Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Season 2

[KeepOnTrekking]

Amok Time 11
The Doomsday Machine 15+
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 8-
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[EnsignJulka]

Amok Time 12+
The Doomsday Machine 13-
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 8-
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Amok Time 12
The Doomsday Machine 13
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 9 +
Journey to Babel 9 -

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Michael]

Amok Time 10 -
The Doomsday Machine 13
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 9
Journey to Babel 10 +

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Defcon]

Amok Time 10
The Doomsday Machine 11 -
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 10 +
Journey to Babel 10

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[idreamedmusic]

Amok Time 10
The Doomsday Machine 9 -
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
Journey to Babel 11 +

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[c5maier]

Amok Time 8 -
The Doomsday Machine 9
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 11 +
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Outpost4]

Amok Time 6 -
The Doomsday Machine 9
Mirror, Mirror 12 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 11
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[EnsignJulka]

Amok Time 7 +
The Doomsday Machine 7 -
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 11
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Jackson_Roykirk]

Amok Time 5 -
The Doomsday Machine 8 +
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 11
Journey to Babel 11

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

I like Amok Time, but I like it the least of those five -- Amok Time still makes my top ten all time TOS list.

Doomsday, Babel and Mirror, Mirror are simply classics and great examples of very well-constructed TV episodes. Tribbles is great because it shows that Star Trek isn't afraid to poke fun at itself and the traits that it established for its characters -- I loved all of the "Star Trek in-jokes"

 

[Geck]

Amok Time 5
The Doomsday Machine 8
Mirror, Mirror 13 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 11
Journey to Babel 9 -

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Mallory]

Amok Time 6 +
The Doomsday Machine 8
Mirror, Mirror 13
The Trouble with Tribbles 9 -
Journey to Babel 9

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Amok Time 6
The Doomsday Machine 9 +
Mirror, Mirror 11 -
The Trouble with Tribbles 9
Journey to Babel 9

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Amok Time 7 +
The Doomsday Machine 9
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 9
Journey to Babel 7 -

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[TigerOfDarkness]

Amok Time 8 +
The Doomsday Machine 9
Mirror, Mirror 9 -
The Trouble with Tribbles 9
Journey to Babel 7

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Orac]

Amok Time 8
The Doomsday Machine 9
Mirror, Mirror 10 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 7 -
Journey to Babel 7

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[DevilintheDark]

Amok Time 9+
The Doomsday Machine 7-
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 7
Journey to Babel 7

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[idreamedmusic]

Past midnight, yay!

Amok Time 9
The Doomsday Machine 5 -
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 7
Journey to Babel 8 +

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Defcon]

Amok Time 9
The Doomsday Machine 3 -
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 8 +
Journey to Babel 8

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory

 

[Michael]

Amok Time 7 -
The Doomsday Machine 3
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 8
Journey to Babel 9 +

Eliminated:
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis
11th: The Changeling
12th: The Apple
13th: Friday's Child
14th: The Deadly Years
15th: A Private Little War
16th: The Immunity Syndrome
17th: A Piece of the Action
18th: Who Mourns for Adonais?
19th: The Gamesters of Triskelion
20th: Bread and Circuses
21st: Wolf in the Fold
22nd: I, Mudd
23rd: Patterns of Force
24th: Catspaw
25th: Assignment: Earth
26th: The Omega Glory