MY REVIEW:
*****LIGHT SPOILERS*******
I thought the film was terrific. It didn't run too long or too short - the length was appropriate for the story that they were telling. The sound and visuals were of course second to none with some of the most impressive battle sequences ever seen in a Star Trek film. Leonard Nemoy's appearance was also handled quite well as they did not milk his presence on screen nor did they make any reference to the universe he came from. However, I felt that a lot of potential was lost for Simon Pegg's Scotty as we're only introduced to him in the last 45 minutes of the film.
As for the performances, generally they were pretty solid. A special mention goes to Zachary Quinto who made the role of Spock his own, meanwhile, Kirk is also well played (I missed the actors name here). Ulhura was also terrific here. Finally, the role of Captain Pine was played perfectly. However, some of the performances didn't go without the cringe factor. The Chekov character felt quite forced and comedic (at best). Doctor McCoy was hit and miss but certainly didn't go without some memorable moments. Meanwhile, Simon Pegg's Scotty (as mentioned) never really had his full potential realised. I felt Eric Bana (for the most part) did a really good job as Nero, though, like McCoy, his performance didn't go without the lesser moments.
As for the story, it's terrific. It's straight forward, action packed and a lot of fun. There were a couple (literally) of plot holes that I wish to address but I won't discuss them until more people have seen the film. There is also one major plot device that will change the face of Star Trek for quite some time and will no doubt anger long term fans - this is for you to discover!
I also must say I did enjoy a lot of the modern elements of the film such as a young Kirk speeding along a highway listening to the Beastie Boys while answering his Nokia communicator. At the same time, some of it can be a little forced with the testosterone induced fist fights that Kirk seems to involve himself in with fellow officers, not to mention the bitchier side of the Vulcans being exposed. Throw in some sexy college dorm shenanigans, the film (at times) can feel a little dumbed down. But is definitely doesn't let the film down in anyway. The modernisation is much needed after the stiffness of the latter Trek from 2000-2003.
Overall, a terrific film with some minor flaws and a promising new beginning!
4 out of 5