• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

EMH Mark XI ?

I would use the word "tool" as opposed to "servant". I also imagine that most of the holos onboard the Galen wouldn't be as advanced mentally as the Doc is...

True. :) Yes, you're right, "tool" is probably a far more accurate word. But I suppose if the Gorn see holograms programmed to mindlessly serve and obey the Federation being given Gorn bodies...at least some of them might hiss in protest. They might not care who made them or how advanced they are- they might just see a Federation tool being given the shape of a Gorn.
 
I don't understand why the idea of emergency holograms wasn't expanded to include other vital areas besides medicine. Voyager lost her chief engineer. Why aren't there Emergency Engineering Holograms?
Well, a lot of Engineering emergencies involve things like radiation that interfere with holograms. That's the in-universe answer.

The out-of-universe answer is that the EMH was a problematic idea to begin with. As is, it opens up new areas of tech, new possibilites, that create a lot of problems from a storytelling point of view. People start asking questions just like yours: if holograms could be used to do (Job X), why would you use humans? Since holograms can be as strong as desired, and made immune to weapons fire, why not use them for all security needs? While the Doctor's mobile emitter was future-tech, couldn't Starfleet build one that was roughly man-sized? After all, Barclay built a device to contain the entire Moriarty and present him with a simulated world that he could hold in his hand, so the program for the Doctor can't take up all that much space.
Which makes episodes like Message In A Bottle suddenly seem stupid: it wouldn't have hurt the episode one bit to have a copy of the Doctor be what the Prometheus received, and what they sent back, but instead they have it somehow be the only copy of the Doctor, so Voyager has no doctor until he gets back. Because even the writers realized that if you could make infinite copies of him, then he is less special and unique. If he gets killed, you can always replace him with a copy from last week.

Sorry, I got a bit ranty there.
 
Last edited:
Rant update:
The mobile emitter highlighted one of the biggest problems with the EMH as a character.
See, as soon as they had a mobile emitter for him, people started to notice that, if the mobile emitter has enough memory to hold his program, and the sickbay holosuite has enough memory to hold his program, there is no reason at all why he can't be in both places at once.
And there really isn't a reason why he couldn't do that: two different Doctors. They'd be individuals: there is no reason why one would know something that was happening to the other, but they could merge their memories periodically to keep up-to-date.

Once you've realized that, and how little physical space the amount of memory required to hold the Doctor represents, you realize that there could probably be 2 Doctors simultaneously in sickbay. The Doctor doesn't need an assistant: he can be his assistant. And his own Nurse. He can work 3 shifts and still go hang out on the holodeck.
Oi! The holodeck! Even if the sickbay holosuite has a sharp limit on how many characters it can hold in memory, the holodeck can do a handful at once. Granted, at any given time some of the "people" in Fair Haven were likely just moving images, but like a dozen of them at once were real, interactive fully-realized holoimages. So the Doctor could use a holodeck as a small hospital, with a Dozen doctors who were all Doctors.

A bit expensive from the effects-budget end of things, but a million laughs. :) Think of it: a recurring gag where, while one person is being examined by the Doctor in sickbay, another Doctor walks by carrying a tray, and they talk briefly.

The Doctor is a computer program. Like Moriarty, he is an apparently sentient computer program, but still just a program. He can be "cloned" by copying his program into any system with enough memory to hold it: if it can run the program, so much the better. As such, he is pretty much immune to permanent death, and only able to manefest in the physical world if there are holoemitters.

I personally like the idea that the holoemitters in sickbay are special: that the Doctor's ability to function as a doctor is tied to the ability of those special emitters to create more sensitive force fields (or whatever), and that when visiting the holodeck the Doctor loses much of his sense of touch, for example. But still, the guy's unique quality is his very lack of uniqueness. :)
 
^I took the Doctor in a similar direction in Myriad Universes: Places of Exile. And the Mark IX "Haley" EMH does have the ability to operate multiple bodies at once in large-scale emergencies, as seen in Greater Than the Sum, but it places a greater strain on computer resources.
 
It might also go back to Cethente's observations in "Over a Torrent Sea" --would you really want an exact duplicate of yourself running around to potentially cause problems (both practical, ethical, and philosophical) down the road? There may well be some sort of hardwired copy-protection at play.

(I like to think tha Vic Fontaine started his existence as a pirated copy of the EMH, which was then heavily customized by Julian's enigmatic "friend.")

I also imagine that most of the holos onboard the Galen wouldn't be as advanced mentally as the Doc is...
But who is, really?
[/DOCTOR]
 
(I like to think tha Vic Fontaine started his existence as a pirated copy of the EMH, which was then heavily customized by Julian's enigmatic "friend.")

I believe that friend's name was Felix. If I remember correctly that is...
 
I wonder if there is going to be a USS Enlightment crewed by holographic recreations of Starfleet's finest throughout history? :rommie:
 
I really hope that Vic Fontaine isn't forgotten. Anytime a Hologram Sentience/Rights story gets thrown around from now onward, he should at least be mentioned if not thought about outright. The Doctor & Vic really should meet and I'd love to read that scene.
 
I really hope that Vic Fontaine isn't forgotten. Anytime a Hologram Sentience/Rights story gets thrown around from now onward, he should at least be mentioned if not thought about outright. The Doctor & Vic really should meet and I'd love to read that scene.

I'd love to hear the song they'd sing!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top