• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is Kathleen Kennedy Ruining Star Wars (a catchall thread)

Is Kathleen Kennedy doing a bad job?

  • Yes, she will soon ruin Star Wars

    Votes: 2 7.1%
  • Yes, she will soon be fired

    Votes: 2 7.1%
  • She is doing OK, lets see where she takes the franchise

    Votes: 18 64.3%
  • No, Star Wars has never been healthier! Thank you Kathleen!

    Votes: 6 21.4%

  • Total voters
    28
Status
Not open for further replies.
Who's to say there are even humans in the Star Wars universe?

Just because Han and Leia look like us doesn't mean they are the same species....
 
You are a racist. Don't bother responding. You've outed yourself.
Ugh, I am going to get banned again, but I can't in good conscience tolerate a race war baiting white guilt riddled racist...
All-white or 99% white film casts were the default in Hollywood from its inception, even when it was a movie about Mongols or Native Americans or Egyptians, and overwhelmingly white casts are still the norm today despite LA and SoCal being an incredibly diverse area (as are most other popular film locations).

While I don't personally see the need to exclude white actors from a film unless it's about a region or subject matter where that would make sense, instead preferring to see greater proportional representation (relative to population) for minority and female actors, him suggesting that does not in any way make him a racist, because the imbalance in favor of white people over the past century would take decades or more to correct, and being denied one film does not create an exclusion for the hundreds of others being produced in any given year.

What's wrong with my posting history?

Other than that, I fight the good fight and only call out people who deserve it.
You're a frequent shit-stirrer. You're needlessly hostile and go on the attack when it's not called for. Sometimes it's against people who are generally annoying (not including you in that group, fireproof), but it's even when they are not doing anything wrong at the time, so it still makes you come off looking bad or that you're trolling for a response.

Then you have weird over-the-top defensive reactions to stuff like you're part of some oppressed underclass. Get a grip.
 
All-white or 99% white film casts were the default in Hollywood from its inception, even when it was a movie about Mongols or Native Americans or Egyptians, and overwhelmingly white casts are still the norm today despite LA and SoCal being an incredibly diverse area (as are most other popular film locations).

While I don't personally see the need to exclude white actors from a film unless it's about a region or subject matter where that would make sense, instead preferring to see greater proportional representation (relative to population) for minority and female actors, him suggesting that does not in any way make him a racist, because the imbalance in favor of white people over the past century would take decades or more to correct, and being denied one film does not create an exclusion for the hundreds of others being produced in any given year.


You're a frequent shit-stirrer. You're needlessly hostile and go on the attack when it's not called for. Sometimes it's against people who are generally annoying (not including you in that group, fireproof), but it's even when they are not doing anything wrong at the time, so it still makes you come off looking bad or that you're trolling for a response.

Then you have weird over-the-top defensive reactions to stuff like you're part of some oppressed underclass. Get a grip.
I've been raised to say what's right, and I will not be oppressed. Will never tolerate trolls nor racists.
 
She's making it the way she wants and bringing in the people she wants. The same way any show with any one at the helm does. When making something, how does one know if it's going to work or not since the goal is to make money? Especially when soft reboots have happened before and to critical acclaim, such as BSG'04?

Do I thiink the ST can be better? Yep. Same for the PT, OT, and pretty much anything. That aside, does what works outdo what doesn't? YMMV based on who's sitting in the theater chair.

Heck, noting that the 1977 original flick (sans edit three years later to become "Episode IV") needed a bunch of edits juggled about (there's an interesting extra bonus feature, the very original edit... *shudder* ), the same criticisms and worse could be applied to anyone in charge of that. movie. too. /cheapmelodrama
 
You literally admitted to being a full on racist earlier, and now you think it's a joke?
I think the reaction to my comment is a joke. I admitted to nothing of the sort, as evidenced by the reaction of several others in this thread.

I simply stated a desire to see a SW movie with a non-white cast. This is largely due to the fact that the majority of films, especially the OT and PT, revolved around white cast members. ANH is almost exclusively white. So, I wouldn't mind seeing a film with a nonwhite cast, or better representation of diversity overall. More diversity is not racist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top