Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 2

[ZMistress]

The Circle 1 -
The Siege 5
Cardassians 9 +
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 16
Blood Oath 9
The Maquis, Part I 9
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 26
Crossover 15
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 22

Eliminated:
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[erastus25]

The Circle 1
The Siege 5
Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 16
Blood Oath 9
The Maquis, Part I 9
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 26
Crossover 16 +
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 20 -

Eliminated:
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

The Siege 5
Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 16
Blood Oath 9
The Maquis, Part I 9
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 26
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21 +

Eliminated:
14th: The Circle -
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Geck]

I'm really surprised the opening trilogy is doing so poorly...I'd put all three eps in the Top 10 for the season.

 

[boognish]

The Siege 3 -
Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 16
Blood Oath 9
The Maquis, Part I 10 +
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 26
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[RaymondJames]

Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 16
Blood Oath 10 (+)
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 26
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
13th: The Seige (-)
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[boognish]

Sabotadge! You're only allowed to hurt an episode 2 points!

 

[Defcon]

^I've put it back in with one remaining point.

The Siege 1
Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 14 -
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27 +
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[BigFoot]

Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 14
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 22 +

Eliminated:
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Orac]

Cardassians 9
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 13 -
Shadowplay 15 +
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 22

Eliminated:
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[D'deridex]

Cardassians 7 -
Necessary Evil 14
Armageddon Game 2
Whispers 13
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 23 +

Eliminated:
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Garth Rockett]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 14 +
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 23

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Geck]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15 +
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 8 -
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 16
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 23

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[erastus25]

I'm really surprised the opening trilogy is doing so poorly...I'd put all three eps in the Top 10 for the season.

I thought it started out well but got progressively worse with every episode. Definitely didn't live up to its potential either way... But I think it was better than The Maquis story.

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 8
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 17 +
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21 -

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary[/quote]

 

[naf9sd]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 8 -
The Maquis, Part I 9 +
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Michael]

10:54 PM in Germany.

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 15
Blood Oath 6 -
The Maquis, Part I 10 +
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Ro_Laren]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 13 -
Blood Oath 6
The Maquis, Part I 11
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 27
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Defcon]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 11 -
Blood Oath 6
The Maquis, Part I 11
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 28 +
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[Michael]

0:25 AM in Germany.

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 16 +
Shadowplay 11
Blood Oath 4 -
The Maquis, Part I 11
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 28
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary

 

[boognish]

Cardassians 7
Necessary Evil 14
Whispers 15
Shadowplay 12 +
Blood Oath 4 -
The Maquis, Part I 11
The Maquis, Part II 11
The Wire 28
Crossover 17
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 21

Eliminated:
12th: Armageddon Game
13th: The Siege
14th: The Circle
15th: The Alternate
16th: The Homecoming
17th: Rules of Acquisition
18th: Paradise
19th: Playing God
20th: Invasive Procedures
21st: Profit and Loss
22nd: The Collaborator
23rd: Rivals
24th: Second Sight
25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary