Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Ever!

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

At last the final 30.

same rules:
Each episode starts on 10 points.
1 Vote every calander day per member.
On each vote you must both:
Heal your favourite story + 1
& Hurt your least favourite stoy -2
(You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)
Once a story reaches Zero its out
Stories are ranked in order of elimination
Please indicate which episoes you have voted for

GET VOTING!!

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 10
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 10
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 10
Requiem for Methuselah 10

 

[Michael]

Cool!

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 10
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11 +
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 10
Requiem for Methuselah 8 -

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 10
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 10
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 11 +
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8 -
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 10
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Geck]

Gosh, I hardly even know where to start with this list...

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 11 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8 -
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 11
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 10
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11 +
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 11
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 11
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 8 -
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Orac]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12 +
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 10
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9 -
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 8
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Mallory]

There's lots of chaff to be gotten rid of before the voting even begins to get tough.

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 10
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11 +
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 6 -
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[boognish]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 11 +
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 10
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 8 -
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 6
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[c5maier]

I would have wished to first give TAS the same treatment and then compare 4 times ten favourites. I think it would have been interesting to see how the TAS episodes fare in comparison. Well ...

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 11
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 8 -
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 8
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? +
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[EnsignJulka]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9-
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12+
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 8
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 8
Whom Gods Destroy 10
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty?
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Outpost4]

There's lots of chaff to be gotten rid of before the voting even begins to get tough.

But I predict people vote for their personal favorites, the chaff if you like, before the heavyweights take over.

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9 +
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 8
Whom Gods Destroy 8 -
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 7
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Orac]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 9
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6 -
Whom Gods Destroy 9 +
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 7
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10 +
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 10
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 8
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 5 -
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Geck]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 10
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11 +
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 6 -
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 5
Requiem for Methuselah 8

 

[Garth Rockett]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 10
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11 +
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 6
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 5
Requiem for Methuselah 6 -

 

[Mallory]

It's Friday morning and I still don't like Medusans.

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11 +
The City on the Edge of Forever 10
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 10
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 6
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 3 -
Requiem for Methuselah 6

 

[T'Bonz]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 8 -
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 11 +
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 6
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 3
Requiem for Methuselah 6

 

[Jackson_Roykirk]

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 8
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 12 +
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 4 -
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 3
Requiem for Methuselah 6

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

I would have wished to first give TAS the same treatment and then compare 4 times ten favourites. I think it would have been interesting to see how the TAS episodes fare in comparison. Well ...

I dont think it would have been a fair comparison, the format was too different: Animation, and much shorter episodes.

My Vote:

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 8
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 5 +
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 10
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 1 -
Requiem for Methuselah 6

 

[TigerOfDarkness]

Well, this is probably a waste of time, but there's no way ITITNB is the worst episode here....

Where No Man Has Gone Before 11
The City on the Edge of Forever 8
The Devil in the Dark 12
Balance of Terror 12
Errand of Mercy 10
The Corbomite Maneuver 9
The Cage 10
The Menagerie, Part I & II 10
A Taste of Armageddon 11
This Side of Paradise 10
Journey to Babel 10
Amok Time 10
Mirror, Mirror 12
The Trouble with Tribbles 10
The Doomsday Machine 11
Obsession 11
The Ultimate Computer 10
By Any Other Name 5
Return to Tomorrow 10
Metamorphosis 9
The Enterprise Incident 10
The Tholian Web 10
Day of the Dove 10
All Our Yesterdays 11
Wink of an Eye 8 -
Spectre of the Gun 6
Whom Gods Destroy 9
Elaan of Troyius 8
Is There in Truth No Beauty? 2 +
Requiem for Methuselah 6