• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How much time passed between IV and V?

Tribble puncher

Captain
Captain
It seems like maybe only a couple of weeks on one hand, but on the other it seems like it could have been longer, maybe a year or more, as the movie begins with Kirk on leave, but judging by Scotty you could easily believe the ship broke down right after the end credits in ST: IV.
 
I have no idea the official timeframe, but I tend to think it was quite a while, and Scotty's line about the ship is because of all the little things that went wrong on the ship in the last year or so.
 
The most common theory is between six months and a year from "Let's see what she's got" and "We found out, didn't we?"

That there's less than a skeleton crew actually lends credence to the idea that Kirk and the Enterprise-A are a low priority with Starfleet. If the higher-ups wanted the ship to be on active standby and ready for service as quickly as possible, Scotty would have gotten as much help as he needed to meet his projections for repair and upgrade. Not prioritizing the ship that way makes it plain that Kirk is just being indulged because of publicity.
 
The time line place Star Trek 4 in 2286 and it would have to be early in the year as ST3 takes place in 2285. Star Trek 5 official year is 2287. That being said the time line doesn't make a lot of sense because Kirks birthday was seen in ST2 and if I remember right that's in March of the year 2285 so after three months on Vulcan how are we now in 2286? did 6 months pass between ST2 and 3 and then the three months stay on Vulcan?
 
My impression is that it's days or weeks after the end of STIV (which presumably ended in them breaking down just after the credits started rolling)
 
My impression is that it's days or weeks after the end of STIV (which presumably ended in them breaking down just after the credits started rolling)
One more reason I tend to discount TFF. The thought of the new Enterprise breaking down right after TVH's closing shot is just too depressing.
 
The most common theory is between six months and a year from "Let's see what she's got" and "We found out, didn't we?"

That there's less than a skeleton crew actually lends credence to the idea that Kirk and the Enterprise-A are a low priority with Starfleet. If the higher-ups wanted the ship to be on active standby and ready for service as quickly as possible, Scotty would have gotten as much help as he needed to meet his projections for repair and upgrade. Not prioritizing the ship that way makes it plain that Kirk is just being indulged because of publicity.

I mean, the whole story for why it had to be THE ENTERPRISE was clunky to begin with in STV, It was like they were trying to do a McHales Navy but in space, It would have made more sense to have the Enterprise be out and about on it's new mission, in top form, maybe it was already on it's way to Nimbus III on a goodwill mission or happened to be close by and thats why it was chosen, that was always one thing that nagged at me about ALL of the films as an adult, they were never more than a few days or hours from Earth, it TOS, it felt bigger from that sense, because it was implied that they were WAAAAAAY out there and help wasn't coming any time soon if stuff went down, but anyway.
 
My head cannon is several weeks, a hard shake down, a few official missions, and then back to Earth so Starfleet and the contractors could fix any discovered faults.

Most of the crew is encouraged to take leave.

Mostly little irritating things, not major systems.
 
Must of been some amount of time, the bridge was changed out, being a brand new ship there would be bugs of course.
 
My headcanon has been that it was between 6 months to a year between V and VI.

Even if the 1701-A was having problems during the shakedown, the tense political situation would have required the ship to stay out and active for awhile.

Despite the low casualty numbers (possibly zero) for the Alien Probe incident, the Klingons had two vessels neutralized by the probe, who knows if they survived, and if any died, they didn't die in glorious battle, so not exactly an honorable death, yet the Federation turns back the Probe. Combine that with the Federation refusing to extradite Kirk, Kirk and crew being cleared of charges, Kirk being essentially rewarded for his actions, Kruge's bird of prey sinking into the San Francisco bay and not returnable to the empire, tensions would be high.

Despite that Kirk wouldn't be the Captain they'd want on the Klingon border at this point, Starfleet would not be able to afford having a large starship like the Enterprise sitting in Spacedock unless the warp core was breaching, life support were offline and they're out of coffee.

After a few months, the problems with the ship would require a proper stay in spacedock, Starfleet in its infinite love affair with refits, puts the ship through changing the bridge and potentially many other areas of the ship, potentially pushing the repairs Scotty needed to do down the road. The refit crew finishes their work, most of the Enterprise crew takes shore leave, leaving Scotty and the skeleton crew to finish the repairs with little support.
 
Long enough for Taylor to be okayed for work on a starship. Considering where she came from, that can't be a fast or easy process.
 
How long is a shakedown cruise? In ST:FC, the heroes implied the shakedown of the Enterprise-E took a full year...

Between the return from said cruise and the events of the movie, the "three weeks" quote holds. In between the main events of STIV and the end scene where the heroes get the ship, months or even years may be inserted if need be.

I wouldn't insert too much time between the main events of STIV and the trial, though. Everybody would be eager to get the trial held ASAP, and OTOH everything would be in place... Just give Gillian enough time to get the whales properly sorted out so that she can get all excited about the "science ship" (be it on the Pacific or beyond Antares; I see no sense in putting her on a starship unless all three whales were safely dead already).

Timo Saloniemi
 
Long enough for Taylor to be okayed for work on a starship. Considering where she came from, that can't be a fast or easy process.

Who said it was a starship? I thought she was referring to an ocean going vessel that would be monitoring the whales.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top