• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If you could live in the ST Universe rather than ours, would you?

No. Considering the era we would be coming from, it seems like people would go out of their way to regard you as a curiosity at best, a total misfit at worst.

It's such a different world from ours, could any one of us say we would really belong there?
 
^ People are adaptable and flexible.

Apparently Gillian Taylor got along just fine.

Yes, I would live there.

Kor
 
Pros:

No poverty to worry about
No racism, sexism, homophobia, or any other isms
No religious strife or wars
You rarely get sick, long life
Technology advancements everywhere

Cons:

Humans seem to be culturally bland and rigid
No TV media or version of the internet
The dominant music seems to be classical or jazz
The main form of entertainment seems to watching plays
The drinks of choice are tea

Anyone in their right mind would choose the Trek universe.

But some of these cultural limitations makes you want to reconsider. Based on TNG, human society seems real boring. It seems like they let go of a lot of exciting things to obtain their utopia.


Funny but even if they had TV in the Trek universe, it would be probably boring by our standards anyway. Why would future humans want to watch stories about strife, scheming to get rich, sexual intrigue ect?

They've evolved beyond that!
 
In Star Trek, you have a society with a post scarcity economy, interstellar space travel, sentient robots that can be your friend, almost magical medical technology, magical and limitless energy, limitless (apparently) free food and drink, magical holographic entertainment technology to make your every fantasy real (at least for a little while), magical technology in general, communicators so you can keep in touch at all times, monitor your vital signs at all times, and let the higher ups know your location and what you are doing at all times, transporter technology allowing instantaneous travel which also leads to questions of a metaphysical nature, people who use the holodeck to create replicas of you to ridicule, abuse, assault, and rape, killer robots, a class system despite the absence of money, population control through colonization, impoverished colonies despite a post scarcity economy, colonies wiped out by aggressive alien species, aggressive alien species, aggressive alien disease, and the likelihood of being murdered by a fucking cloud. Fuck Star Trek. Who the hell would want to live in that nightmare?

Well said! :techman:
 
To be honest, probably not. Culture is stagnant in the 24th century. No new movies, no TV, no new music, and the only new literature was written by Jake Sisko in an alternate timeline. Okay, so there's holodecks as the primary entertainment medium, but even then, the popular programs are based on Shakespeare, Sherlock Holmes, a 1940s noir detective, and a Flash Gordon-esque adventure program.

It's as if art development just came to a screeching halt sometime during the 21st century. Even much of the civilian wear seen in Enterprise is too contemporary.
 
Nah. I'm good. If there's no such thing as drama or conflict amongst humans, how do we encourage each other to be better people? Forget the medical tech, the holodeck, the starships. That'd all be pretty cool, sure. But the idea of bettering ourselves just cuz is pretty flimsy. We'd get bored. And at that point, a civilization becomes stagnant and dies. No thank you.
 
If I were transplanted into the 23rd/24th Century, one of the first things I would do (after they set me up with housing, which of course they would do) is search the house computer for a record of all video games of the 20th and 21st centuries....or rather, search all interactive entertainment as available... and have a time! :D

Would I want to live in the 23rd or 24th century? Hmmm..... there are compelling pros and cons that have been presented.

No money? No problem.
Equality for all? Excellent.
Political Correctness? Shouldn't even be needed if the Federation is all about equality anyway.
Holodecks (24th Century)... let the games and adventures begin!
 
If I were transplanted into the 23rd/24th Century, one of the first things I would do (after they set me up with housing, which of course they would do) is search the house computer for a record of all video games of the 20th and 21st centuries....or rather, search all interactive entertainment as available... and have a time! :D

You'd get there and find out they were all destroyed during World War III. :eek:
 
I wouldn't even think twice about it. I was so jealous of Gillian Taylor when she got to travel to the future at the end of Star Trek IV.
 
If I were transplanted into the 23rd/24th Century, one of the first things I would do (after they set me up with housing, which of course they would do) is search the house computer for a record of all video games of the 20th and 21st centuries....or rather, search all interactive entertainment as available... and have a time! :D

You'd get there and find out they were all destroyed during World War III. :eek:

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!
 
If I were transplanted into the 23rd/24th Century, one of the first things I would do (after they set me up with housing, which of course they would do) is search the house computer for a record of all video games of the 20th and 21st centuries....or rather, search all interactive entertainment as available... and have a time! :D

You'd get there and find out they were all destroyed during World War III. :eek:

NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!

:lol:
 
As I said at the start of the thread. I don't know enough about the 24th Century to make an informed choice. Could be Earth and the other core worlds of the Federation are the gated communities of the Galaxy and once you get outside the "gates" things are different.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top