• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

I'm doing a rewatch of Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda.

@Gingerbread Demon--are you going to post thoughts on individual episodes?

No not really. There's a few episodes that I love such as the one with the Bellerophon but for the most part I really don't wish to post my thoughts on individual episodes, but feel free if there are ones you would like to talk about ask away. For me all the seasons felt different and unique, season 1 of course was the strongest. Each felt uniquely its own even though there was a thin story linking them all together with the Magog worldship and the Abyss but the latter I felt kind of goofy. I find it a bit odd that this hateful being that wanted to kill everything in the universe deep down had love. I felt that frankly was a bit juvenile of the writers as if they didn't know what to do with the Abyss, it felt pointless.
 
I'll settle for an explanation as to what exactly the hell the fifth season was supposed to be about.

I mean, I haven't been that confused since I last watched a David Lynch movie. :confused:
 
Is there a way to watch it without finding Kevin Sorbo so annoying that the reflex to turn it off becomes overpowering? I couldn't get beyond the first episode. I can't stand seeing the guy act in anything. I know it's irrational but there you go...

Um..yeah, pretty easy. Focus on all the other characters, who have "better" actors.

I would say it's like Babylon 5 and The Outpost. the lead characters were the most bland of the cast. But the supporting cast was so good, that the leads' lack of skill didn't bother me.


I always liked the first season theme song. Very unique. Not generic like the other seasons.

Written by the one and only legendary Rush guitarist Alex Lifeson! One of the only reasons I watched the show in the first place. The first season was enjoyable, but I lost interest into the second season and never picked it up.

That theme sounded truly alien, and should be a standard for sci-fi themes.

Oh, and i felt the end of season 4, they were getting back to what season 1 was about (in terms of how it "felt").

Then we had season 5.
 
I'll settle for an explanation as to what exactly the hell the fifth season was supposed to be about.

I mean, I haven't been that confused since I last watched a David Lynch movie. :confused:


I think someone here said it but season 5 is as close as you get to "christian scifi" and yeah I can see it, I skipped over season 5 this time and feel happy that I chose to do that.

OMG could you imagine Christian Star Trek, there would be no aliens at all it would just be BSG with more God
 
I think someone here said it but season 5 is as close as you get to "christian scifi" and yeah I can see it, I skipped over season 5 this time and feel happy that I chose to do that.

OMG could you imagine Christian Star Trek, there would be no aliens at all it would just be BSG with more God

You want "Christian Star Trek," watch the closing scene of "Bread and Circuses."

There's always been science fiction with a Christian viewpoint, implicitly or explicitly -- especially in the mass media, when anything that wasn't consistent with Christian beliefs would've been too controversial and gotten censored. Look at, say, the climax of The War of the Worlds, where everyone huddles in a church as the Martians close in and their death due to Earth's microbes is essentially played as a miracle sent down by God.
 
You want "Christian Star Trek," watch the closing scene of "Bread and Circuses."

There's always been science fiction with a Christian viewpoint, implicitly or explicitly -- especially in the mass media, when anything that wasn't consistent with Christian beliefs would've been too controversial and gotten censored. Look at, say, the climax of The War of the Worlds, where everyone huddles in a church as the Martians close in and their death due to Earth's microbes is essentially played as a miracle sent down by God.

Oh there's that one for sure but even Wells original story had the microbes being our saviours, though his writing style God was mentioned a lot more too.

I mean more implicitly and direct. I'd love to see a Star Trek kind of show with a full on christian theme just to see how they would do it. Would they even include aliens or leave that out altogether and make it totally human centric because all of creation belongs to man which is what some people I know with that faith seem to believe, they just can't reconcile God would create any other kind of intelligent life beyond humans.
 
I mean more implicitly and direct. I'd love to see a Star Trek kind of show with a full on christian theme just to see how they would do it. Would they even include aliens or leave that out altogether and make it totally human centric because all of creation belongs to man which is what some people I know with that faith seem to believe, they just can't reconcile God would create any other kind of intelligent life beyond humans.

There's no one way to be Christian. Many great scientists have been devout believers and had no problem with the idea of aliens.

Religion is like fandom -- for some, it inspires them to broaden their minds and look for new possibilities, while others use it as an excuse to build walls and judge anyone who doesn't fit their own narrow definitions. And the people in the latter category always insist they're the only "true" believers/fans, yet they usually completely miss the point of the thing they claim exclusive ownership of.
 
There's no one way to be Christian. Many great scientists have been devout believers and had no problem with the idea of aliens.

Religion is like fandom -- for some, it inspires them to broaden their minds and look for new possibilities, while others use it as an excuse to build walls and judge anyone who doesn't fit their own narrow definitions. And the people in the latter category always insist they're the only "true" believers/fans, yet they usually completely miss the point of the thing they claim exclusive ownership of.

Oh totally agree with you..... I'm half tempted to start writing again and do one of these. I sort of did that a while back but got bogged down with writers block and never finished the story I had started. I think next year once facebook is gone I shall.
 
I remember way back in the day reading a chat transcript on Andromeda's official site during its 3rd season with one of the producers, where the concern of Andromeda following in the same downward spiral that plagued Earth: Final Conflict were brought up. Of course the producers were reassuring that that would not happen. I guess if you consider retaining most of your original cast as not following in the same trajectory as EFC that remained true, but personally I'd rather rewatch Earth Final Conflict than Andromeda.
 
I remember way back in the day reading a chat transcript on Andromeda's official site during its 3rd season with one of the producers, where the concern of Andromeda following in the same downward spiral that plagued Earth: Final Conflict were brought up. Of course the producers were reassuring that that would not happen.

By season 3, it was already happening. Bringing in Bob Engels as showrunner wasn't a downward spiral, it was an immediate plummet.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top