I assumed all Hannahs became Hannah Bananas.Hannah Banana? Sounds like the latest Disney teen heroine. And Hannalina Ballerina sounds like a children's song.. . . Hanny, Hannah Banana, Hannah Banana Baneena Banoo, Hannimal, Hannalina Ballerina, Nanna, Nanners, Nanny, Nanny Goat, Goatie, Goat(ie) Girl, Bethy, Bethy-lou....

I'm actually surprised at people having only a few nicknames, or none at all; they're just so ubiquitous for us. I don't think anyone in my immediate family has fewer than 5 or 6 nicknames, including the pets! The beagle we got from a rescue when I was a teenager was already named Harley, he now answers to that along with, Bean, Beanie, Bugle Boy, Beagsly, Smeagol (we're nerds and it sounds ike Beagle), Schmee...
I never even knew my great grandmother's name was Olga until she died; I'd always called her G.G.
I like my nicknames, and my family's. I think they're fun, they're often creative or silly, and remind me of happy times. My most unflattering one -- even more so than Goat Girl -- is "Buffalo Boobs," which has nothing to do with my breast size (and was a continuing joke as I am by far the smallest-chested woman in the family), but came from the time my girl scout troupe drove through Northwest Trek and a buffalo stuck its head in the car and drooled on my chest!