• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Earth: Final Conflict - 1st time watch thread

Friendly Fire

Lili's loyalty is put to the test when Captain Paul Chandler resurfaces and plans to use her stolen shuttle as a weapon against the Taelons, by flying it into the Taelon Embassy. But when Sandoval begins a search to recover the craft for Zo'or, the Resistance must find Chandler first.

I liked seeing Paul Chandler again and his storyline continued. This is one of the story-lines from season 2 that I wanted to see a continuation of and this episode didn't disappoint.

I like that the Resistance has different attitudes and feelings of how far they should go when resisting the Taelons. Obviously, Liam has a line in the sand where he doesn't want any collateral damage when battling the Taelons. Paul Chandler though has a differing viewpoint. Interestingly, it looks like Lili may agree with Paul more than with Liam's point of view.

The twist ending with the Taelon embassy transforming into a fortress was well done. I truly thought for a second that Chandler would be successful even though Da'an would have been killed in the blast. The fact that all the Taelon embassies are fortresses opens a new wrinkle in the Resistance's plans. I also like the very end with Doors using this as another opportunity to get one up on Thompson and pointing more suspicion upon the Taelons.

RATING: 4/5
 
Volunteers

The Resistance looks into the Taelon Volunteers programme, when they believe that volunteers are being trained as soldiers for war against the Jaridians...and for taking over Earth. Liam sends a resistance member undercover to infiltrate the Volunteers Crops while he tries to win the trust of a young woman they freed from the programme.

I'm beginning to sound like a broken record lately, but this season has become consistently good. This episode is actually my favourite episode of season 2 (so far).

Yes, once again we have Zo'or manipulating one of Da'an's projects. The volunteers, sometimes seen on the mothership, are being sent to a different galaxy to battle an unknown enemy (I guess this is the Jaridians? or someone else?)

At first I thought the volunteer program would be just like the one in V (the new one), but the twist with the volunteers being an army for the Taelons was surprising.

Another great scene has Liam and Amanda in the very long hallway with all of the dead bodies. Zo'or is evil.

I also liked seeing Liam acting like the leader of the Resistance when he sent Julia undercover into the volunteer program.

RATING: 4.5/5
 
Personally, I find the second season a bit underrated. I'll admit, the first half of the year was very wobbly as they were trying to re-find their footing. But the back-half was fairly strong.
 
Season 2 is pretty damn good on your first time through, but I find it doesn't really hold up on repeated viewings. Which is hardly relevant.

Anyway the Volunteers develop into one of EFC's more interesting ideas and it's kind of surprising how prominent they'll become just by the season 2's finale.
 
Bliss

A desperate search begins to find Ma'el's lab in Ireland, when Lili, and several thousand others, become infected by a deadly virus known only as 'Bliss', which originated from Strandhill. However, when the Taelons deny all knowledge of the substance, the question remains: where did it come from?

I certainly wasn't expecting this episode to be any good. Virus storylines usually make up some of the worst episodes in sci-fi, so I was surprised by the end of the episode that I actually kind of liked it.

The plot with the virus was nothing special, but I did like seeing Strandhill again and revisiting the Ma'el storyline. I did find it funny how they specifically cast another redhead for the lead scientist in Strandhill but didn't even bother making her Irish (or speak in an irish accent). The Taelonists is an interesting idea, but I felt their presence in this episode was due to plot and not because there's anything big picture planned for them.

There were 2 things that elevated this episode above middling for me. They were the scenes between Lili/Augur and the scenes between Liam/Sandoval. I can't remember a prior episode, at least this season, where Lili and Augur had emotional character scenes together. Usually one is spouting some technobabble while the other get ticked off at Augur's avatar. However, this episode featured an entire subplot dealing with Augur weaning Lili off the drug. These scenes were wonderfully acted by both actors.

Also this season we have frequently seen Liam, sometimes with Lili, in competition with Sandoval. They always have to get to the place before Sandoval, or they have to undermine Sandoval somehow. Finally, I think for the first time this season that didn't take place in an alternate dimension, Liam and Sandoval are working together. It brought back memories of season 1 and the relationship between Sandoval and Boone who, despite killing each others' wives (or so it seemed), were friendly with each other (maybe friend is a bit too much... they put up with each other let's say). Whereas the relationship between Sandoval and Liam has always been adversarial. So it was nice to finally see the two of them working together.

RATING: 3/5
 
Bliss esentially was pointless filler. It's entertaining for what it is, but it's hardly anyting pivotal to the series.

I did find it funny how they specifically cast another redhead for the lead scientist in Strandhill but didn't even bother making her Irish (or speak in an irish accent).

Fortunately, with the presence of interdimensional technology she didn't have to be Irish and they can get away with her not having an accent.
 
Bliss was the last episode I remember liking, and all I really remember now is how good the Lili/Augur scenes were, and how they almost seemed like themselves again.
 
Hijacked

When a reporter comes aboard the Mothership, Liam comes under suspicion as a saboteur and member of the Resistance when the ship is hijacked and sets off on a course for the Jaridian homeworld. Things become more complicated when the reporter videotapes Liam using his shaquarava.

This is a tough episode for me to review. On one hand, there is some pretty good action sequences and more Jaridian stuff. On the other hand, I could completely skip this episode and not miss anything.

I think part of the problem with this episode is how easy everything is resolved. Liam is proven not to be the saboteur because of the video the reporter recorded. Actually, the reporter character as a whole felt like a plot device who's only purpose in the episode was to prove Liam's innocence. With that said, I did like the little twist that the Liam in the video was not the replicant but was actually the real Liam downloading the latest Taelon passwords for Augur.

I didn't really like the technobabble solution at the end with how they got out of dead space. The action was great, but it felt way too easy.

RATING: 2.5/5
 
Yeah, another filler, though decent as space fare. It is kind of interesting when a "down to Earth" type show like this attempts to do space opera.
 
Hijacked? Did they change the title for DVD? When it originally aired, it was "Highjacked" (yeah, it kind of reflected the 'quality' of the show. Of course, DS9 had a typo in one of its episode titles on original airing).
 
Hijacked? Did they change the title for DVD? When it originally aired, it was "Highjacked" (yeah, it kind of reflected the 'quality' of the show. Of course, DS9 had a typo in one of its episode titles on original airing).

I think it said Hijacked, but maybe not. I'll try to remember to check it next time I watch an episode.


Defector

As Da'an begins an ancient Taelon ritual of self-renewal, a Taelon renegade crash lands on Earth hoping to defect and join the Resistance. As Sandoval begins a search for the Taelon, Liam must learn to trust Be'lie when he learns that it was Da'an who designed the Taelon plan for galactic domination.

This episode is excellent.

First of all, the revelation that there is a Taelon underground opposed to the Synod is inspired. I really like the idea that there are a lot of Taelons opposed to the Taelon policy being carried out. Also the fact that there are many Taelon occupied worlds and Earth is just one of them is interesting.

Then there's the twist that Da'an may be more involved in the Taelon aggression than he seemed to be. Bel'lie's statement that Da'an is the architect of the Taelons' strategy threw me for a loop. The ambiguous ending with Liam saving Da'an from the Atavus-formed Bel'lie is also interesting as Da'an was not very convincing with his answers to Liam's questioning. He basically said he's not the Taelon he once was. Is Da'an truly sympathetic to the Resistance or is he just manipulating them to serve his purpose?

Smaller things I liked about this episode was the two kids who hid Bel'lie as well as the glimpse we got into Taelon culture and their homeworld. This episode deserves my first perfect score of season 2.

RATING: 5/5
 
Heroes & Heartbreak

When Augur is recruited to fix the bugs in a mysterious project code named 'Forge', involving state-of-the-art technology, he soon discovers he is in way of his head. The project is actually a Taelon one to turn Earth into the largest cannon ever conceived, capable of wiping out the Jaridians.

The ending kind of ruined this episode for me. Maybe ruined is too harsh a term, but it was disappointing. The fact that there was a wormhole open for the Jaridians to come to Earth was a great idea and I thought that this would obviously come into play in the season finale.

However, seconds later upon learning that a Jaridian planet destroyer was in the wormhole, I knew that the wormhole would somehow be closed. Earth is not going to be destroyed, at least not in the 2nd season (and especially not in a season finale). All of the statements by Da'an about how his and Liam's attempt would be a suicide mission did nothing to dissuade my opinion. Da'an and Liam were not going to be killed off in this episode. Maybe a couple of episodes from now they will be, but not this one. So what happens? Liam and Da'an get lucky and close the wormhole, even though it was next to impossible to do.

Surprisingly enough, despite the disappointing ending, I thought this was a strong episode. How can you go wrong with an Augur-centric episode? Sure, his relationship with his boss happened a bit too fast, but that's episodic television for you. The Forge project, basically it turns the Earth into a huge weapon is an interesting idea.

Also, this episode continues the is Da'an evil storyline that started up again last episode (there hasn't been too much ambivalence with the character of Da'an this season as he has seemed to be on the side of the Resistance until last episode). He wasn't too forthcoming with information when Liam was questioning him about the Forge project, and I loved his sharp response to Liam.

Overall, a good episode hampered by a by-the-book ending.

RATING: 3.5/5
 
Future episodes really start showing that there is a dark side to Da'an, though he never becomes as villainous as Zo'or.
 
Message In A Bottle

As a Jaridian probe crash lands on Earth, Liam, Augur and Julia are taken prisoner by an advanced commando unit who have been working to remove the Taelons by force since the day they arrived. But the situation takes an unexpected turn when they discover that the one leading the troops is the real Liam Kincaid.

What's the point of this episode? When BorgAugur is telling real Augur that the Jaridians want to be allies with the Resistance and here's some information on how to build a communication array to talk to the Jaridians, I had a sinking feeling that Sandoval and his troops would burst in and interrupt the transfer process. Unfortunately I was correct. What's the point of introducing a cool new plot development but have it reset to square one at the end of the episode?

There are things in this episode I liked. I loved the scene between Lili and Da'an where Da'an had to betray his own people to help the Resistance.

I also liked meeting the real Liam Kincaid. I had forgotten that Augur based Liam's identity on a real person, so I liked seeing this plot thread continued. Also interesting is the real Liam's special forces unit and their alliance with the Resistance. Of course, if the real Liam Kincaid never shows up again, then this plot is basically a waste of time too.

RATING: 2/5
 
What's the point of introducing a cool new plot development but have it reset to square one at the end of the episode?

To be fair, this happens in a lot of shows. Yes, I'm sure someone can provide examples of shows where it doesn't happen, but that's not the point. Yes, it's annoying when it happens, but kind of understandable in the sense they don't want to shake things up too seriously.

But yeah, this episode is basically more filler. Real Liam is never heard from again, though the actor returns in a recurring role playing a character so similar you wonder why they didn't just make him the real Liam. Meanwhile the Jaridian storyline develops in a completely different way than this episode would have you think.

I did like the idea of a secret military unit that had gone underground when the Taelons arrived in the event the Taelon turned out to not be good guys. It's an interesting idea that could have developed into a pretty good storyline, but is sadly swept aside.
 
Crossfire

In the run-up to the Presidential elections, the Resistance works to uncover a Taelon plot to have Doors assassinated, ensuring that President Thompson, a Taelon supporter, stays in power, giving Zo'or unlimited power.


Wow. This is my favourite episode of the entire series. I can't believe how good everything came together.

The whole assassination plot was amazing. I was certain that Doors would be the one assassinated so you can imagine my surprise when Thompson ended up being the victim. The surviving victim I might add, since this was an elaborate plan by Zo'or to keep Thompson as President. I think the easiest way for me to review this episode is to give a recap and give my thoughts along the way.

It all begins when a Taelon warrior (genetically engineered human to fight Jaridians), one of the season 2 plot threads, acts suspicious at a Jonathan Doors press conference and sets the whole plot into motion. After doing some detective work, the Resistance realizes that this Taelon warrior has been stalking Doors for a while. Instead of confronting Zo'or with this evidence, Liam decides to wait until after the election. After all, Doors has built quite the lead in the polls, there is no way he is going to lose.

Meanwhile, Da'an is feeling pretty good about himself right now with Doors about to become President and the Resistance about to be officially sanctioned. Zo'or will surely be removed as leader of the Synod now.

Liam warns Jonathan Doors about the possible threat coming from the Taelons but Jonathan takes the threat lightly. Joshua on the other hand increases his father's security. He's just worried about his father's safety. After all, if Doors was going to be assassinated it would be tonight at the final Presidential debate.

Augur and Julia manage to track down the arms dealer who sold the weapon to the Taelon warrior. After being interrupted by more Taelon warriors, Augur and Julia manage to escape with the weapon specs and discover that the Taelon warriors are using weapons that are undetectable by the security scans used at presidential functions.

It's at this point that Liam begins to suspect that the Resistance is being set up and will take the blame if Doors is assassinated. Therefore he doesn't allow any Resistance members to be present at the debate acting as extra security for Doors. Julia disagrees with him and goes to Joshua behind Liam's back, perfectly in character by the way as Julia has been shown to be impulsive, and offers her Resistance cell as extra security. Joshua accepts, after all he's just worried about his father's safety.

That night at the debate Liam runs into Julia and is furious that she and the rest of her cell are there and armed. Of course, he can't remove them without drawing attention so he leaves them to look around. Liam runs into 3 suspicious men all fiddling with a video camera. When he asks to see their identification he notices the implants they have (meaning they are Taelon warriors). He tries to subdue all 3 by himself, but 1 of the warriors gets away. He radios Julia to track down the Taelon warrior that got away while he deals with the other 2. While going after the warrior, Julia and her Resistance cell are arrested by the secret service.

During all of this, the real assassin takes aim and fires at, not Doors, but President Thompson. Sandoval reacts by firing his skrill at the assassin and dissolving him.

Because of the assassination attempt against Thompson, and with Julia and her Resistance cell arrested for carrying out the assassination attempt, Thompson takes a lead in the polls. And yes, despite taking two shots (in the shoulder), Thompson will recover.

Then in what is my favourite scene of the entire episode, Joshua Doors holds a press conference. In it he says that his father was the architect of the plot to assassinate President Thompson and the secret service has a warrant for his arrest. From the beginning of this Jonathan Doors running for President subplot, I was a little confused by Joshua Doors' relationship with his father. In season 1, Joshua was adversarial with his father to say the least. Then in season 2 he supports his father's run for presidency and in effect is his Chief of Staff? I chalked the change in characterization up as just another change for season 2. But this explanation, that Joshua had planned this outcome from the beginning is awesome and is perfectly in character. Of course, it's a bit unbelievable that his plan worked so well given all of the things that could have gone wrong, but I'll look past that since the twist is perfect.

But no, that's not the end. Now re-elected as President, Thompson declares a state of emergency and imposes martial law until the Resistance is completely destroyed. This scene is also awesome, if only for the great visual of the Taelon ships hovering down behind Thompson. And who are tasked to round up the members of the Resistance? The Volunteers of course.

Liam is now in hiding with Augur and Jonathan Doors when he is contacted by Lili. She is in the engine room (I think) of the Taelon mothership and wants to overload the power supply, destroying the ship and killing everyone onboard including herself. Liam, of course, doesn't want to sacrifice innocent lives so he orders her not to do it. This reminded me of the episode "Friendly Fire" where Lili and Liam had disagreements of how far they should take the fight to the Taelons. The apartment where Liam, Augur, and Doors are hiding out is attacked by the Volunteers and Lili loses contact. She takes matters into her own hands and starts the overload.

Now that is a season finale.

RATING: 5/5


Now that I've finished season 2, I can see why some people don't like it as much as season 1 as it does feel like a different show and the first chunk of episodes are not the greatest, but about a quarter into the season it turns a corner and starts some interesting arcs. Overall, in my opinion, I prefer season 1 but season 2 was almost as good. I look forward to season 3 and I'm kind of interested to see if the style of the show will change again and also if any more characters will be killed off (it's a Tribune show after all). With the way the season finale ended, the fates of all the main characters are up in the air.
 
I know most of you have jobs or lovers, and some of you might even have both, but how come it's taking y'all so long to watch this clusterfuck?

Earlier this year, I got though seasons 1 through 4 in 3 days, took a 6 month break because my mind hurt, and then polished off season 5 in a week.

Maybe some of you might sleep more than 3 hours a night?

Oh.

Vin Flores was in Lost Girl this week super pissed that a necromancer had stolen his boyfriends corpse..

He's looking better now that all his hair has fallen out.

That transitional balding look is always a bit off compared with the final stages of the metamorphosis.
 
Season 3 has some cast changes, and some minor format changes. Nothing quite so drastic as the changes from season 1 to 2, and indeed season 3 feels more like an organic continuation to season 2 than 2 felt to 1. But the core story is still there. It's still Taelons with a shandy agenda for humanity and their enemies the Jaridians. And I don't think it's too much of a spoiler to reveal that the Resistance continues on in some manner.
 
Crackdown

Lili is captured by the Taelons and held prisoner for attempting to destroy the Mothership, while Liam and Augur escape the Volunteers with a little help from an unidentified woman. As they work to identify her and uncover the true assailant of President Thompson, Doors is forced to re-negotiate his relationship with the Taelons.

Most of the cliffhangers from the previous episode are resolved and reset, but there are also some interesting plot developments.

Lili gets caught trying to blow up the mothership and is killed because Taelon justice includes the death penalty. However, as the last scene in the episode shows, she is not actually dead. What is the Taelons' plans for her? Or maybe it's Sandoval acting on his own? Anyway, she's not in the main credits anymore, which have changed again, so I'm guessing she's not in every episode this season.

Replacing her in the main credits is Jayne Heitmeyer as Renee Palmer, who is the CEO (I think) of Doors International. She also seems to be just as computer-savvy as Augur. She also posed as a Volunteer at the beginning and saved Liam and Augur, but couldn't keep Doors from getting captured.

Doors on the mothership is met by Zo'or, where in a meeting taking place offscreen, Doors completely changes his mind about the Taelons and announces an alliance between the Taelons and Doors International. Obviously, I don't think Doors changed his mind about the Taelons, but I wonder what Zo'or threatened him with to get him to agree to this alliance.

I liked the callback to season 1 when Augur discovers that the real assassin was Judson Corr, the murderer of William Boone's wife (and the person Sandoval hires to do his dirty work). Liam presents the evidence to President Thompson, who in an interesting reversal lifts the national state of emergency and frees all of the Resistance members who have been arrested.

Although I'm a bit disappointed that there is not going to be at least a few episodes featuring the state of emergency and the Resistance being hunted, I like that it seems Thompson and Doors have switched sides. Thompson, now having been elected and probably not liking how he was treated by the Taelons in the run up to the election, is now going against the plans they have for him. Doors, on the other hand, is allied with the Taelons and is working with them. A complete reversal of season 2.

RATING: 4/5
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top