• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Gift-giving (during the holidays and in general)

Gryffindorian

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Holidays? Bah humbug!

I was just reading an article on CNN.com that supported the benefits of giving, and so the old saying goes: It's better to give than to receive.

Does science agree it’s better to give than receive? A doctor explains | CNN https://share.google/iknkHjeAgNBOg2prp

The question: Is it really? It's the time of the year when it's a pretty common practice (or even a tradition) for many of us to give holiday presents to the ones we love, or those we care about and appreciate.

As someone who has both given and received gifts, I feel a great deal of satisfaction from gifting, especially when I want to acknowledge or show my appreciation for someone and don't expect anything in return. So it's true that when you give from the heart, giving feels good and becomes meaningful.

I'll be honest when I say holiday gifting has been a source of stress and anxiety too, and perhaps others can relate to this experience. This is when giving comes with pressure and guilt, as has been the case with me in the past. As I get older, I've gotten better and set boundaries by reminding myself that giving Christmas presents is not and shouldn't be obligatory, but still, it can't be helped sometimes. That's just human nature. My nature.

Gift-giving can also backfire when expectations are set high. An example is when you expect the other person to reciprocate, but this is hardly an issue for couples, friends, and family when giving is a given. 😉

To quote Dr. Leanna Wen, "Giving can be good for health, but only when it is done thoughtfully and within one’s means."

What say you? What are your thoughts on holiday gifting?
 
It is not something that I enjoy. I don't need or want more "stuff" at my advanced age. My family usually plans to only do Christmas gifts for the youngsters.
 
The problem I have is now that I'm an adult and have my own money, I can buy what I want whenever I want. So I have nothing left that I want by Christmas, so I just ask for coupons
 
From a giver's perspective, and this is just me, I've found it unappealing when the other person doesn't acknowledge what I gave them. It doesn't have to be a long-winded thank you, but a simple "The coffee mug is nice" would suffice. I remember posting on here many years ago that I found it off-putting when others didn't appreciate what I had done for or given to them, and these sentiments still ring true to me.
 
Well, yes. It's rather poor manners to not even acknowledge a gift. Even a basic ," Got the mug. Thanks!" is enough to satisfy the most minimum standards of basic etiquette.

Complete silence on all channels leads the giver to imagine the person really didn't like, was insulted or maybe the person never received it at all.
 
So for quite a while now my family only does presents for the grandkids, and there's only four of them so I'll set a limit of like $25. Last few years I've taken my older sister's three kids shopping and let them pick what they want. One girl had a birthday in November and one in January so I just doubled their limit.
So like I said we don't normally do presents for the adults but this year I did and that only worked out because all year I was checking out things in like op shops or other random places and buying things with the idea to store them for either a birthday or christmas. Sometimes I would see things I wanted to buy for myself but couldn't justify the idea of spending money on something that i wasn't sure I would use, like this Simpsons Mr Sparkle smoothie cup because I'm not a collector really, but I know my brother-in-law is so I got it for him instead (I actually got it for him in 2024 with the intention to give it to him for his birthday August 2025 but then forgot about it!) That way it's not "What should I get this person?" and more "I think this person would like this." And I got one for everyone but my mum and told her straight up and she was like "yeah of course that's fine."
For me my family know I would much rather have some kind of gift made or something I could use. My sister got me a The Big Issue calendar, and it helped out some dude selling it and I've never had a calendar so it was great to get one.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top