Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Grand Final

[MyCylon]

S1 Duet 19
S1 Emissary 11+
S2 The Wire 6
S2 Crossover 7
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 7
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 7
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 8
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 8

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Captain Ryan]

S1 Duet 19
S1 Emissary 12+
S2 The Wire 6
S2 Crossover 7
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 7
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 7
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 8
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 4 -
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 8

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Geck]

S1 Duet 19
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 6
S2 Crossover 7
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 7
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5 -
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 8
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5 +
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 8

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[SoM]

S1 Duet 20 +
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 6
S2 Crossover 7
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 5 -
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 7
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 8
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 4
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 8

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress[/QUOTE]

 

[Nerys Ghemor]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7 +
S2 Crossover 5 -
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 5
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 7
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 8
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 4
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 8

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Orac]

1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 5
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 5
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 7
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9 +
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 4
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6 -

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

SoM posted earlier at the same time as Geck .
Adjusting score to account for Geck's post:


S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 5
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 11
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 5
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5 (2-)
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5 (1+)
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Natural]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 5
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12 +
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 3 -
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[McCoy]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 5
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12 +
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S4 Little Green Men 1 -
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 12 +
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6

Eliminated
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[EMHMark613]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 5
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12 +
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 13 +
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[BigFoot]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 3 -
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 13
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6 +
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 6

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[LeadHead]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 3
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 13
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 4 -
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7 +

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Sisko4Life]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 3
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5 <--- ?????
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11-
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5+ <--- what the fuck is going on here?????
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[BigFoot]

^ I'm wondering the same thing.

 

[MyCylon]

It's strange that By Inferno's Light and Far Beyond the Stars are doing so badly, I agree.

In fact, the former is doing even worse while the latter is doing a little better. SoM's post missed out on Geck's post which reduced BIL by 2 points and upped FBTS by 1 point.

I've corrected the scores and highlighted the corrections in the list:

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 12 +
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 1 -
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 3 corrected
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 19
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6 corrected
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[naf9sd]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 10 -
S2 The Wire 7
S2 Crossover 1
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 17
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 3
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 20 +
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Garth Rockett]

By Inferno's Light's low score is definitely surprising. I personally find Far Beyond the Stars to be overrated, but I think it should stick around for a while.

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 10
S2 The Wire 7
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 18 +
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 3
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 9
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 20
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
20th: S2 Crossover -
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[D'deridex]

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 10
S2 The Wire 5 -
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 18
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 3
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 11
S5 For the Uniform 10 +
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 20
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 6
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[SoM]

Actually, Justtoyourleft, KeepOnTrekking already corrected for the error caused by my simulpost with Geck's post, so Geck's post has now been counted twice. I've dialled it back to once here. (And I'm one of the ones voting FBtS down, partly because it's DS9's These Were The Voyages..., with the focus completely off the DS9 characters.)

S1 Duet 20
S1 Emissary 10
S2 The Wire 6+
S3 Improbable Cause 11
S3 The Die is Cast 9
S3 Visionary 12
S4 The Visitor 18
S4 The Way of the Warrior 20
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 5 (fixed double-count of a -2)
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 9-
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 20
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 5 (fixed double-count of a +1)
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 16
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 11
S7 What You Leave Behind 7

Eliminated.
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[MyCylon]

^
Apologies. I could have sworn it had not been accounted for. I don't know how I missed that. Glad it got corrected, anyway.