Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Season 2

[EnsignJulka]

Amok Time 21 +
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 11
Journey to Babel 18
Obsession 15
By Any Other Name 2 -
Return to Tomorrow 2
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Outpost4]

Amok Time 21
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 12 +
Journey to Babel 18
Obsession 15
By Any Other Name 2
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Orac]

Amok Time 21
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 18
Obsession 13 -
By Any Other Name 3 +
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[DevilintheDark]

Amok Time 22+
The Doomsday Machine 18-
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 18
Obsession 13
By Any Other Name 3
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Tallguy]

In some ways this is turning out to be an odd list...

Amok Time 20 -
The Doomsday Machine 18
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19 +
Obsession 13
By Any Other Name 3
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Amok Time 20
The Doomsday Machine 19 +
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 13
By Any Other Name 3
The Ultimate Computer 5 -

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Michael]

Amok Time 20
The Doomsday Machine 19
Mirror, Mirror 17 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 11 -
By Any Other Name 3
The Ultimate Computer 5

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Mallory]

Amok Time 20
The Doomsday Machine 19
Mirror, Mirror 17
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 9 -
By Any Other Name 3
The Ultimate Computer 6 +

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Geck]

Amok Time 20
The Doomsday Machine 19
Mirror, Mirror 17
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 10 +
By Any Other Name 1 -
The Ultimate Computer 6 +

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

Amok Time 18-
The Doomsday Machine 20+
Mirror, Mirror 17
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 10 +
By Any Other Name 1
The Ultimate Computer 6

Eliminated:
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[TigerOfDarkness]

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 17
The Trouble with Tribbles 12
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 7 +

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[hokstein]

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 15 -
The Trouble with Tribbles 13 +
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 7

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Defcon]

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 15
The Trouble with Tribbles 14 +
Journey to Babel 19
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 5 -

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Kagan]

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 15
The Trouble with Tribbles 14
Journey to Babel 20 +
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 3 -

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[hokstein]

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 15
The Trouble with Tribbles 15 +
Journey to Babel 20
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 1 -

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Michael]

The Ultimate Computer 1 -

LEAVE DAYSTROM ALONE! *sob*


Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 20
Mirror, Mirror 16 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 15
Journey to Babel 20
Obsession 8 -
The Ultimate Computer 1

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[c5maier]

Instead of sobbing, I am going to help it a little. Actually it does not seem such a strange list to me: All episodes left now are good and would deserve to win IMHO.

Amok Time 18
The Doomsday Machine 18 -
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 15
Journey to Babel 20
Obsession 8
The Ultimate Computer 2 +

Eliminated:
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Michael]

Instead of sobbing, I am going to help it a little. Actually it does not seem such a strange list to me: All episodes left now are good and would deserve to win IMHO.

Yeah, I figured healing it with only one point wouldn't keep it from being eliminated within the next two or three posts. So I healed "Mirror, Mirror" instead, which needs to be very high in this list.

But I agree, the remaining episodes are all good.

 

[EnsignJulka]

Amok Time 19+
The Doomsday Machine 18
Mirror, Mirror 16
The Trouble with Tribbles 15
Journey to Babel 20
Obsession 8

Eliminated:
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Orac]

Amok Time 19The Doomsday Machine 18
Mirror, Mirror 17 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 15
Journey to Babel 20
Obsession 6 -

Eliminated:
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory