• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Good characters or good science?

Besides, in the context of science fiction, the question isn't whether it will happen, but whether it's plausible that it could. That's what science fiction is about: possibilities, not certainties.

Hard scientific evidence tells us that the universe is filled with planetary systems. It seems highly likely that there are many Earthlike planets elsewhere in the galaxy. Studies of life on Earth tell us that life can thrive in an enormous range of environments, essentially anyplace where there's water, carbon, and energy. We don't yet know for certain whether the spontaneous emergence of life is a rare or common event, but we do know that some species of bacteria can survive the vacuum and radiation of space, and that it's physically possible for such microbes to be blown off one planet and drift through interstellar space to be deposited on others. All told, there is very, very good scientific reason to consider it probable that life exists elsewhere in the universe.

As for interstellar travel, we know it to be difficult, but not impossible. FTL is probably unattainable, but there are plenty of slower-than-light ways of travelling between the stars: fusion rockets, antimatter rockets, laser-driven lightsails, particle beam-driven magnetic sails, self-replicating Von Neumann probes, etc. All of these concepts are the products of solid scientific and engineering research and the groundwork for them is being developed in earnest. So there is very, very good scientific reason to consider it a certainty that it is possible to travel between stars, even if it takes hundreds or thousands of years to do so.

Therefore, the concept of humans meeting alien life in the flesh is not an absurd or impossible one. It's true that it probably won't happen in our lifetimes, but all that matters for science fiction is that there's no reason why it couldn't happen, either within our lifetimes or within the lifetimes of characters living centuries or millennia in our future.
 
To be fair, they were able to do that because the entire series focused on only one alien race, rather than a different one each week. I should point out that in DS9, we got extensive development of the Bajorans and Cardassians, because they were constant, ongoing presences in the series.

Well, they didn't have to make each alien species as diverse and interesting as the Newcomers in AN. But a little more diversity would've been nice to see. Other than the couple of exceptions have we ever seen a Klingon that wasn't a yelling, lunkheaded, warrior?
 
Characters with science that fits seamlessly in whatever rules the story establishes. If the science doesn't jerk me out of the story - even if its not at all plausible - its okay with me.
 
You're not seriously saying that we're going to meet little green space friends in our lifetime? Jules Verne wrote fiction. Science fiction or at least the precursor to it. I don't know who your 'countless' people are but there's a difference between Margaret Thatcher saying there wouldn't be a woman PM in her lifetime and me saying humanity is not going to meet aliens across the void.

The only difference being Marget Thatcher's claim and yours is that it had nothing to do with science, science fiction, or drama. Jules Verne wrote science fiction; he wrote a book about going to the moon. Even a mere decade before we actually achieved it there were still plenty of people that thought we wouldn't ever do it.

The universe has a habit of proving anyone claiming something can't happen wrong; either in his life time, or soon after.

Your claim, simply put, is ridiculous; at least the other claims had at least some semblance of their science on their side. Your claim, not so much.

Actually the difference between Margaret Thatcher's prediction and mine is that hers was entirely possible in her lifetime. My claim is the only sensible one when it comes to aliens and human interaction therewith. It won't happen soon and it won't happen in a thousand years. It's a fun idea though, which is why it produces so many enjoyable stories.
 
^Neither one of those things can be said for certain. It's irrational to assume we know what the next thousand years will hold. Would people who lived a thousand years ago have been able to predict anything about our world today?
 
Well I predict that humanity will become extinct before any aliens come along. The distances are too vast. We're stuck here and anyone else is stuck wherever they are. Even if they manage to send out generational ships, the chances of them stumbling on our solar system are infinitely small. Even if we ever send out generational ships, the chances of us stumbling across anyone else are infinitely small.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top