• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recasted

Lt. Cheka Wey

Lt. Cheka Wey

Commander
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

I changed the pics to links because I assumed that you don't all or really any of the webspace they're hosted on. Hotlinking is against the rules here.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Lt. Cheka Wey said:
And they would recasted the crew from the the Cage which actors should had portrayed the characters?
Click to expand...

Why didn't you leave Quinto in Spock's role ? Just curious.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Interesting question, interesting choices. I would say that Alyson Hannigan, born in 1974, is way too old for the part of Colt. Don't get me wrong, she looks great, but Colt was about 20 in "The Cage," and American Pie was a loooong time ago.

Michael Hogan as Boyce would be fascinating - I know him mostly from BSG, and playing a wise, caring mentor would be quite different from that role!
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Robert_T_April said:
I'm still wondering why they would do a reboot with the characters from an episode that was never even aired???
Click to expand...

It was aired but much later. First time I saw it was on syndication on ABC.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

The Cage was aired as The Menagerie Parts 1 and 2.

Pike is part of Bad Robot Trek.

No problemo.:techman:
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Belz

Why didn't you leave Quinto in Spock's role ? Just curious.
Click to expand...

Just curious how Morgan would do, i would also like to see a more immature Spock than we had ever seen onscreen. I think he could play one well.

Robert_T_April

I'm still wondering why they would do a reboot with the characters from an episode that was never even aired???
Click to expand...

This is just one of the half bilion what if threads that are floating around here.

Citizen:
Interesting question, interesting choices. I would say that Alyson Hannigan, born in 1974, is way too old for the part of Colt. Don't get me wrong, she looks great, but Colt was about 20 in "The Cage," and American Pie was a loooong time ago.
Click to expand...
Who would you pick instead?

And now with nonhotlinked pics:
Pike..........Greenwood

Spock.......Colin Morgan
http://img843.imageshack.us/img843/3121/thebeasttravisfimmel143.jpg

Philip Boyce-Michael Hogan
http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/8650/220pxmichaelhoganccjuly.jpg

José Tyler-Christopher Egan
http://img824.imageshack.us/img824/5307/eganchristopheregan2508.jpg

J.M. Colt-Alyson Hannigan

http://img90.imageshack.us/img90/9920/alysonhannigan2011cb200.jpg


Number One-Jennifer Beals

http://img855.imageshack.us/img855/2793/73575121897977871855358.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Belz... said:
It was aired but much later. First time I saw it was on syndication on ABC.
Click to expand...

First aired as part of "Star Trek Saga: From One Generation to the Next", after premiering on home video.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Lt. Cheka Wey said:
<snip>

And now with nonhotlinked pics:
Pike..........Greenwood

Spock.......Colin Morgan
http://img843.imageshack.us/img843/3121/thebeasttravisfimmel143.jpg

Philip Boyce-Michael Hogan
http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/8650/220pxmichaelhoganccjuly.jpg

José Tyler-Christopher Egan
http://img824.imageshack.us/img824/5307/eganchristopheregan2508.jpg

J.M. Colt-Alyson Hannigan

http://img90.imageshack.us/img90/9920/alysonhannigan2011cb200.jpg


Number One-Jennifer Beals

http://img855.imageshack.us/img855/2793/73575121897977871855358.jpg
Click to expand...
No, replacing hotlinks to images on colinmorganfan.com, fanpop.com, celebritybase.net, etc. with hotlinks to image-hosting accounts belonging to people who aren't you doesn't work, either. To post them as inline images, the pics will need to be uploaded to an account which is registered to you, and then linked from there.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Therin of Andor said:
Belz... said:
It was aired but much later. First time I saw it was on syndication on ABC.
Click to expand...

First aired as part of "Star Trek Saga: From One Generation to the Next", after premiering on home video.
Click to expand...
When was that, around 1988? I saw The Cage on tv, the version that was about half & half B/W and color, with Malachi Throne's unaltered Talosian voice in the B/W scenes. Roddenberry introduced it as I recall, explaining that they had found an original print and pieced it together with the only color scenes available from The Menagerie.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Carcazoid said:
When was that, around 1988? I saw The Cage on tv, the version that was about half & half B/W and color, with Malachi Throne's unaltered Talosian voice in the B/W scenes. Roddenberry introduced it as I recall, explaining that they had found an original print and pieced it together with the only color scenes available from The Menagerie.
Click to expand...

Yep. The b/w reels were from the "workprint", which GR used to show at university gatherings. After the b&w/color compile was put out on home video and then TV (within the "Saga" documentary") and got some new publicity, the original editor from Desilu realized he still had the missing color offcuts in his attic, and an all-color version was finally assembled.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

I did actually started thread like this couple years ago if they would do another Star Trek tv series. Anyway i do like Chris Egen as Jose Tyler but the rest isent that good. I feel Greenwood, Beals and Hannigan way too old for this.

I can see Castle actress Molly C. Quinn as Yaoman Colt. She is twenty and had also reddish hair.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

I agree about Hannigan. I don't know how old Majel was at the time but she looks mature like Beals. I had gone with Greeonwood out of respect for the new creative team.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Majel was 33-34 years old during Cage. Beals turns 50 this year so no way too mature for role Number One.
Greenwood(56) again just too old. Come on you most have some other alternatives than this old farts.
 
Last edited:
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Belas does not look 50, i could buy her as a 34.

ith whoom would you replace Greenwood.
 
Re: If the reboot would had involved Pike and crewAnd they would recas

Lt. Cheka Wey said:
Belas does not look 50, i could buy her as a 34.

ith whoom would you replace Greenwood.
Click to expand...

I think Beals looks great, but not early-mid 30s.

I was going to suggest Ben Browder for Pike, but he's 50, too.

And I agree that a reboot Pike and Number One should be younger than 50+.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top