Could Star Trek be Re-rebooted?

[Ray Hardgrit]

Define "good" Star Trek?


Many would put City on the Edge of Forever or Best of Both Worlds as good. I'd say they are ok, at best.

Appealing to many people sounds like a good start and if the worst that people have to say about an episode is 'it was okay, at best' then no one's being pissed off.

I would define good Star Trek as being Balance of Terror, Journey to Babel and The Trouble with Tribbles.

The Measure of a Man, Yesterday's Enterprise and Darmok.
Duet, The Way of the Warrior and The Siege of AR-558.
Deadlock, Scorpion and Timeless.
Twilight, Similitude and In a Mirror, Darkly.
What's Past is Prologue, If Memory Serves and Species Ten-C.
Calypso, The Escape Artist and The Trouble with Edward.
Remembrance, Nepenthe and Surrender.
Crisis Point, First First Contact and Reflections.
Kobayashi, Mindwalk and Ouroboros.
Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow, Those Old Scientists and Under the Cloak of War.
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, First Contact and Star Trek '09.

I don't think opinion is that wildly varied on what episodes people like, and 'good Trek episode' is not a particularly narrow target to hit either. The trick is to respect the show and characters, and tell a great story that would appeal to people watching the show.

 

[fireproof78]

The trick is to respect the show and characters, and tell a great story that would appeal to people watching the show.

Define respect.

Does "Spock's Brain" respect the characters? Nope.

How about in TNG were the Enterprise is routinely boarded or conquered by inferior opponents? Is that respectful?

I think respect is a terrible word at this stage I'm my life because it's often used as a measuring stick to tell someone how they have failed.

 

[Firebird]

They don't have to please everyone, just people who like good Star Trek episodes, or would like them if they were introduced to the series as a new viewer.

"Good Star Trek" is so nebulous that it's a useless metric for anyone to measure.

And trying to chase the dragon of people who aren't already fans is trying to please everyone.

 

[Ray Hardgrit]

Define respect.

a: to consider worthy of high regard.
b: to refrain from interfering with.

It is the process of honouring something by exhibiting care, concern, or consideration.

To respect Star Trek would involve being consistent with its story continuity and design continuity, to follow on from the artistic decisions made by previous creators, to make an effort to stick to the morality and philosophy espoused by the series to a reasonable degree that takes into account social progress, and just generally make an effort to give fans something that feels respectful.

Does "Spock's Brain" respect the characters? Nope.

How about in TNG were the Enterprise is routinely boarded or conquered by inferior opponents? Is that respectful?

Oh no I'll have to take Spock's Brain and Rascals off the 'good episode' list.

And trying to chase the dragon of people who aren't already fans is trying to please everyone.

Only if they're trying to make literally everyone a fan.

 

[Phoenix219]

The USS Falcon with Anthony Ingruber as the captain and a Caitian called Meowbacca as the First Officer.

Don't know how i missed this.

Thats hilarious, and with them doing Aliens already, why not?? LOVE Ingruber..... I'll watch him doing a "Ford" ANY day. I'm still mad he wasn't cast in the Han Solo spinoff - I truly think it would have saved the movie. He's uncannily close, and I wouldn't even call it an impression. Ford approves; he literally played a young Ford on screen already in the same movie, with his blessing.

 

[fireproof78]

respect Star Trek would involve being consistent with its story continuity and design continuity, to follow on from the artistic decisions made by previous creators, to make an effort to stick to the morality and philosophy espoused by the series to a reasonable degree that takes into account social progress, and just generally make an effort to give fans something that feels respectful.

I don't think TOS did this.

And relies highly in subjective feelings that fans feel "respected."

Well, I didn't with Enterprise so guess I'll discard that.

"Good Star Trek" is so nebulous that it's a useless metric for anyone to measure.

And trying to chase the dragon of people who aren't already fans is trying to please everyone.

Indeed. It is often more of a Fan's preference metric.

 

[HotRod]

It is the process of honouring something by exhibiting care, concern, or consideration.

To respect Star Trek would involve being consistent with its story continuity and design continuity, to follow on from the artistic decisions made by previous creators, to make an effort to stick to the morality and philosophy espoused by the series to a reasonable degree that takes into account social progress, and just generally make an effort to give fans something that feels respectful.

So..... Strange New Worlds?

It really is great, isn't it?

 

[Phoenix219]

So..... Strange New Worlds?

It really is great, isn't it?

It started out great, but every single thing I hear about the new season it sounds worse and worse. That trend started last season so.... Not hopeful for where this is going.

But that's just one fans opinion.

 

[fireproof78]

This season is worse?

I guess it will never succeed...

 

[Phoenix219]

This season is worse?

I guess it will never succeed...

Well, it's already canceled. It is what it is. It really doesn't matter what it does for the next 26 episodes. Lol.

 

[fireproof78]

Well, it's already canceled. It is what it is. It really doesn't matter what it does for the next 26 episodes. Lol.

Or if we watch it.

Lol.

 

[Phoenix219]

Or if we watch it.

Lol.

Very true. That won't affect anything except our personal experiences. Completely irrelevant to the larger picture.

 

[fireproof78]

Very true. That won't affect anything except our personal experiences. Completely irrelevant to the larger picture.

Well, now we are all relieved of this burden I feel much better.