• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Frank Miller's "The Spirit ...... "

It looks really corny. Some of that trailer dialogue was atrocious:

"I'm gonna kill you all kinds of dead!" ???????

and

"I'm the Octopus. I have eight of everything." (yeah, that doesn't sound wrong...)
 
Okay, this has been really bothering me so I thought I'd revisit this thread. Look, here's the deal, guys: most of you non-comic junkies and geeks will know anything about The Spirit. And there's nothing wrong with that. The Spirit is Denny Colt. He's a cop who is knocked unconscious by a bad guy's experimental nerve gas (this was the 40s, folks) and is buried because he appears to be dead. He "returns from the dead" and realizes that a man who is considered legally dead has the best secret identity of all. He adds a simple domino mask to his standard 40s attire (fedora, trenchcoat, suit) and fights crime with his fists, his brains, and his heart. Denny Colt is the original comic book everyman. Forget Peter Parker; Colt is the one who can really be identified with. He bleeds, he gets his ass kicked often. But he perseveres because of his willingness to succeed. This is what makes him the "spirit" of his city, and it's his fighting "spirit" that makes him a hero. Frank Miller (the douchebag whose work has been overrated by literary snobs who only think good comic books are those that deconstruct what comic books are) took The Spirit and made him into a guy who can jump great distances and who has a Wolverine-like ability to withstand injury. This is like making a Superman movie that requires Superman to use a car and not fly. The Spirit is a great character who sadly will not see the proper exposure he deserves because of a shitty movie made by a man with very little creative horizons, a one-trick pony who cannot get beyond "Sin City." Please, go and read these comics. Those of you who laugh at traditional superheroes and comic books in general will be pleasantly surprised, entertained, and then disgusted with this film.
 
As a non-comic book reader, but one who absolutely loved both the 300 and Sin City films, I have to say that honestly, this film looks just awful based on the trailer. I'll definitely be taking a pass.
 
I personally can't stand this movie's style.

It looks so much like Sin city ( even the poster) that I bet casual movie goers may think it's been re-released.
 
I personally can't stand this movie's style.

It looks so much like Sin city ( even the poster) that I bet casual movie goers may think it's been re-released.

From the trailer it looks like a cheap knock-off of Sin City - as if they thought Sin City was good because of the b&w look and virtual sets rather than because of story/script/direction/acting etc
 
Some colleagues of mine and I were discussing this at work this week.

Promoting The Spirit as a comic book film makes zero sense; the general public has no idea who The Spirit is or even that it was a comic. Frank Miller turning it into Sin City 1 1/2 made a fair bit of sense; the visual style is something the audience would understand, promoting it as "The new film by the creator of Sin City and 300" would have some draw, and it could get people interested in ways that promoting it as "the new comic book film" would not.

Of course, the stench the film is giving off is going to turn anyone away, not just the people who know about The Spirit as a comics character. I'm thinking this could turn into a Uwe Boll-scale disaster. *shrug*
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top