of a sudden beaming up people without any kind of testing first.
 
Kruge asking random people to give them Genesis. What did he expect to receive?

People do this in real life, demanding someone to give them something in a box or a bag they think it might be something to profit or enjoy or whatever without really knowing what the contents were.

I don't think that applies here. They could have either given him the project data files, the blueprint of the Genesis torpedo, or the torpedo itself. And that's it.

Nobody would have taken a Manhattan project scientist hostage at the bomb test site, just demanding "Give me Manhattan!" They would have either wanted access to the project files, the plutonium, or the bomb itself.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top