Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Grand Final

[LeadHead]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 10
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 9
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 11
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 13
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 10
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 9
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 10 +
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 The Siege of AR-558 1 -
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10


Eliminated
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Geck]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 10
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 9
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 11
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 13
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 10
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10 +
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 10
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10


Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558 (sorry, I've always found it huuuuuuuugely overrated. Not even in the top half of S7 for me)
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Saga]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8-
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 9
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 12+
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 13
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 10
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 10
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

 

[BigFoot]

^ Include the eliminated list next time.


S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7 -
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 12
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 14 +
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 10
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 10
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress


Btw, you guys seriously suck for eliminating AR-558 already.

 

[boognish]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 7 +
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 12
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 14
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 10
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8 -
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Frenzy]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 7
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10 -2
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 14
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 10
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11 +1
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[naf9sd]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 5 -
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 8
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 14
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 11 +
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Garth Rockett]

Btw, you guys seriously suck for eliminating AR-558 already.

To each his own, but I agree with Geck. I thought it was overrated in the S7 ranking. Too cliched for my tastes. It's main redeeming feature is that it sets up the excellent It's Only A Paper Moon, which IMO should have made the top 5 from S7. But that's why we play the game!

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 5
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 5
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6 -
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15 +
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 11
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 10

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[D'deridex]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 5
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3 -
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 11
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8 -

Eliminated
33rd: The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Natural]

Wow, Siege gone already? It's better than half of these episodes.

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6 +
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 10
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9 -
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 6
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Apogeal Alpha01]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11+
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 14
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 4 -
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15+
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 10
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 2 -
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 8
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[LeadHead]

S1 Duet 12
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 6
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8 -
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 2
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9 +
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Nerys Ghemor]

S1 Duet 13 +
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4 -
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 12
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S6 The Magnificent Ferengi 2
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Sisko4Life]

S1 Duet 13
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 7
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 11
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 13+
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi -
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[BigFoot]

S1 Duet 13
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 5 -
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 9
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 12 +
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 13
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

Btw, you guys seriously suck for eliminating AR-558 already.

To each his own, but I agree with Geck. I thought it was overrated in the S7 ranking. Too cliched for my tastes. It's main redeeming feature is that it sets up the excellent It's Only A Paper Moon, which IMO should have made the top 5 from S7. But that's why we play the game!

I definitely agree that It's Only a Paper Moon is an awesome ep, one of my favourite from the show as well (just like AR-558).

 

[Sisko4Life]

I'm going to third that. The Siege of AR-558 IMO was the best of Season 7. Dogs of War wtf???? I just re-watched that episode yesterday and it was a total crapshoot.

 

[Saga]

S1 Duet 13
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 5
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 7-
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 13 +
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 13
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 8
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[Geck]

S1 Duet 13
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 6 +
S1 Captive Pursuit 6
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 7
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 13
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 13
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 6 -
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress

 

[naf9sd]

S1 Duet 13
S1 Emissary 8
S1 In the Hands of the Prophets 6
S1 Captive Pursuit 4 -
S2 The Wire 8
S2 The Jem'Hadar 11
S2 Crossover 10
S2 Necessary Evil 3
S2 Whispers 8
S3 Improbable Cause 10
S3 The Die is Cast 10
S3 Visionary 10
S3 Defiant 4
S3 The Adversary 10
S4 The Visitor 15
S4 The Way of the Warrior 15
S4 Hard Time 10
S4 Little Green Men 8 +
S5 Call to Arms 10
S5 By Inferno's Light 11
S5 In Purgatory's Shadow 10
S5 Trials and Tribble-ations 10
S5 For the Uniform 10
S6 In the Pale Moonlight 13
S6 Far Beyond the Stars 8
S6 Sacrifice of Angels 13
S6 Favor the Bold 11
S7 The Changing Face of Evil 10
S7 What You Leave Behind 9
S7 The Dogs of War 6
S7 Treachery, Faith and the Great River 8

Eliminated
32nd: S6 The Magnificent Ferengi
33rd: S7 The Siege of AR-558
34th: S4 Our Man Bashir
35th: S1 Progress