Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Season 2

[idreamedmusic]

I don't think the rules should be changed, either. Aside from being unfair to S3 (as much as most of us would love to hurt certain eps more than once), the -2/+1 system works great, IMHO. It makes the finale that much better. I can hear the Amok Time fight music, yeah baby!

That said, one more hour till I can vote again, ack. Come on Butt-Fu!

 

[Mallory]

Actually I'd find it better if we'd keep the rules as they are at least for the third season. (1.) I don't really find it THAT slowly. (2.) Wouldn't it be a bit unfair to rate the third season by another system? We wouldn't really be able to compare the different season's rakings.

My suggestion was intended as a joke, based on the Third Season's somewhat questionable reputation. I'm perfectly fine with the rules as they are now. Sorry if I caused any confusion.

 

[Michael]

Actually I'd find it better if we'd keep the rules as they are at least for the third season. (1.) I don't really find it THAT slowly. (2.) Wouldn't it be a bit unfair to rate the third season by another system? We wouldn't really be able to compare the different season's rakings.

My suggestion was intended as a joke, based on the Third Season's somewhat questionable reputation. I'm perfectly fine with the rules as they are now. Sorry if I caused any confusion.

Yeah, I understood it as a joke. But ZERO seemed to miss that. But maybe you know that and just quoted the wrong post ...

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Actually I'd find it better if we'd keep the rules as they are at least for the third season. (1.) I don't really find it THAT slowly. (2.) Wouldn't it be a bit unfair to rate the third season by another system? We wouldn't really be able to compare the different season's rakings.

My suggestion was intended as a joke, based on the Third Season's somewhat questionable reputation. I'm perfectly fine with the rules as they are now. Sorry if I caused any confusion.

Actually I'd find it better if we'd keep the rules as they are at least for the third season. (1.) I don't really find it THAT slowly. (2.) Wouldn't it be a bit unfair to rate the third season by another system? We wouldn't really be able to compare the different season's rakings.

My suggestion was intended as a joke, based on the Third Season's somewhat questionable reputation. I'm perfectly fine with the rules as they are now. Sorry if I caused any confusion.

Yeah, I understood it as a joke. But ZERO seemed to miss that. But maybe you know that and just quoted the wrong post ...

Yes actually I did, I hang my head in emarrasment!

Still Im glad people are enjoying the game!

 

[Michael]

^ It's great fun! Thank you for bringing it to the Trek BBS.

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

^ It's great fun! Thank you for bringing it to the Trek BBS.

No! Thank you!

 

[idreamedmusic]

Six more mins and the Butt-Fu may have a chance. Me, sad? No way.

 

[Michael]

Midnight in Germany.

ETA: What's up with the board time?

Amok time 2 -
Journey to Babel 6 +

Eliminated:
03rd: Mirror, Mirror
04th: The Trouble with Tribbles
05th: The Doomsday Machine
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[idreamedmusic]

Wohoooo!
ETA: Yeah, def past midnight here. Time diff, it can be a nice thing.

Journey to Babel 7 +

Eliminated:
02nd: Amok Time -
03rd: Mirror, Mirror
04th: The Trouble with Tribbles
05th: The Doomsday Machine
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Season 3

is up and running now!

 

[Mallory]

I just want every one to know I will remember who kept The Apple out of the Top 10.

 

[Michael]

I just want every one to know I will remember who kept The Apple out of the Top 10.

Yeah, some people virtually scream for a permaban, what do you say?

 

[c5maier]

I just want every one to know I will remember who kept The Apple out of the Top 10.

That's just your fair return for conspiring with your co-moderator against "Bread and Circuses"!

 

[EnsignJulka]

I can't believe Amok Time is second! Tis a crying shame!

 

[Jackson_Roykirk]

I just want every one to know I will remember who kept The Apple out of the Top 10.

Well -- I don't like that episode because poor Mallory got "blowed up real good". He deserved better.

Seriously though, I think that list panned out almost exactly as I would have done it personally, with a few tweaks here and there. I really didn't mind Assignment: Earth that much and would have put it towards the middle of the list, and I would have moved Gamesters toward to bottom.