• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Help with a McCoy quote!

ampers_and

Cadet
Newbie
I'm positive that McCoy utters something along the lines of "Never underestimate the body's natural ability to heal itself" at some point in the original series, but I can't find the exact episode!

Does anyone remember which it was?

Thanks in advance!

EDIT: If I am incorrect, then can anybody suggest a few notable episodes which demonstrate McCoy's philosophy toward medicine/humanity?
 
Last edited:
Are you positive it was from the show itself? Kelly voiced an opinion similar in Inside Star Trek. (I'll be able to provide the quotation in full tomorrow, if you want to check.)
 
I was almost certain it was from an episode, but I might be getting it jumbled in my head. I'd very much love to know the exact quote, if it's possible.
Thanks!
 
You've got me stumped and dialogue from TOS usually lodges in my brain quite easily.

Doesn't help you, I know... but to me, it sounds more like something Dr. Phlox would say. 'Strange New World', if I remember correctly. When they beam up a crewmen and surrounding matter (leaves blown about in the wind mostly) is embedded in his skin.

If not, it's one of those conundrums that'll lie low for a while, then suddenly wake you in the middle of night.
 
If I am incorrect, then can anybody suggest a few notable episodes which demonstrate McCoy's philosophy toward medicine/humanity?
McCoy episodes sure... not sure how well they fit your criteria.

The Man Trap, The City of the Edge of Forever, For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky,

Times when he had more to do in the story than wind up Spock at any rate...

The Corbomite Maneuver, Miri, The Galileo Seven, Friday's Child, The Empath.

McCoy would have some good lines to do with medicine from time to time, beyond the "I'm a Doctor, not a *insert here*" catchphrase. Pretty light on terminology though.
 
Could it have come from the episode where Spock was shot in the back? ( A Private Little War?? Memory eludes me as well)
 
Are you positive it was from the show itself? Kelly voiced an opinion similar in Inside Star Trek. (I'll be able to provide the quotation in full tomorrow, if you want to check.)


I've had that record since it came out, but only played it once or twice. I'd like to give it a listen again, but haven't had a turntable in ages. IIRC, on the record, DeForest Kelly was in character as McCoy as he was being "interviewed" by Roddenberry. I believe the quote in question DOES come from there.
 
No, that was Mark Lenard being in character as Sarek being interviewed by Roddenberry. Kelley did his talk as himself.

As for lack of a turntable, as was mentioned above, the record was rereleased as part of a two disc set along with the TMP soundtrack.

Get thee to a Barnes & Noble.
 
I'd like to give it a listen again, but haven't had a turntable in ages.

I also hadn't listened to it in forever, so I used stone knives and bearskins to patch the turntable into the library computer. Roddenberry and DeForest Kelley have a six-minute discussion on the role of McCoy, fans' reactions to it, and the state of medicine then (c. 1976) and in the future.

While mentioning that playing McCoy influenced him and agreeing that fans relate to him as the character, Kelley says that he never thinks of himself as McCoy. When asked by Roddenberry if people ask him for medical advice, Kelley replies, "you know our fans are brighter than that; they know I'm not really McCoy."

Kelley then discusses his visits to some permanently or terminally ill children whose parents have written to him, the role of hope, and his views on contemporary medicine, starting by mentioning that it's too expensive. What ampers_and asked about then follows: Two-minute excerpt.
 
I was almost certain it was from an episode, but I might be getting it jumbled in my head. I'd very much love to know the exact quote, if it's possible.
Thanks!

Are you positive it was from the show itself? Kelly voiced an opinion similar in Inside Star Trek. (I'll be able to provide the quotation in full tomorrow, if you want to check.)


I've had that record since it came out, but only played it once or twice. I'd like to give it a listen again, but haven't had a turntable in ages. IIRC, on the record, DeForest Kelly was in character as McCoy as he was being "interviewed" by Roddenberry. I believe the quote in question DOES come from there.

Here's DeForrest Kelly, from Inside Star Trek:
=======================
Roddenberry: Medicine today, what do you think of it?
Kelley: It's too expensive.
Roddenberry: Come on, that's a pretty safe generality.
Kelley: Is it? Look, when millions of inhabitants on a planet can't afford medical care, then it's obviously too damned expensive. Now, if you wanna ask what I think of medical care that is available...
Roddenberry: I've noticed you do seem to be critical of medicine today.
Kelley: Well, like anything else, Gene, medicine reflects the society it's part of. Just as our 20th century has tried to find happiness outside ourselves in material things, I think our medicine today has too often tried to find its answers outside the human body -- in other words, in technology, or pharmacology, or sometimes in physically assaulting the body. Now, I'm not criticizing our physicians, understand -- that just happens to be the state of the art today. They save a lotta lives. They save a lotta lives, just as doctors once had to cut off all gangrenous limbs to save a lotta lives. [...] When we start Star Trek again, we've just got to have some scenes of medicine the way it's going to be. You see, I see the physician as less a mechanic or a chemist, but more a teacher. In other words, teaching the patient to use the natural healing ability we all have in our bodies. And our natural healing body is incredible, absolutely incredible. Most top doctors today will admit that we're on the edge of such a medical revolution. They no longer ignore the mounting evidence that infection and disease have much to do with the state of our conscious or unconscious mind.
Gene: I can agree with that. I remember onstage, we used to say we were all too busy to catch a cold -- and none of us ever did.
Kelley: And you know, a surprising number of people have cured themselves of diseases from athlete's foot to cancer, and some of them were never aware they were healing themselves! Plus the fact that some of our best physicians are no longer laughing at things like...well, witch doctors, yoga, Zen, Christian Science, acupuncture, meditation and so on. Our bodies are incredibly sophisticated and capable machines, and it's time that we began respecting those bodies for what they are, and began learning what they can do.

========

Before this, Kelley talks about how much of himself he invested in the character of McCoy and how the character and he invariably rubbed off on one another -- so McCoy may have made a similar statement.
 
Like somebody said, it doesn't sound like an exact quote--more like a paraphrase.

But as the other poster said it doesn't ring a bell and I'ves seen most episodes dozens of times.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top