I hope she finds happiness... I hope I'm in the picture. I would love to get back together at Christmas time. If it doesn't happen then, it would probably never happen.
And I would love the USC cheerleaders to bring me breakfast in bed.
Unless she changes what sounds like one of her core values, didn't you say that wouldn't be possible? That she told you the difference was insurmountable?
Would you compromise one of your core values to be with her? If you did, could you live with yourself?
Best advice, put her on "ignore" for a while - don't go to her facebook or other pages, archive her emails on a flash drive or CD, put any cards or letters from her in storage and try to move on without her.
Having those reminders will, for a while, lead you to believe that you can get back together if you're just there for her.
I said it before, but I think the religion issue was an excuse. You may never know what the true issue is and it doesn't matter.
Is this your first big dumping?