• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Grand Final

S4 The Visitor 5 +
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 34 -

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
S4 The Visitor 3 -2
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 35 +1

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
S4 The Visitor 4 +
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 34 -

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
S4 The Visitor 5 +
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 32 -

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
S4 The Visitor 3 -
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 33 +

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
I've been wondering why people have been voting for OR against ITPM for the past... oh... ten rounds or so (i.e., going back to the point Die Is Cast was eliminated) at least. It was SO obviously going to win...

S4 The Visitor 1 -
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 34 +

Eliminated:
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
^ Personally, I can never decide which is the better of the two episodes. They're definitely my favourite two episodes of Trek ever.

As for why I was healing The Visitor and hurting ITPM, well 'cause I want the difference between the eps to be as small as possible. ;)
 
Let's end this ;)

S6 In the Pale Moonlight 35 +

Eliminated:
2nd:S4 The Visitor -
3rd: S6 Sacrifice of Angels
4th: S5 Call to Arms
5th: S1 Duet
6th: S6 Favor the Bold
7th: S3 Improbable Cause
8th: S4 The Way of the Warrior
9th: S5 In Purgatory's Shadow
10th: S3 Visionary
11th: S3 The Die is Cast
12th: S7 The Changing Face of Evil
13th: S5 Trials and Tribble-ations
14th: S5 By Inferno's Light
15th: S2 The Wire
16th: S6 Far Beyond the Stars
17th: S1 Emissary
18th: S5 For the Uniform
19th: S7 What You Leave Behind
20th: S2 Crossover
21st: S4 Little Green Men
22nd: S2 The Jem'Hadar
23rd: S2 Whispers
24th: S3 The Adversary
25th: S7 The Dogs of War
26th: S4 Hard Time
27th: S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River
28th: S1 In the Hands of the Prophets
29th: S2 Necessary Evil
30th: S1 Captive Pursuit
31st: S3 Defiant
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress
 
I also think it is quite overrated. I was more upset about Far Beyond the Stars not making the Top 15... c'mon now!!!

Sacrifice of Angels---> #3!!! Sweet! I guess I'm not the only nerd out here that likes space battles, escapes from prison, and divine intervention!
 
I do think ITPM is excellent. However, I'd love to see the kind of debate that would take place here if it DIDN'T win for a change :D.
 
McCoy said:
But I was glad to see Duet in the top 5. The performances in that were fantastic. Harris Yulin rocks!
Click to expand...

I'm glad it made the top 5, but I would rather have seen it make the top 3 at Visitor's expense. For me, it's a better show than that (and CtA).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Sakonna
Game The Most Disliked Season Finale Antagonist, 2025 Edition
3 4 5
Replies
82
Views
2K
Sakonna
Sakonna
Admiral Jean-Luc Picard
Complete Star Trek Timeline (why not?)
2 3
Replies
43
Views
4K
Admiral Jean-Luc Picard
Admiral Jean-Luc Picard
Admiral Jean-Luc Picard
When did you feel each show found its footing?
2
Replies
38
Views
3K
Lord Hierarch
L
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top