I don't think anyone is saying the older plane would be as good as the F-22, just that the F-22 is massive overkill in the current climate. It's like getting a P-90 for disciplining a kindergarden class. At this point, no one is threatening enough to justify needing something as massively cool as the F-22. You yourself made the same point when you bet that a U.S. could defeat an enemy pilot even in an equivalent or lesser plane.