But if the show were to approach the style of the reboot - more action, more tension, with character conflict, charisma and "consistency", I don't see a problem with a show being sold on any network if done right.
If that were true, then where are all the action-packed space operas on network TV?
Networks don't like shows with too-freaky topics. Aliens are too freaky. Even an action-packed show with aliens would still be off-putting for the mass audience. They can't relate to green people, and if they see one, they change the channel. They just want cops.
Networks won't take risks. Basic cable takes a few risks. Premium cable takes more. HBO is doing okay with
Game of Thrones, which is a topic that is no less freaky than space opera. HBO doesn't need a mass audience of people who won't change the channel if they see something freaky - a few million viewers is just fine.
My hope is that
Game of Thrones' example emboldens Showtime to take a gamble on
Star Trek. What both have in common is a dedicated core fanbase of people who probably aren't currently subscribers, but are big enough fans to spring for an extra $10/month.
It's a reason why shows like Fringe and Supernatural are so popular and have lasted for so long.
Those are both the "safe" kind of sci fi which is all the networks go for anymore: based in a recognizable, modern-day Earth milieu, with familiar cop show elements (missions, guns, FBI agents, etc). The networks are developing a bunch more shows like this for next fall: cop shows with fantasy and sci fi elements. But no space operas at all.
