Peck is the best thing to happen Spock since genesis
Favourite DSC Story arc
- Thread starter FederationHistorian
- Start date
Peck is the Best Spock since Quinto
Much better than Quinto but thats more to do with the poor writing behind Quintos Spock
I prefer Quinto.
My favorite arc was the Mirror Universe and then the Federation-Klingon War. I thought the first season arcs were stronger than the second season's.
When it comes to Quinto vs. Peck, I liked Quinto quite a bit. Peck was adequate but I didn't go crazy over his performance. I did think Quinto's Spock was a little too emotional, but then again, Abrams was all about pushing emotion and action, so I gave him the benefit of the doubt there.
When it comes to Burnham I still wish she had been the adopted daughter of Soval or T'Pol. She could still have the Vulcan upbringing, still be tied to a Trek legend (albeit one not as well known or heralded as Spock or Sarek), and avoiding all the headaches and heartburn over Burnham never being mentioned before, etc. Soval and T'Pol's futures were blank slates, and it gave the DISCO creators a lot of room to play around in. Soval or T'Pol being on DISCO also would've honored the tradition of handing the baton that we've had from Admiral McCoy on "Encounter at Farpoint" to Cochrane in "Broken Bow" and arguably Prime Spock in Star Trek 2009.
When it comes to Quinto vs. Peck, I liked Quinto quite a bit. Peck was adequate but I didn't go crazy over his performance. I did think Quinto's Spock was a little too emotional, but then again, Abrams was all about pushing emotion and action, so I gave him the benefit of the doubt there.
When it comes to Burnham I still wish she had been the adopted daughter of Soval or T'Pol. She could still have the Vulcan upbringing, still be tied to a Trek legend (albeit one not as well known or heralded as Spock or Sarek), and avoiding all the headaches and heartburn over Burnham never being mentioned before, etc. Soval and T'Pol's futures were blank slates, and it gave the DISCO creators a lot of room to play around in. Soval or T'Pol being on DISCO also would've honored the tradition of handing the baton that we've had from Admiral McCoy on "Encounter at Farpoint" to Cochrane in "Broken Bow" and arguably Prime Spock in Star Trek 2009.
You know I half expected Burnham to be the estranged daughter of T'Pol or someone from Enterprise
Mirror Universe, Red Angel & Sarek Family Drama
When S3 is over, I will add those arcs to the poll too.
When S3 is over, I will add those arcs to the poll too.
Similar threads
