• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Poll Dryson Array vs. Dyson Sphere

Is a Dryson Array a better choice in harvesting and converting energy into electricity?

  • Yes - Explain answer

    Votes: 3 50.0%
  • No - Explain your answer

    Votes: 3 50.0%

  • Total voters
    6
I think he's trying to go down to posterity...

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
No if you read the beginning of the post this is a discussion about a Dryson TEG Array that converts heat from the Red Spot on Jupiter compared to a Dyson Swarm harvesting solar energy from the Sun. Two completely different processes and facilities.
 
More energy can be harvested at the sun, you are correct, but the safety hazards with harvesting the storm spots on a Gas Giant are less. A sun attracts everything in the solar system because it is the largest source of gravity. A Gas Giant is simply in the way of those objects being pulled to the sun.

If your engineering is sufficiently advanced to create mega-structures, you've already solved the safety issues.
 
If your engineering is sufficiently advanced to create mega-structures, you've already solved the safety issues.

Sounds like famous last words. Earthmen taught the Kzin not to laugh at their primitive starship.
 
But Capt. John Carter can get all the way to Mars through sheer willpower—because he's John Carter and you're not.
 
Besides there would not be any purpose to a Dyson Swarm as you could not build a community around it like you could build a community around a Dryson TEG Array. Why would humans build something around the sun that a community could not build close to and then branch out from there?

Early humans lived around water holes and were nomadic. Once they began to evolve they used trees and rocks and the mud around the water hole to promote their growth. Where are the trees and rocks and mud close to the sun that the cave man does not have to fear the T-rex at?
 
Last edited:
Ancient man never knew the t-rex, it having died out millions of years earlier.

But didn't you know? The reason the famous illustration showing hominid evolution depicts our ancient ancestors hunched over is because of the tunnels they had to live in to avoid the dinosaurs! It's in The World According to Dryson. Pick up your copy today.
 
But didn't you know? The reason the famous illustration showing hominid evolution depicts our ancient ancestors hunched over is because of the tunnels they had to live in to avoid the dinosaurs! It's in The World According to Dryson. Pick up your copy today.
Or maybe the reason why our ancient ancestors were hunched over is based on the Baby Syndrome where over millions of years humans evolved from a hunched over baby position to a full grown walking adult.

Explain it for Metryq.

The other issue with a Dyson Swarm not be viable is that that ships coming and going from the array would have to deal with increased radiation as they approached the sun. Heat shields the size of the one seen on the Icarus II from the movie Sunshine for reference.
 
You didn't say anything about "Baby Syndrome" in this post.

So, you're saying ships in a Dyson swarm would be zapped like a bug light from the space-time radiation?
 
If your engineering is sufficiently advanced to create mega-structures, you've already solved the safety issues.

Which is the main reason that an advanced space faring society would never build a large energy harvesting structure around their sun. There are to many variables that could go wrong such as large solar flares destroying the Dyson Swarm or a section of it at least that would effect the rest of the Swarm and the civilization that depended on it.
 
Before you can build a Dyson Sphere, you would have already reached the Singularity, and you have evolved to machine life. We are talking Type 2 and 3 Civilizations.
 
Before you can build a Dyson Sphere, you would have already reached the Singularity, and you have evolved to machine life. We are talking Type 2 and 3 Civilizations.

If you are a Type 2 or 3 civilization and have reached the Singularity I think that such a civilization would have found a way to use the Singularity to generate electrical power rendering a Dyson Swarm rather obsolete.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top