• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How come no Biblical elements in Stargate?

They've taken jabs at the Bush administration before. The reason they are pro-military is because they rely on the Air Force for support. They made the NID as a way to tell anti-military stories without actually involving the military. Sokar was the Christian Devil, and the entire Ori arc were pretty much a take on the Jewish-Christian-Islamic religion.

Light jabs at George W. Bush hardly count as political engagement. You'll have to enlighten me on where these jabs actually occur also, besides Jack's "shrub" comment about Kinsey. The fact that, after viewing the entire series more than twice, I can't remember these jabs isn't indicative of them having much potency, but my memory could just be a fault.

The NID is a civilian agency, which undercuts any "anti-military" sentiment of the stories. I totally understand why the series is so pro-military-- the closest its come to being anti-military is a bad commander or two--characters who are always repentant of their poor leadership (or in the very least punished for it) in order to glorify the military heroes of the series. But let's be honest and admit to ourselves that Stargate's pro-military sentiments are prevalent.

Sokar was an Egyptian God. "Satan" was only mentioned as one of the guises he took on, and, besides, the character didn't even last an entire season.

Lastly, the Ori arc goes out of its way to avoid talking about Christianity, Islam, or Judaism. The show can't even mention Jesus Christ when talking about immaculate conception, preferring a Darth Vader joke instead.

None of these comments are to take the series too far to task. I love it for what it is, at least as far as the eighth season. After that, I've found it wildly inconsistent, but that has nothing to do with its politics.
 
Sokar was an Egyptian God. "Satan" was only mentioned as one of the guises he took on, and, besides, the character didn't even last an entire season.

Yeah but they did use the he's the devil stuff I mean SG-1 went to a prison of Sokar's that was called Hell.
 
Light jabs at George W. Bush hardly count as political engagement.
I get the sense from this thread that being "Scifi" they are expected to "take jabs at GWB", I must say its more refreshing for a series to not go this route, its trite and lame not to mention predicable.

Sharr
 
Sokar was an Egyptian God. "Satan" was only mentioned as one of the guises he took on, and, besides, the character didn't even last an entire season.

Yeah but they did use the he's the devil stuff I mean SG-1 went to a prison of Sokar's that was called Hell.

True. That's Jolinar's Memories/The Devil You Know, right?

I think and considering who showed up the title of part two was pretty ironic.
 
Light jabs at George W. Bush hardly count as political engagement.
I get the sense from this thread that being "Scifi" they are expected to "take jabs at GWB", I must say its more refreshing for a series to not go this route, its trite and lame not to mention predicable.

Sharr

I don't think there were any shots at GWB but there was a slight one at Cheney's hunting "accident". ;)
 
I've always had the opinion that Jesus Christ, in the SG universe, was a Tok'ra. Heck, most of the more fantastic figures in the Old and New Testament were Go'auld or Tok'ra. I know it would piss off many Christians, but ask me if I care.

I know, I know. IDIC. Some one should tell them that as well.
 
I've always had the opinion that Jesus Christ, in the SG universe, was a Tok'ra. Heck, most of the more fantastic figures in the Old and New Testament were Go'auld or Tok'ra. I know it would piss off many Christians, but ask me if I care.

I know, I know. IDIC. Some one should tell them that as well.

I think the Ori fit better, the Go'aulds taking the persona of gods rather then Prophets given power in service to God being the distinction of the Jewish/Christian/Islamic stories.
 
How come there is no biblical elements in Stargate?

I thought they wasted a prime opportunity in this regard, when we learned that the offspring of two Goa'uld hosts, a human being with the genetic memory of the Goa'uld, is called Harcesis. With those memories, the Harcesis can be a "savior" of humanity in its fight to overthrow Goa'uld oppression.

Son of God(s) == Harcesis == (even sounds like) Jesus

Too controversial, obviously. It's okay to say everyone else's gods are fake, just not the "real" one. :rolleyes:
 
They had to avoid controversy. They took mythology from older religions and used them just fine, but to take current myth (seven days? really?) would have been just too 'controversial'... One fictionalized 'religion' is much the same as the other, isn't it?

When this question was asked a fewe months ago I was the last post in a dying thread. To stray into Nuetral Zone territory consider Islam accepts the Old Testament Prophets and stories as being from God. Should a TV show casually say it is all fictional.

Since it is all fictional, yes. It's just a story, with fans following it to the extreme. The bible is like Twilight. It's poorly written, internally inconsistent, and its more extreme fans are quite insane.
 
and its more extreme fans are quite insane.
As are many of its extreme critics. ;)

This is a good thread, so please let's not turn it into a referendum on the Bible or any other real life religion's documents.
 
There's a timing difference to take into account as well. Laying aside the question of Young Earth vs Old Earth Creation theory, the Tau'ri Rebellion took place ~5-6000 years ago, IIRC.

That would mean the Goua'uld were long gone BEFORE the first rise of Israel as a culture, let alone Christianity. Now the Asgard apparently continued to monitor Earth for some time, since they took Dark Ages/Medieval Ages Vikings to other worlds at one point, and may or may NOT have been on Earth as recently as the 1940s.
 
I've always had the opinion that Jesus Christ, in the SG universe, was a Tok'ra. Heck, most of the more fantastic figures in the Old and New Testament were Go'auld or Tok'ra. I know it would piss off many Christians, but ask me if I care.

I know, I know. IDIC. Some one should tell them that as well.

They could have also taken the route of "Jesus was an Ancient because he ascended" and left no body"
 
In the episode "Politics", when Kinsey is trying to shut down the stargate program, and has been told that the Goa'uld are coming he intimates that god will save the world from them, and Jack sarcastically remarks that "And you think...God is going to save us?". That may be the most anti-religious statement they made against the current earth religions.
 
In the episode "Politics", when Kinsey is trying to shut down the stargate program, and has been told that the Goa'uld are coming he intimates that god will save the world from them, and Jack sarcastically remarks that "And you think...God is going to save us?". That may be the most anti-religious statement they made against the current earth religions.
Kinsey did make quite a few references to God throughout the series, most of which made him appear crazy and evil (well, maybe not evil, but certainly a jackass).
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top